Should I Bulk or Cut at 20 Body Fat? The Definitive Answer

Should You Bulk or Cut at 20 Body Fat?

This is one of the most common questions in fitness, and the indecision can lead to months of spinning your wheels. For the vast majority of people with some training experience who find themselves at 20 percent body fat, the answer is clear: you should cut first. The goal is to lose between 0.5% and 1.0% of your body weight per week until you reach a leaner base of around 12-15 percent body fat. This isn't about getting shredded overnight. It's a strategic move to prime your body for building muscle far more effectively in the future.

Attempting to bulk from 20 percent body fat is a classic mistake that often leads to gaining significantly more fat than muscle. This digs a deeper hole, making your eventual cutting phase longer, harder, and more demoralizing. A short, focused cut now sets you up for a much more productive and efficient muscle-building phase later. Let's dive into the science behind this recommendation.

Why Cutting First Makes You Build Muscle Faster Later

The primary reason to cut from 20 percent body fat is to improve your 'nutrient partitioning' or 'P-ratio'. This is your body's ability to direct incoming calories toward muscle cells for repair and growth, instead of storing them in fat cells. At higher body fat levels, your insulin sensitivity is generally lower. Insulin is a key storage hormone, and when your cells are less responsive to it, your body is more likely to store the calories you eat as body fat, especially when you're in a calorie surplus (a bulk).

By cutting down to a leaner base of 12-15 percent body fat, you significantly improve your insulin sensitivity. Your body becomes more efficient at using nutrients. When you eventually switch to a lean bulk, a much higher proportion of your calorie surplus will go towards building the quality muscle you want, not unwanted fat. Cutting now is the fastest way to get bigger later.

Furthermore, your hormonal environment is more favorable for muscle growth at lower body fat levels. Higher body fat is associated with increased activity of an enzyme called aromatase, which converts testosterone into estrogen. This can create a less anabolic (muscle-building) environment. Reducing your body fat helps to optimize your natural hormonal profile, making your body a more efficient muscle-building machine. The common mistake of the 'dirty bulk' from an already high starting point just worsens these issues, creating a frustrating cycle of long cuts and inefficient bulks. A strategic cut breaks this cycle for good.

The Exception: When to 'Mini-Bulk' First

While cutting is the right move for most, there is one key exception: the individual at 20% body fat who has very little underlying muscle mass, often as a result of being new to proper resistance training. For this person, an immediate cut can be demotivating, as it may simply result in a smaller, but still soft, physique-the classic 'skinny-fat' look.

In this specific scenario, a 'mini-bulk' can be the better initial strategy. This involves a short, controlled muscle-building phase lasting 8-12 weeks. The goal is not to get huge, but to build a solid foundation of muscle mass. This is done by eating in a small, controlled calorie surplus of 200-300 calories above maintenance, combined with a focus on progressive overload in the gym. This short phase allows you to build some initial strength and muscle, which provides a better base to reveal once you do begin to cut. After the 8-12 week mini-bulk, you would then transition into the cutting phase as described below, but you'll do so with more muscle and a higher metabolism than when you started.

What About Body Recomposition?

Another strategy you'll hear about is body recomposition-the idea of losing fat and building muscle at the same time. This is the holy grail of fitness, and it is possible, but only under specific circumstances. Body recomposition is a realistic goal for three main groups: complete beginners to weight training, individuals returning to training after a long layoff (muscle memory), and overweight individuals who are new to lifting.

For these groups, the powerful new stimulus of resistance training can trigger muscle growth even while in a slight calorie deficit, as the body can use its ample stored fat for energy. The protocol involves eating right around your maintenance calories (or in a very small deficit), consuming a high-protein diet (around 1 gram per pound of bodyweight), and training hard with progressive overload. However, for anyone with 6+ months of consistent training experience, body recomposition is an incredibly slow and inefficient process. You will make far faster and more noticeable progress by dedicating specific blocks of time to a single goal: first cutting fat, then building muscle.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 3-Step Plan to Cut From 20 Percent Body Fat

For the majority who have decided to cut, success lies in a clear, consistent plan. This is not about starving yourself; it's about creating a moderate energy deficit while keeping protein high to preserve precious muscle mass. Follow these three steps.

