Is Myfitnesspal Still the Best

For over a decade, MyFitnessPal was the undisputed king of calorie counting. It taught millions of people what a calorie was. But as we head into 2026, the game has changed. You're right to be skeptical and ask if it's still the top choice.

Key Takeaways

• MyFitnessPal is no longer the best tracking app because its database is over 75% user-generated and filled with errors.
• An inaccurate food entry can throw off your daily calories by 100-300 calories, sabotaging your fat loss or muscle gain goals.
• Modern apps like MacroFactor use a verified food database and an adaptive algorithm that adjusts your calories based on your weekly progress.
• The MyFitnessPal barcode scanner, a crucial feature for quick logging, is now behind an $80/year paywall.
• For serious results, the best investment is an app with a verified database, which eliminates the guesswork and ensures your tracking is accurate.
• While MFP's free version exists, its limitations and inaccuracies make it a frustrating choice for anyone committed to seeing real change.

The Original King: Why Everyone Started with MyFitnessPal

To answer the question 'is MyFitnessPal still the best' directly: no, it's not. For anyone serious about their results, it was overtaken years ago. But to understand why, you have to understand why it became so popular in the first place.

For a long time, MyFitnessPal (MFP) was revolutionary. Before it, people were writing things down in notebooks or using clunky spreadsheets. MFP put a food database of millions of items in your pocket, for free. It made the abstract concept of a "calorie" tangible.

You could scan a barcode and instantly see the nutritional information. This was a game-changer. It taught an entire generation of gym-goers about macros, portion sizes, and the energy content of food. Its network effect was massive; everyone used it because everyone else used it, which only made its database larger.

The core premise was simple: log your food, stay under your calorie goal, and you'll lose weight. And for many people, it worked, at least initially. It provided a basic framework for accountability that was better than nothing. If you went from eating mindlessly to tracking anything at all, you were bound to see some progress.

It became the default recommendation from trainers, dietitians, and fitness influencers. It was the Kleenex or Google of its category-the brand name became the verb. "Just track it in MyFitnessPal."

Stop guessing your calories.

Track your food with Mofilo. Know you hit your numbers every single day.

Start your 7 day free trial

The Problem: Why MyFitnessPal Fails Serious Users in 2026

The very thing that made MyFitnessPal massive is now its greatest weakness: its user-generated database. This is the single biggest reason it is no longer the best app.

Here’s the problem: anyone can add any food to the database. This has led to a digital junkyard of inaccurate, duplicate, and incomplete entries.

Imagine you search for "grilled chicken breast." You might find 20 different options:

• "Chicken Breast" - 165 calories per 100g (Correct)
• "My Chicken Breast" - 250 calories per 100g (User added oil)
• "Chicken" - 120 calories per 100g (Wrong)
• "Grill Chix Breast" - No weight, just "1 serving" (Useless)

A 10-20% error margin on every food you log adds up. If you're eating 4-5 times a day, you could be off by 200-400 calories and not even know it. That's the difference between losing a pound a week and gaining weight. You think you're in a deficit, but the bad data is lying to you. This is why so many people say, "I'm eating in a deficit but not losing weight!"

Then, in a move that alienated millions, MFP put its barcode scanner behind the Premium paywall. This feature was the cornerstone of its convenience. Taking it away made the free version dramatically more tedious. Now, instead of a quick scan, you have to manually search for every item, navigate the messy database, and hope you pick the right entry.

Finally, MFP is a static tool. It gives you a calorie goal based on a generic formula (like the Mifflin-St Jeor equation) and leaves it there. It doesn't learn. If your metabolism adapts or your weight loss stalls, the app doesn't adjust. You have to do all the math and troubleshooting yourself. Modern apps have solved this problem.

The Top 3 Alternatives to MyFitnessPal

If you're serious about your goals, you need a tool built for accuracy. The good news is that several superior alternatives have emerged. They cost money, but they solve the exact problems that make MFP so frustrating. The $10-15 per month they cost is a small price for getting results instead of spinning your wheels.

Alternative #1: MacroFactor (The Best Overall)

This is our top recommendation for 95% of people. MacroFactor was built from the ground up to be more accurate and intelligent than older apps.

• Key Feature: Verified Database & Adaptive TDEE. Its food database is professionally managed and verified. This eliminates the guesswork. More importantly, its algorithm is the best in the business. You weigh in daily and log your food, and the app calculates your actual, personal Total Daily Energy Expenditure (TDEE). It then adjusts your calorie and macro targets each week based on your real-world results. If you stall, it adjusts. If you lose too fast, it adjusts. It's like having a personal nutrition coach doing the math for you 24/7.
• Who it's for: Anyone who wants the most accurate, data-driven results and is willing to pay for the best tool available. It's perfect for beginners who want to be guided and advanced users who love data.
• Downside: There is no free version. It's a premium product from day one, with a free trial. The subscription is around $72 per year.

