Training Through Soreness Myth Explained

The Training Through Soreness Myth Explained

The fitness world is full of conflicting advice. One camp shouts "No pain, no gain!" urging you to push through any discomfort. The other preaches a softer approach: "Listen to your body," suggesting any ache is a signal to stop. The truth, as it often does, lies somewhere in the middle. The training through soreness myth is partially true. You can and sometimes should train with mild to moderate soreness, which is a 6 out of 10 or less on a pain scale. However, training with severe soreness, a 7 out of 10 or higher, hinders recovery and dramatically increases injury risk. This simple rule helps you stay consistent without derailing your progress.

This approach works for anyone engaged in resistance training, from beginners to advanced lifters. The key is distinguishing between the dull ache of muscle soreness and the sharp signal of actual pain. Pushing through the former can be beneficial, while ignoring the latter is a recipe for a setback. Understanding this difference is what separates smart, sustainable training from reckless, short-lived effort. Before we can decide whether to train, we must first understand what we're feeling.

The Critical Difference: Muscle Soreness vs. Actual Pain

Confusing the deep, satisfying ache of Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness (DOMS) with the sharp, alarming signal of an injury is a common and dangerous mistake. They are not the same. One is a sign of adaptation; the other is a warning sign of damage. Learning to differentiate them is a non-negotiable skill for long-term progress.

DOMS feels like a generalized, dull ache in the belly of the muscle you worked. It's often tender to the touch and can create a feeling of stiffness. Think of it as a low, humming reminder of the hard work you put in. It typically appears 24 to 48 hours after your workout and affects muscles on both sides of your body-for example, both quads will be sore after a tough leg day. Crucially, this type of soreness often lessens with light movement and a good warm-up.

Pain from an injury is fundamentally different. It’s often sharp, stabbing, or shooting. It’s highly localized to a specific point, frequently near a joint or tendon. Unlike DOMS, it can appear suddenly during a specific movement and is often one-sided. If you feel a sharp twinge in your right shoulder during a press, that’s a blaring fire alarm, not a sign of a good workout. This type of pain gets worse with movement and does not subside during a warm-up. Training through this kind of pain is like ignoring a fire alarm and continuing to cook; it will only lead to a bigger disaster.

Here’s a simple breakdown:

• Sensation: Soreness is a dull ache; pain is sharp and stabbing.
• Location: Soreness is diffuse across a muscle; pain is localized to a specific point.
• Onset: Soreness peaks 24-48 hours later; pain is often immediate.
• Symmetry: Soreness is usually bilateral (both sides); pain is often unilateral (one side).

Never train through pain. If you feel a sharp, localized signal, stop immediately. For general soreness, however, the rules are different.

Why Soreness Is Not a Sign of Growth

Many people believe that extreme soreness equals a great workout. This is a misunderstanding of what causes muscle growth. Growth comes from progressive overload, which is the principle of gradually increasing the demand on your muscles over time. Soreness, or DOMS, is simply a side effect of muscle damage, especially when you introduce a new exercise, intensity, or a higher volume of work-what the body perceives as a 'novel' stimulus.

The goal is not to get sore; the goal is to get stronger and apply progressive overload. For example, if you bench-pressed 150 lbs for 8 reps last week, your goal this week is to either hit 9 reps or increase the weight to 155 lbs for 8 reps. That is measurable progress. Getting so sore from a workout that you have to skip your next session is the opposite of progress. Chasing soreness often leads people to perform sloppy reps or take too much time off between sessions, which ultimately slows down results. The most productive workouts are the ones you can recover from and repeat consistently.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

How to Decide if You Should Train Sore

Instead of guessing, you can use a simple system to make the right decision every time. This three-step method removes the emotion and helps you train effectively and safely.

Step 1. Rate your soreness on a 1-10 scale

First, assess how you feel. Be honest with yourself. A number provides a clear, objective measure to guide your decision.

• 1-3 (Mild): You barely notice it. You might only feel a slight tenderness if you press directly on the muscle. It has zero impact on your daily movement.
• 4-6 (Moderate): You are aware of the muscle ache during normal movement, like walking or sitting down, but it does not limit your range of motion. It's a noticeable reminder of your last workout but doesn't cause you to wince.
• 7-9 (Severe): Movement is uncomfortable. Your normal range of motion is restricted, and you might find yourself altering your movement patterns to avoid discomfort. Getting out of a chair is a conscious effort.
• 10 (Extreme Pain): This is beyond soreness. You are actively avoiding using the muscle group entirely. This is a major red flag that you've either overdone it significantly or potentially caused an injury.

