If Not Gaining Muscle Should I Eat More or Lift Heavier

You're stuck. You go to the gym, you lift, you try to eat right, but the scale isn't moving and your muscles don't look any different. It's one of the most frustrating plateaus in fitness. So, if not gaining muscle should I eat more or lift heavier? The answer for 9 out of 10 people is to lift heavier. Eating more without lifting heavier just makes you fatter, not bigger.

Muscle growth is a reaction to stress. You must give your body a reason to build new tissue, and that reason is an ever-increasing challenge. Before you add a single calorie to your diet, you must first prove your training demands it.

Key Takeaways

• Before eating more, you must be correctly applying progressive overload in your training.
• "Lifting heavier" means adding about 5 lbs to your main compound lifts every 1-2 weeks, or adding 1-2 reps per set.
• Eating more without increasing the stimulus from your workouts will primarily lead to fat gain, not muscle.
• A proper muscle-building calorie surplus is a small, controlled 200-300 calories above your daily maintenance needs.
• If your lift numbers are not increasing over a 2-3 week period, your body has no reason to build muscle, regardless of how much you eat.
• The definitive way to break a plateau is to track your workouts and your calories; you cannot manage what you do not measure.

Why "Lifting Heavier" Is Almost Always the First Answer

If you're asking if you should eat more or lift heavier, you've already identified the two key variables for muscle growth: stimulus (lifting) and resources (eating). But you have the order wrong. The stimulus must come first.

Think of your body like a construction company. Your muscles are the buildings. The workouts are the construction orders, and the food you eat is the raw material (lumber, concrete, steel).

If you keep sending the same small construction order every week-lifting the same 135 pounds for 8 reps-the company has no reason to expand. It has already built a structure perfectly capable of handling that load. If you suddenly start sending truckloads of extra lumber and concrete (a calorie surplus) without a bigger construction order, the company won't build anything new. It will just pile the extra materials in the yard. That’s fat gain.

To get the company to build a bigger, stronger building, you must send a bigger order. You must demand it lifts 140 pounds for 8 reps. This new, challenging order signals that the current structure is inadequate. Only then will the company use the raw materials you provide to build a bigger, stronger muscle.

This is progressive overload. It is the absolute, non-negotiable foundation of muscle growth. It’s the process of making your workouts harder over time. Without it, you are just exercising, not training. Exercising burns calories. Training builds muscle.

Most people who think they're training hard are actually just having hard workouts. They get sweaty, they feel a burn, but the actual weight on the bar or the reps they complete hasn't meaningfully changed in months. They've hit a plateau because they stopped giving their body a reason to adapt.

Your first step is not to open the fridge. It's to open your workout log. If you don't have one, that's problem number one. You must start tracking your lifts. You need to know, with certainty, if you are getting stronger. If you are not, eating more is a waste of time.

Stop guessing if you're getting stronger.

Track your lifts in Mofilo. See your strength numbers go up every week.

Start your 7 day free trial

What If I'm Already Lifting Heavier? When to Eat More

Let's say you are tracking your workouts. You are genuinely fighting to add 5 pounds to your squat or one more rep to your bench press every week. But you're stalling. You've failed to hit your target reps on a key lift for two weeks in a row. You feel tired, and your motivation is dipping.

This is when you earn the right to eat more.

At this point, your training (the construction order) is demanding more than your resources (the food) can supply. Your body is sending clear signals that it doesn't have enough fuel to recover and build back stronger. Now, and only now, does a calorie surplus become the solution.

But this isn't a license to eat everything in sight. The infamous "dirty bulk" is a mistake that leaves most people feeling soft and discouraged. Your body can only build muscle so fast-about 0.25 to 0.5 pounds of new muscle tissue per week under ideal conditions for an intermediate lifter. Any calories you eat beyond what's needed for that process and to fuel your workouts will be stored as fat.

A controlled, lean bulk is the answer. This involves eating in a small, consistent calorie surplus. We're talking about 200-300 calories above your Total Daily Energy Expenditure (TDEE), which is the amount of calories you burn per day.

For example, if your maintenance is 2,500 calories, you would aim for 2,700-2,800 calories per day. This small surplus provides just enough extra energy to fuel muscle repair and growth without spilling over into significant fat storage. A 300-calorie surplus per day equates to about 2,100 extra calories per week, which supports a healthy weight gain of around 0.5 pounds per week. This pace is ideal for maximizing the muscle-to-fat gain ratio.

Eating more is the fuel. Lifting heavier is the engine. You need both, but the engine has to be running first.

Your progress, proven in numbers.

Every workout logged. Every PR recorded. Proof you're building muscle.

Start your 7 day free trial

The 3-Step Diagnostic to Fix Your Muscle-Building Plateau

Stop guessing and start diagnosing. Follow these three steps in order. Do not skip to the next step until you have confirmed the previous one is handled.

Step 1: Audit Your Training Log for Progressive Overload

Your workout log is the most important tool you have. If you aren't using one, start today. Open a notebook or a tracking app. For every exercise, write down the weight, reps, and sets.

