If I Can't Do a Pull Up Should I Do Negatives or Hangs

The question of 'if I can't do a pull up should I do negatives or hangs' is one of the most common points of frustration in the gym. You see people making it look easy, but when you try, you barely move. It feels like you're missing a secret. The good news is, you're not weak, you're just untrained in a very specific movement. This guide will give you the exact, no-BS path to get your chin over that bar.

Key Takeaways

• To get your first pull-up, you should start with negatives; they build the specific eccentric strength required for the pulling motion.
• Aim to complete 3 sets of 3-5 negatives, with each one lasting at least 5 seconds, before worrying about other exercises.
• Dead hangs are for building grip strength and shoulder stability, but they will not build the back strength needed to pull yourself up.
• You must supplement negatives with inverted rows to build the horizontal pulling strength that supports your vertical pull.
• A realistic timeline to achieve your first unassisted pull-up is between 8 and 12 weeks of consistent, dedicated training 2-3 times per week.
• Avoid using resistance bands when you start, as they provide the most assistance at the bottom of the movement, which is exactly where you need to build strength.

The Direct Answer: Negatives First, Then Hangs

When you're stuck wondering, 'if I can't do a pull up should I do negatives or hangs,' the definitive answer is to start with negatives. They are not just an alternative; they are the single most effective exercise for building the strength to achieve your first pull-up.

Think of it this way: a pull-up has two parts. The 'up' phase (concentric), where you pull your body to the bar, and the 'down' phase (eccentric), where you lower yourself. Your muscles are significantly stronger during the eccentric phase. A pull-up negative trains this exact pathway, just in reverse. You are teaching your lats, biceps, and back muscles how to handle your bodyweight under tension.

By jumping to the top position and slowly lowering yourself down, you are forcing your muscles to do the work of a pull-up. Each controlled negative is like a blueprint, showing your nervous system and muscles exactly what they need to do. You are building the specific strength required, not just general strength.

Hangs, on the other hand, are an isometric exercise. This means your muscles are under tension, but they aren't changing length. A dead hang is fantastic for building grip strength and decompressing your spine. It's a crucial component, but it's a supporting actor. Your grip might be the first thing to fail, but a stronger grip alone won't pull you over the bar. You can hang for 2 minutes and still not be able to do a pull-up if your back isn't strong enough.

So, the hierarchy is clear: negatives build the primary pulling strength. Hangs build the secondary grip strength. You need both, but you must prioritize negatives.

Finally get your first pull-up.

Track your negatives and rows. Watch your strength build week by week.

Start your 7 day free trial

Why Just Hanging or Using Bands Won't Work

If getting your first pull-up were easy, everyone would do it. Many people get stuck because they follow common but flawed advice. They spend months on exercises that feel productive but don't actually build the right kind of strength.

The Problem with Only Doing Hangs

Hanging from the bar is a great start. It gets you comfortable with supporting your bodyweight. But it's a static hold. It primarily trains your forearms, grip, and shoulder stability. It does very little to strengthen your latissimus dorsi (lats), the massive back muscles that do about 70% of the work in a pull-up. You can have a world-class grip, but if your lats can't initiate the pull, you will remain stuck at the bottom.

The Flaw in Resistance Bands

Resistance bands seem like the perfect solution. They make the pull-up easier, allowing you to complete reps. Here's the problem: a band offers the *most* assistance at the bottom of the pull-up, in the dead hang position. It offers the *least* assistance at the top, when your chin is near the bar.

This is the exact opposite of what you need. The hardest part of a pull-up is initiating the pull from a dead hang. By using a band, you are essentially skipping the most important part of the exercise. You are training yourself to be weak where you need to be strong. It's a crutch that prevents you from building the foundational strength to pull your own weight from the bottom.

Why Lat Pulldowns Don't Directly Translate

The lat pulldown machine seems like a 1-to-1 substitute. You're pulling a bar down, after all. While it does strengthen your lats, it's what's known as an 'open-chain' exercise. Your body is stationary, and you are moving the weight. A pull-up is a 'closed-chain' exercise where the object (the bar) is stationary, and you are moving your body through space. This requires far more core stability, coordination, and neurological adaptation. Lat pulldowns are a good accessory, but they will never be a replacement for practicing the actual movement pattern with your own bodyweight.

The 3-Phase Plan to Your First Pull-Up

This isn't a 'maybe' plan. If you follow this program 2-3 times per week, with at least one day of rest in between, you will get your first pull-up. The goal is consistent effort, not daily exhaustion.

Phase 1: Building the Foundation (Weeks 1-4)

Your goal here is to build a base of eccentric strength and horizontal pulling power. Don't even attempt a full pull-up yet. Focus on perfect form with these exercises.

