Is It True That Shoulder Press Is Bad for You

The shoulder press has a reputation for being a joint-wrecker. You've probably seen videos or heard from someone at the gym that it's a guaranteed way to get an injury. Let's clear this up immediately: the exercise itself is not the enemy. Bad form is.

Key Takeaways

• The shoulder press is not inherently bad; poor form and limited mobility are the real culprits behind the pain.
• Flaring your elbows out to 90 degrees is the number one mistake that causes shoulder impingement and pain.
• Tucking your elbows forward to a 45-60 degree angle instantly makes the press safer and more effective for your delts.
• Using dumbbells is safer than a barbell for most people because it allows a more natural range of motion for your joints.
• A sharp, pinching pain is a signal to stop immediately; it is not the same as the muscle burn you feel during a good set.
• Start with a weight you can control for 8-12 perfect reps, which for many people is just 10-20 pound dumbbells.

Why You've Heard the Shoulder Press Is "Bad"

The answer to 'is it true that shoulder press is bad for you' is no-but the reason you're asking is completely valid. Doing this movement with bad form *is* one of the fastest ways to injure your shoulders. You're not imagining the risk; you've just been given the wrong diagnosis for the problem.

The fear comes from a real mechanical issue called shoulder impingement. Your shoulder is a ball-and-socket joint, held together by a group of muscles and tendons called the rotator cuff. Think of it like a complex system of pulleys and ropes.

When you perform a shoulder press incorrectly, you can create a pinching action inside the joint. The most common mistake is flaring your elbows directly out to your sides, creating a 90-degree angle between your torso and upper arm. This position dramatically shrinks the space inside your shoulder joint, pinching the rotator cuff tendons between the bones.

Imagine pinching a cable under a heavy door. Do it once, and it's irritated. Do it for 3 sets of 10 reps, twice a week, and you're going to fray that cable until it snaps. That's what happens inside your shoulder. This is the sharp, pinching pain people feel at the top or front of their shoulder, and it's why the exercise gets a bad reputation.

The good news is this is 100% avoidable. The problem isn't the act of pressing overhead. The problem is the path your arms take to get there. By simply changing the angle of your elbows, you open up that space in the joint and remove the pinch point entirely.

Stop guessing if your form is right.

Track your lifts and notes. Know you're getting stronger, safely.

Start your 7 day free trial

The Real Culprit: 3 Common Form Mistakes

It's not the press that's bad for you; it's these three common mistakes that are. If you've ever felt shoulder pain from pressing, you are almost certainly making one of them. Here’s how to identify and fix them for good.

Mistake #1: Flaring Your Elbows Too Wide

This is the big one, responsible for at least 80% of shoulder press-related pain. People are often taught to create a "T" shape with their arms out to the sides. This is the most unstable and mechanically dangerous position for your shoulder joint.

When your elbows are at 90 degrees, you are forcing the head of your humerus (the ball of the ball-and-socket joint) up against the acromion (the bony roof of your shoulder). This is the direct cause of impingement.

The Fix: Tuck your elbows forward to a 45 to 60-degree angle. Instead of a wide "T" shape, your arms should form more of an arrow or "A" shape. This simple adjustment creates space in the joint, aligns the muscle fibers of your deltoids for a better contraction, and takes the stress off your rotator cuff.

Mistake #2: Using a Barbell When You Lack Mobility

A barbell forces your hands, wrists, and shoulders into a fixed, symmetrical path. If you have any slight imbalance, tightness, or mobility restriction in one shoulder (which most people do), the bar will force that joint into a compromised position.

Your body isn't perfectly symmetrical, so forcing it to move a perfectly symmetrical object can cause problems. One shoulder might be able to handle the path, but the other gets torqued and strained on every single rep.

The Fix: Switch to dumbbells. Dumbbells allow each arm to move independently, finding its own natural and safe path. Your wrists can rotate slightly, and your elbows can find the perfect angle without being locked in place by a rigid bar. For 9 out of 10 people, the dumbbell shoulder press is the superior choice for both muscle growth and joint health.

Mistake #3: Arching Your Lower Back Excessively

If you see someone leaning way back during a shoulder press, they are not pressing the weight; they are turning it into a standing incline chest press. This is a cheat move used to lift weight that is too heavy.

This excessive arch places massive compressive force on your lumbar spine. You're trading shoulder development for a potential lower back injury. It's a terrible trade-off.

The Fix: Lower the weight. Brace your core as if you're about to be punched in the stomach, and squeeze your glutes. This creates a stable, rigid torso. The press should come from your shoulders, not from momentum generated by your back. Pick a weight you can press for 8-12 strict reps.

