Are Deep Squats Actually Bad for Your Knees

The fear around deep squats is one of the most persistent myths in the gym. You hear it from well-meaning friends, old-school trainers, and countless online forums. This guide clears up the confusion with a direct answer and a clear path forward.

Key Takeaways

• Deep squats are not inherently bad for healthy knees; poor form and mobility are the real culprits.
• Partial squats can create more dangerous shearing force on the knee joint than full-depth squats.
• The safest point in a squat is at the bottom, where compressive forces strengthen cartilage and ligaments.
• Knee pain during squats almost always points to an issue elsewhere, typically poor ankle or hip mobility.
• You should only squat as deep as your body allows while keeping your heels down and your spine neutral.
• A simple wall test, taking less than 30 seconds, can reveal if your ankles are limiting your squat depth.

Why the “Deep Squats Are Bad” Myth Exists

The debate over whether are deep squats actually bad for your knees comes from a fundamental misunderstanding of physics. People feel pressure in their knees during a squat and assume more depth equals more danger. The opposite is true. The forces acting on your knee change dramatically as you descend, and the bottom of the squat is actually the safest place for your ligaments.

There are two main forces at play: shear force and compressive force.

Shear force is a sliding, tearing force. Imagine trying to snap a pencil by pushing on both ends in opposite directions. This is the force that damages ligaments like your ACL and PCL. Shear force on the knee is highest during a partial squat, when your knee is bent around 90 degrees and your quads are pulling your tibia (shin bone) forward.

Compressive force is a squeezing force. Imagine standing on top of a soda can. This is the force your body experiences at the bottom of a deep squat. Your hamstrings and glutes press against your calves, creating a wrapping effect that stabilizes the entire knee joint. This compression is healthy-it pushes fluid into the cartilage, keeping it nourished and strong.

When you only perform half-squats or quarter-squats, you repeatedly load your knees at the point of maximum shear force while never reaching the stable, compressive bottom position. This is why many people who only do partial reps develop knee pain over time. They are training in the most unstable part of the movement.

A full, deep squat moves through that high-shear zone and settles into a stable bottom position where the load is shared between the hips, glutes, and hamstrings-not just the knees. The problem isn't depth; it's poor form or stopping in the most vulnerable position.

Build stronger legs without the pain.

Track your form and lifts. Know you're getting stronger the right way.

Start your 7 day free trial

The Real Culprits Behind Knee Pain From Squats

If deep squats aren't the problem, why do your knees hurt? The pain you feel is a symptom, not the root cause. Your knee is a simple hinge joint caught between your ankle and your hip. When one of those more complex joints doesn't do its job, the knee takes the punishment. Here are the four most common culprits.

1. Poor Ankle Mobility (Dorsiflexion)

Ankle dorsiflexion is your ability to pull your toes up toward your shins. If your ankles are tight, you can't keep your heels on the ground as you squat deep. Your body has to compensate. Either your heels lift, making you unstable, or your knees slide excessively forward, creating massive shear force. This is the number one reason people experience sharp pain at the front of their knee.

The 5-Inch Wall Test: Kneel facing a wall. Place your big toe 5 inches away from it. Without lifting your heel, try to touch your knee to the wall. If you can't, your ankle mobility is limiting your squat.

2. Weak Hip Abductors (Knee Valgus)

Knee valgus is when your knees collapse inward during a squat. It's a classic sign of weak gluteus medius muscles, which are responsible for stabilizing your pelvis and keeping your femurs (thigh bones) externally rotated. When these muscles don't fire, your knees drift inward, stretching the MCL (a key ligament on the inside of your knee) and grinding the cartilage under your kneecap. This often feels like a dull ache on the inside of the knee.

3. A “Butt Wink” (Pelvic Tilt)

As you approach the bottom of your squat, watch to see if your lower back rounds and your pelvis tucks underneath you. This is called a butt wink. It's a clear signal that you have squatted past your active range of motion. This happens when your hips run out of room or your hamstrings are tight. This rounding transfers the load from your legs directly to your lumbar spine and alters the mechanics at the knee, creating instability.

4. Ego Lifting

This is the simplest and most common problem. You load the bar with more weight than you can control with perfect form. Your body defaults to its strongest-but not safest-movement patterns. Your chest falls, your hips shoot up, your knees cave in, and your lower back rounds. The weight gets moved, but at the cost of your joint health. Lower the weight by 20% and focus on perfect, controlled reps.

How to Perform a Safe Deep Squat (Step-by-Step)

Mastering the squat is about building a consistent, repeatable setup. Don't just walk up to the bar and go. Follow these steps every single time, even with an empty barbell, to build the right habits.