• Pull-Up Negatives: Place a box under the pull-up bar. Use your legs to jump to the top position, with your chin over the bar. Hold for 1 second, then begin lowering yourself as slowly as possible. Fight gravity. Your goal is a 5-second descent. If you can only manage 2-3 seconds at first, that's fine. The intent to go slow is what matters. Perform 3 sets of 3-5 reps.
• Inverted Rows: Set a barbell in a squat rack at waist height. Lie underneath it and grab the bar with an overhand grip, slightly wider than your shoulders. Keeping your body in a straight line from head to heels, pull your chest to the bar. Squeeze your shoulder blades together at the top. Lower yourself under control. Perform 3 sets of 8-12 reps.
• Dead Hangs: At the end of your workout, simply hang from the bar with your arms fully extended. Focus on your grip. Your goal is 3 sets of 30-second holds.

Phase 2: Increasing Time Under Tension (Weeks 5-8)

Now that you have a foundation, we increase the difficulty to force your muscles to adapt further. Your body is stronger, so the stimulus needs to be greater.

• Weighted Negatives (Optional but effective): If you can comfortably perform 5-second negatives, it's time to add a small amount of weight. Hold a 5 or 10-pound dumbbell between your feet. This will make your bodyweight feel lighter when you eventually remove it. Perform 3 sets of 3-5 reps, still aiming for that 5-second descent.
• Elevated Inverted Rows: Perform your inverted rows, but this time, place your feet on a bench or box. This increases the percentage of your bodyweight you have to pull, making the exercise harder. Perform 3 sets of 8-12 reps.
• Scapular Pulls: From a dead hang, without bending your elbows, pull your shoulder blades down and back. You should feel your body lift an inch or two. This small movement is crucial for learning how to initiate the pull-up with your lats, not your arms. Perform 3 sets of 10-15 reps.

Phase 3: The Final Push (Weeks 9-12+)

This is where it all comes together. You've built the strength; now it's time to practice the skill.

• The First Attempt: At the beginning of each workout, give one, maximal-effort attempt at a full pull-up from a dead hang. Don't cheat. Just pull as hard as you can. One day, you will surprise yourself.
• Partial Range Pull-Ups: After your attempt, perform partial reps. Pull as high as you possibly can, even if it's only halfway. Hold that top position for a second, then perform a slow, 5-second negative. This builds strength in your specific weak points. Perform 3 sets of 3-5 reps.
• Continue with Elevated Inverted Rows and Scapular Pulls: Keep building your overall back strength. These exercises are still vital.

Your first pull-up is closer than you think.

Log every rep and set. See the proof that you're getting stronger.

Start your 7 day free trial

What to Expect: A Realistic Timeline

Getting your first pull-up is a marathon, not a sprint. Your body needs time to build new muscle tissue and create the neural pathways for this complex movement. Here is an honest timeline.

Weeks 1-2: You will be sore. Your first negatives might feel more like controlled falling. A 3-second negative will feel like an eternity, and a 30-second hang will feel impossible. This is normal. Your body is in shock. Stick with the program. The goal is consistency, not perfection.

Weeks 3-4: The soreness will lessen. You'll notice you have more control over your negatives. You might hit your first clean 5-second descent. Your inverted rows will feel smoother, and your hang time will likely increase to 30 seconds or more. You're building momentum.

Weeks 5-8: This is the grind. You are noticeably stronger. You can control your negatives for the full 5 seconds, and you might even be adding a 5 lb dumbbell. During a pull-up attempt, you might get your head to the bar level. You are close. Don't get discouraged if you're not there yet; this phase builds the final block of strength needed.

Weeks 9-12+: This is typically when the magic happens. After weeks of building specific strength, you'll attempt a pull-up, and your chin will clear the bar. It might be shaky, and it won't be perfect, but it will be a full rep. Once you get one, the path to 2, 3, and 5 reps is exponentially faster. You've broken the barrier.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should I train for pull-ups?

You should train these exercises 2 to 3 times per week. Your muscles need at least 48 hours to recover and grow stronger. Training every day is counterproductive and will lead to burnout and overuse injuries, not faster progress.

What if I can't even do a slow negative?

Start with a faster negative, even if it's just 1 or 2 seconds. The key is to actively resist gravity for as long as you can. Combine this with a heavy focus on inverted rows to build your baseline back strength. As your rows get stronger, your negatives will get slower.

Should I use a chin-up grip or pull-up grip?

Start with a chin-up grip (palms facing you, shoulder-width apart). This grip recruits more of your biceps, which makes the movement easier for beginners. Once you can do 3-5 clean chin-ups, you can start working on the overhand pull-up grip.

Do I need to lose weight to do a pull-up?

It helps tremendously. Every pound of excess body fat is like strapping a weight plate to your waist. Losing just 5-10 pounds can be the difference between getting your chin to the bar and getting it over. Combining this training plan with a modest 300-500 calorie deficit will dramatically speed up your progress.

What about assisted pull-up machines?

They can be a useful accessory, but they shouldn't be your primary tool. They suffer from the same flaw as resistance bands: they provide the most help at the bottom of the movement. Use them for higher-rep sets after you've already done your negatives to get more volume in, but prioritize negatives for building raw strength.

Conclusion

Stop wondering and start training. The answer is negatives, supported by hangs and rows. It's not a secret trick; it's a proven method of building specific, usable strength. Follow the plan, be patient, and you will earn that first pull-up.