Step 2. Follow the rule for your score

Your score from step one dictates your action. There is no ambiguity. Training with a score of 7 or higher is counterproductive because the muscle is still in a deep state of repair. Adding more stress through intense training will only compound the micro-trauma, impair motor control (increasing injury risk), and prolong the recovery process, ultimately delaying growth.

• Score 1-6: Proceed with your planned workout. Perform a thorough warm-up. For your first exercise, reduce the weight by 10-20% for the first set. If the soreness lessens or stays the same as you warm up, you can proceed with your planned weights.
• Score 7 or higher: Do not train the sore muscle group with high intensity. This is a clear signal that the muscle is not ready for more stress.

Step 3. Choose your activity based on the score

Based on the rule, you can now select the right type of activity for the day.

• Score 1-6: Perform your scheduled workout. The movement will likely help alleviate the feeling of stiffness.
• Score 7-8: Opt for active recovery. This is where you can train a completely different muscle group (e.g., train upper body if your legs are sore) or perform light, restorative work.
• Score 9-10: Take a complete rest day. Focus on sleep, nutrition, and hydration. Your body needs a full break to repair and rebuild.

Movement as Medicine: How Light Activity Speeds Up Recovery

When you're rated at a 7 or 8 on the soreness scale, the answer isn't to lie on the couch all day. The answer is active recovery, or what can be thought of as 'movement as medicine.' Light activity is one of the most effective tools for alleviating DOMS and accelerating the healing process. It works through several key mechanisms.

First, it boosts blood flow. Think of your circulatory system as a delivery and waste-removal service for your muscles. Light exercise increases blood circulation, which delivers a fresh supply of oxygen and nutrient-rich blood to the damaged muscle tissues. At the same time, it helps flush out metabolic byproducts associated with muscle damage, like creatine kinase. This enhanced exchange speeds up the repair of muscle fibers.

Second, it stimulates the lymphatic system. Unlike your cardiovascular system, which has the heart as a pump, your lymphatic system relies on muscle contractions to move fluid. This system is crucial for clearing cellular waste and managing inflammation. Gentle movement acts as that pump, helping to reduce swelling and stiffness. For example, 20-30 minutes of incline walking at 3.0 mph with a 5% grade is enough to get this system working without causing more muscle damage. Similarly, 20 minutes on a stationary bike at a low resistance (level 4 out of 10) can work wonders.

Finally, light activity can help manage the discomfort itself through a process called 'gate control theory.' Simply put, the gentle sensory input from movement can override the pain signals from soreness traveling to your brain. This, combined with the release of endorphins-your body's natural pain relievers-is why you often feel better after a light walk or stretch session.

What to Expect When You Train Smarter

When you stop chasing soreness and start managing it, you will experience more consistent progress. Your strength gains will become more predictable because you are no longer forced to take unplanned days off due to debilitating stiffness. Progress is built on consistency, not sporadic, all-out intensity.

Within the first 4-8 weeks of using this system, you should notice fewer interruptions in your training schedule. This consistency is what drives long-term results. You will find that you can train harder on the days you feel good because you allowed for proper recovery on the days you needed it. There's also a significant psychological benefit: you'll reduce the anxiety around soreness, build confidence in your ability to make smart training decisions, and foster a healthier, more intuitive relationship with your body. You're no longer a victim of how you feel; you're in control.

This method is not a magic bullet. It does not prevent all injuries or guarantee linear progress. However, it provides a logical framework for making intelligent training decisions. It shifts the focus from how you feel after one workout to what you can achieve over many months of consistent effort.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does being sore mean I had a good workout?

No. Soreness indicates novelty or muscle damage, not necessarily an effective stimulus for growth. The best indicator of a good workout is improved performance over time, known as progressive overload.

Should I stretch to reduce soreness?

Static stretching before or after a workout has shown little to no effect on reducing muscle soreness. A dynamic warm-up before training and light active recovery, such as walking or cycling, are more effective for increasing blood flow and easing stiffness.

How long should muscle soreness last?

Typical DOMS peaks 24-48 hours after a workout and should significantly decrease within 72 hours. If your soreness is severe and lasts longer than three days, you may be overtraining or under-recovering.

Is it okay to get a massage when I'm sore?

Yes, a light massage can be beneficial. It can help increase blood flow, reduce muscle tension, and alleviate the discomfort of DOMS. Avoid deep tissue massage on severely sore muscles, as it can sometimes increase inflammation and damage in the short term.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.