Alternative #2: Carbon Diet Coach (The Coach-Focused App)

Developed by renowned coaches Dr. Layne Norton and Holly Baxter, Carbon is another excellent premium option with a strong emphasis on the coaching process.

• Key Feature: Coaching Check-ins. Like MacroFactor, it uses an adaptive TDEE to adjust your targets. Its process is structured around a weekly "check-in" where you get your new targets. This mimics the experience of working with a real coach. It also has a high-quality, verified food database.
• Who it's for: People who appreciate a more structured, coach-like process and may follow the founders' content. The core functionality is very similar to MacroFactor.
• Downside: Subscription-based, with no free tier. Some users find the interface slightly less intuitive than MacroFactor's, but it's still a top-tier choice. The cost is around $80 per year.

Alternative #3: Lose It! (The Best Free Alternative)

If you absolutely cannot pay for an app, Lose It! is a far better choice than MyFitnessPal.

• Key Feature: Better Free Experience. The biggest advantage is that the barcode scanner is available in the free version. This alone makes it significantly less frustrating than MFP. The interface is cleaner, there are fewer intrusive ads, and the community is very active.
• Who it's for: People on a tight budget who want a free tracking app that feels more modern and less clunky than MyFitnessPal.
• Downside: It still relies heavily on a user-generated database. While it's generally considered cleaner than MFP's, the risk of inaccurate entries remains. Its calorie suggestions are also based on static formulas, not an adaptive algorithm.

Your macros. Every day. On track.

No more guessing. Know your numbers and see the results you've earned.

Start your 7 day free trial

How to Choose the Right App For You

Your choice of app comes down to one question: How much is an accurate result worth to you? Wasting 3-6 months on a flawed plan because of bad data is far more costly than any app subscription.

Here’s a simple breakdown to make your decision.

Choose MacroFactor if:

You are serious about seeing results and want the most powerful, accurate tool on the market. You believe in data, want the app to handle all the weekly adjustments for you, and are willing to invest about $12/month to ensure you're not wasting your time and effort in the gym.

Choose Carbon Diet Coach if:

You want an adaptive algorithm and a verified database, but you prefer a more structured weekly check-in process. You might be a fan of the founders and their coaching philosophy. The outcome is similar to MacroFactor, but the user experience is different.

Choose Lose It! if:

Your budget is zero, and you cannot afford a subscription. You accept the risk of an unverified database but want a better user experience than MyFitnessPal, primarily by having access to a free barcode scanner.

Use MyFitnessPal only if:

You are prepared to manually double-check every single food entry against the USDA food database online. You have the patience to navigate a clunky, ad-filled interface and a paywalled barcode scanner. For nearly everyone, the frustration is not worth it.

For 9 out of 10 people we work with, the recommendation is clear: start the free trial for MacroFactor. The clarity and confidence you get from a verified database and an adaptive calorie target are game-changing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is MyFitnessPal Premium worth it?

No. For its annual price of around $80, you can get a subscription to a vastly superior app like MacroFactor or Carbon. These apps offer verified databases and adaptive calorie coaching, two critical features that MFP Premium lacks.

What is the most accurate food tracking app?

MacroFactor and Carbon Diet Coach are the most accurate food tracking apps. Their accuracy comes from two things: a professionally curated and verified food database, and an adaptive algorithm that calculates your personal energy expenditure based on your body's actual results.

Can I lose weight with the free version of MyFitnessPal?

Yes, it is possible, but it is significantly harder and more frustrating. You must be extremely diligent about double-checking every food entry for accuracy and manually adjust your own calories when you hit a plateau. The lack of a free barcode scanner also makes logging a slow process.

Is Lose It! better than MyFitnessPal?

Yes, for most users, Lose It! is a better free app than MyFitnessPal. Its interface is cleaner, and its free version includes the barcode scanner, which is a major advantage. While its database is also user-generated, the overall experience is less frustrating.

Conclusion

The tool you use to track your nutrition is just as important as the effort you put in at the gym. Using an app with a flawed database is like trying to build a house with a broken measuring tape. MyFitnessPal was a great starting point, but it's a relic from a past era.

Choosing a modern tool with a verified database is the first real step toward taking control of your nutrition. Stop guessing, start tracking accurately, and get the results you've been working for.