Step 1: Find Your Stance

Start with your feet about shoulder-width apart, with your toes pointed slightly outward (between 5 and 15 degrees). This is just a starting point. Your ideal stance depends on your unique hip anatomy. Some people need a wider stance, while others feel better narrower. Your goal is to find a position where you can reach full depth without your lower back rounding or heels lifting.

Step 2: Master the Brace

Before you even begin to descend, take a big breath of air *into your belly*, not your chest. Imagine you're about to get punched in the stomach. This creates intra-abdominal pressure, which acts like a natural weightlifting belt, stabilizing your spine and making the entire movement safer and stronger. Hold this brace throughout the entire repetition.

Step 3: Initiate With Your Hips and Knees

Think of the squat as sitting back into a small chair. Initiate the movement by breaking at your hips and knees at the same time. Push your hips back as your knees bend and travel forward. Your torso will naturally lean forward; this is necessary to keep the bar over your mid-foot. The goal is to keep your chest up and your spine neutral.

Step 4: Control the Descent (The Negative)

Don't just drop into the bottom of the squat. Control the descent over a 2 to 3-second count. This builds stability, muscle, and control. Think about actively pulling yourself into the bottom position using your hip flexors. Go as deep as your mobility allows while keeping your heels flat and your spine straight.

Step 5: Drive Up with Your Glutes

From the bottom, think about driving your upper back into the bar and spreading the floor apart with your feet. This cue helps engage your glutes and prevents your knees from caving in. Drive your hips and chest up at the same rate until you are standing tall. Exhale at the top, and then repeat the bracing sequence for the next rep.

Your squat progress. All in one place.

Every workout logged. Proof you're building strength safely and effectively.

Start your 7 day free trial

What to Do If You Have Knee Pain Now

If you're currently experiencing knee pain, the first rule is to stop doing what hurts. Pushing through sharp pain is a recipe for chronic injury. Instead, take a step back and rebuild your foundation.

1. Regress the Movement to a Pain-Free Level

The best tool for this is the box squat. Set up a box or bench at a height where you can squat down, touch it, and stand back up with zero pain. This might be a high box where your thighs are well above parallel. That’s your new starting point.

Your goal is to perform 3-4 sets of 8-10 reps at this height, focusing on perfect form. Every week, try to lower the box by half an inch. Over 4-8 weeks, you will gradually increase your depth while reinforcing safe movement patterns.

2. Focus on Mobility Every Day

Spend 5-10 minutes before every workout on mobility. Don't treat it as an afterthought. Your two biggest priorities are likely ankles and hips.

• For Ankles: Perform deep goblet squat holds. Hold a light dumbbell (10-25 lbs) and sink into the bottom of a squat. Use your elbows to gently press your knees out and focus on driving your heels into the floor. Hold for 30-60 seconds.
• For Hips: Do banded clamshells. Lie on your side with a mini-band around your knees. With your knees bent and feet together, lift your top knee against the band's resistance. Perform 15-20 reps per side to activate your glute medius.

3. Strengthen Supporting Muscles

Your knee pain is often a sign that other muscles aren't doing their job. Shift some of your training focus to strengthening your posterior chain-the glutes and hamstrings.

Incorporate exercises like Romanian Deadlifts (RDLs), glute bridges, and hip thrusts. These movements build the muscles that support your hips and take pressure off your knees. Bulgarian split squats are also excellent for building single-leg stability and strength in a knee-friendly way.

Expect this process to take time. You are retraining years of movement patterns. Be patient, be consistent, and listen to your body. You can build a strong, resilient, and pain-free squat in 2-3 months.

Frequently Asked Questions

How deep should I squat?

You should squat as deep as you can while maintaining a neutral spine and keeping your heels flat on the floor. For most people, this means the crease of your hip should pass just below the top of your knee. This is often called “squatting to parallel.” Forcing depth beyond your mobility leads to injury.

Are goblet squats safer for knees?

Yes, for most beginners, goblet squats are safer. Holding a weight in front of your body acts as a counterbalance, making it easier to sit back and keep an upright torso. This naturally improves form and reduces stress on the lower back and knees, making it an excellent teaching tool.

What if I can't squat deep due to my anatomy?

That's perfectly fine. Not everyone has the hip structure for an ass-to-grass squat, and forcing it is a mistake. Work within your pain-free range of motion. You can supplement with exercises like the leg press, Bulgarian split squats, or lunges to ensure you're still achieving full muscle development.

Do knee sleeves help?

Knee sleeves provide compression and warmth, which can increase blood flow and make the joint feel more stable. They can be helpful for managing minor aches. However, they are a tool, not a crutch. They will not fix bad form or prevent an injury caused by poor mechanics.

Is the Smith machine a good alternative?

No, the Smith machine is often worse for your knees than a free-weight squat. It locks you into a fixed, perfectly vertical bar path that is unnatural for the human body. This can increase dangerous shear forces on the knees and place unnecessary stress on your spine. Learning with free weights is superior.