Your progress, week after week.

Every workout logged. Proof you're getting stronger without the pain.

Start your 7 day free trial

How to Perform a Safe and Effective Shoulder Press

Forget what you've seen people do with bad form. Follow these steps to build strong, healthy shoulders without the pain. We'll focus on the seated dumbbell shoulder press, as it's the safest and most effective variation for most people.

Step 1: Choose the Right Variation (Dumbbells First)

Start with dumbbells. They are more forgiving and better for learning proper mechanics. Sit on an adjustable bench set to an 80-90 degree angle. A fully upright bench is fine, but a slight incline can be more comfortable for some.

Using a bench with back support prevents you from using your lower back to cheat and provides a stable base to press from. This isolates the work to your shoulders where it belongs.

Step 2: Set Up Correctly

Plant your feet firmly on the floor. Kick the dumbbells up to your shoulders one at a time, or have a spotter help you. Your palms should be facing forward.

Now, perform the most important part: tuck your elbows. Move them forward from that 90-degree side position to a 45-60 degree angle in front of your body. Your forearms should be vertical. This is your safe and strong starting position.

Step 3: Execute the Press

Before you press, take a deep breath, brace your core, and ensure your back is pressed firmly against the bench pad. Squeeze the dumbbell handles hard.

Press the dumbbells up and slightly inward, as if you're forming a triangle at the top. Don't let them crash into each other. Stop just short of locking out your elbows to keep tension on the deltoids.

Control the descent. This is just as important as the press itself. Lower the dumbbells slowly over 2-3 seconds until your hands are roughly at chin level or your upper arms are just below parallel with the floor. Don't go so deep that you feel a stretch or pain in the front of your shoulder. Pause for a second at the bottom and repeat.

What to Do If You Still Feel Pain

If you've corrected your form and still feel a sharp, pinching pain (not muscle fatigue), stop. Pain is a signal from your body that something is wrong. Pushing through it is how chronic injuries develop.

First, understand the difference between good pain and bad pain. The burning sensation in your muscles towards the end of a set is good. That's metabolic stress, and it leads to growth. A sharp, stabbing, or pinching feeling in the joint itself is bad. That's a mechanical issue.

If you experience bad pain, it's time to switch to an alternative exercise that doesn't cause it. Your shoulders don't know if you're doing a dumbbell press or a landmine press; they only know tension. Here are three excellent, joint-friendly alternatives:

1. Landmine Press: This is one of the best shoulder-builders, period. By pressing a barbell wedged into a corner (or landmine attachment) upwards and forwards, you work the delts in a very natural, scapula-friendly angle. It's almost impossible to do this one with bad form.
2. Half-Kneeling Single-Arm Press: Kneeling on one knee while pressing with the opposite arm forces your core to stabilize and prevents you from cheating. It also allows for a completely free range of motion, letting your shoulder find its happiest path.
3. Arnold Press: This variation starts with palms facing you and rotates as you press up. That rotation can help open up the shoulder joint for people who feel a pinch with the standard press. Use a lighter weight and focus on a smooth, controlled motion.

Don't forget to warm up properly with exercises like band pull-aparts and face pulls to activate the small stabilizing muscles of your rotator cuff before you press.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is barbell or dumbbell shoulder press better?

Dumbbells are better and safer for most people. They allow each shoulder to move through its own natural range of motion, reducing joint stress and promoting balanced muscle development. Barbells let you lift heavier weight but carry a higher risk of injury if you have poor mobility.

Is the machine shoulder press a good alternative?

It can be a good option because it provides stability. However, the machine follows a fixed path that may not align with your body's natural mechanics. If the machine feels smooth and pain-free, it's a fine choice. If you feel any pinching, avoid it.

How heavy should I go on shoulder press?

You should use a weight that you can lift for 8-12 repetitions with perfect form. If you have to arch your back, use your legs for momentum, or can't control the weight on the way down, it's too heavy. Start with 10-20 lb dumbbells and focus on technique.

What's the difference between a shoulder press and an overhead press (OHP)?

The terms are often used interchangeably. "Overhead Press" (OHP) usually refers to the standing barbell version, which is a full-body strength movement. "Shoulder Press" is a broader term that includes seated, dumbbell, and machine variations that are more focused on isolating the shoulder muscles for hypertrophy.

Conclusion

The shoulder press is not bad for you, but bad technique is. By tucking your elbows, using dumbbells, and lifting with strict form, you can turn it into one of the best shoulder-building exercises in your arsenal. Stop fearing the movement and start respecting the technique.