Step 1. Find Your Maintenance Calories

A simple and effective starting point for your daily maintenance calories is to multiply your bodyweight in pounds by 15. This estimate works well for most people with a moderately active lifestyle. For example, if you weigh 180 pounds, your estimated maintenance is 2,700 calories (180 x 15). For a more personalized number, you can use an online TDEE (Total Daily Energy Expenditure) calculator that factors in your age, sex, height, and activity level. This is the approximate number of calories you'd eat to maintain your current weight.

Step 2. Set Your Calorie and Protein Targets

To lose fat, you must be in a calorie deficit. Subtract 300 to 500 calories from your maintenance number. For our 180-pound example, a daily target of 2,200 to 2,400 calories is a perfect starting point. Next, and just as important, set your protein target. Aim for 1.6 to 2.2 grams of protein per kilogram of bodyweight (or about 0.8 to 1 gram per pound). For a 180-pound person, this is 144-180 grams of protein daily. This high protein intake is crucial for preserving muscle mass in a deficit and keeping you feeling full. Great protein sources include chicken breast, lean beef, fish, eggs, Greek yogurt, cottage cheese, and whey protein.

Step 3. Track Your Intake and Adjust Weekly

Consistency is everything. You must track your calorie and protein intake to ensure you're hitting your targets. You can use a simple notebook, but this can be tedious. For a shortcut, Mofilo’s food logger lets you scan barcodes or snap photos to log meals in seconds. Weigh yourself daily, first thing in the morning after using the restroom, and take the weekly average. If your average weight isn't dropping by 0.5% to 1.0% per week, your deficit isn't large enough. If your tracking is accurate, adjust your daily calories down by another 100-200 and assess again the following week.

How Long Does It Take to Cut to 15 Percent?

Setting a realistic timeline is key for motivation. For a 180-pound person, losing 0.5% to 1.0% of body weight per week means losing 0.9 to 1.8 pounds weekly. To get from 20 percent body fat to 15 percent, you will likely need to lose around 10 pounds of pure fat. Given that some weight will also come from water and glycogen, the total scale weight loss might be slightly more.

Based on this rate, a successful cut should take between 6 and 12 weeks. Progress is never a straight line. Some weeks you'll lose more, some less. Trust the process, focus on your weekly average weight, and be patient. Once you reach your goal of around 15 percent body fat, don't immediately jump into a huge surplus. We recommend a 2-week maintenance phase. Bring your calories back up to your new maintenance level to give your body and mind a break from dieting before transitioning into a productive lean bulk.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I change my training while cutting?

No. Your primary training goal during a cut is to maintain strength and muscle mass. You do this by giving your body a reason to keep its muscle-lifting heavy. Continue to train with the same intensity as before. Your recovery capacity will be lower due to the calorie deficit, so you may need to slightly reduce your total training volume (e.g., one less set per exercise), but do not make the mistake of switching to light weight and high reps.

How much cardio should I do during a cut?

Cardio is a tool to increase your calorie deficit, not a requirement for fat loss. Start your cut with minimal to no cardio. Focus on hitting your calorie target first. If your fat loss stalls for two consecutive weeks, you can either reduce calories further or add in 2-3 sessions of 20-30 minutes of low-intensity steady-state (LISS) cardio, like walking on an incline. This form of cardio is effective and has minimal impact on your recovery from weight training.

Can I just eat clean without tracking calories?

While eating whole, unprocessed foods is an excellent habit for health, it does not guarantee a calorie deficit. 'Clean' foods still contain calories, and it's very possible to overeat healthy foods like nuts, avocados, and olive oil. For the defined period of a cut, tracking your intake is the most reliable and efficient way to ensure you are consistently in a deficit and making progress toward your goal.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.