Now, look back at the last 4 weeks. Pick your main compound lifts: Squat, Bench Press, Deadlift, and Overhead Press. Is the number bigger now than it was 4 weeks ago? There are two primary ways to progress:

1. Intensity: You lifted more weight for the same number of reps. (e.g., Week 1 Bench Press: 150 lbs for 3 sets of 8. Week 4: 160 lbs for 3 sets of 8.)
2. Volume: You lifted the same weight for more reps or sets. (e.g., Week 1 Bench Press: 150 lbs for 3 sets of 8. Week 4: 150 lbs for 3 sets of 10.)

If you cannot see clear, undeniable progress in your log, you have found your problem. Your goal for the next month is simple: add 5 pounds to your primary lower-body lifts and 2.5-5 pounds to your upper-body lifts every 1-2 weeks. Or, add one rep to every set. That's it. This is your only job.

Step 2: Verify Your Calorie and Protein Intake

Only after you confirm your training is progressive should you look at your diet. Don't just "eat more." Track it.

For 3-5 days, log everything you eat and drink in an app. Be brutally honest. This will give you your baseline.

Next, calculate your estimated maintenance calories (TDEE) using an online calculator. Compare your tracked intake to your estimated TDEE. Are you actually in a surplus? Most people who are "eating a lot" are surprised to find they are barely eating at maintenance.

Your targets:

• Calories: Your TDEE + 200-300 calories. For a 180lb man, this might be 2,500 + 300 = 2,800 calories.
• Protein: 1.6 to 2.2 grams per kilogram of bodyweight (or about 0.8 to 1.0 grams per pound). For that same 180lb man, this is 144-180 grams of protein per day.

If your tracked intake is below these numbers, you have found your problem. Adjust your daily eating to consistently hit your calorie and protein targets. A 30g protein shake or an extra chicken breast can easily fix this.

Step 3: Check Your Recovery Variables

If your training is progressive AND your nutrition is on point, but you're still stuck, the final piece is recovery. Your muscles don't grow in the gym; they grow when you rest.

• Sleep: Are you getting 7-9 hours of quality sleep per night? This is when your body releases growth hormone and repairs damaged muscle tissue. Less than 7 hours consistently will sabotage your gains. It's that simple.
• Stress: Chronic high stress elevates cortisol, a catabolic hormone that can break down muscle tissue and encourage fat storage. While you can't eliminate all stress, finding ways to manage it (walking, meditation, less screen time) is crucial for an optimal hormonal environment for growth.
• Deloads: You can't push 100% all the time. Every 4 to 8 weeks of hard training, you need a deload week. This means reducing your training volume and/or intensity by about 40-50%. You'll lift lighter weights or do fewer sets. This gives your joints, nervous system, and muscles a chance to fully recover, setting you up for future progress. It feels like taking a step back, but it's what allows you to take two steps forward.

What to Expect (A Realistic Timeline)

Building muscle is a marathon, not a sprint. You need to have realistic expectations, or you will quit.

When you first combine progressive overload with a slight calorie surplus, you will see the scale move. Expect to gain 0.5 to 1 pound per week. Be aware: much of this initial gain is not pure muscle.

• Week 1-2: You'll likely see a jump of 2-4 pounds. This is primarily increased water retention and glycogen storage in your muscles from the extra carbohydrates. Your muscles will look and feel fuller. This is a good sign.
• Month 1: After the initial water gain, you should aim for a steady gain of 0.5-1 pound per week. For a beginner, about half of this can be muscle. That's 1-2 pounds of actual muscle in a month, which is fantastic progress.
• Month 3-6: As you become more advanced, the rate of muscle gain slows. An intermediate lifter might gain 0.5-1 pound of muscle per month. The scale should still be creeping up by about 0.5 pounds per week. If it's moving faster, you're likely eating too much and gaining excess fat. If it's not moving at all, you need to slightly increase your calories (by another 100-150 per day).

Don't just rely on the scale. Take progress photos every 4 weeks and track your key lift numbers. Your bench press going from 135 lbs to 155 lbs is a much better indicator of muscle gain than the number on the scale.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much heavier should I be lifting?

Aim for small, consistent jumps. For compound movements like squats and deadlifts, try to add 5 pounds to the bar each week. For upper body lifts like bench press and overhead press, adding 2.5 to 5 pounds per week is a great goal. If you can't add weight, aim to add 1-2 reps to each of your sets with the same weight.

How much more should I eat to gain muscle?

Start with a conservative surplus of 200-300 calories above your daily maintenance level. For most people, this is the equivalent of adding a protein shake with milk and a banana, or an extra serving of chicken and rice. This controlled increase minimizes fat gain while fueling muscle growth.

Will I get fat if I eat more?

You will gain some body fat during a muscle-building phase. It's unavoidable. However, by keeping the calorie surplus small (200-300 calories) and prioritizing protein, you can maximize muscle gain and minimize fat gain. A slow weight gain of 0.5-1 pound per week is the target.

What if I can't lift heavier due to injury?

If you have an injury, progressive overload is still the goal, but you must be smarter. You can progress by increasing reps, increasing sets, decreasing rest time between sets, or improving your form. You can also choose different exercises that don't aggravate the injury. The principle remains: the body must be challenged.

How do I know if it's muscle or fat I'm gaining?

Look at three things. First, your strength in the gym. If your lifts are consistently going up, you are gaining muscle. Second, take progress photos every month. You will be the best judge of your changing physique. Third, measure your waist. If the scale is going up but your waist measurement is staying the same or increasing very slowly, you're doing it right.