Are Arm Size Determined by Genetics Reddit

You've been doing curls for months, but your arms just aren't growing. You scroll through Reddit, see guys with massive 18-inch arms, and start to wonder if you just lost the genetic lottery. It's a frustrating feeling that can make you want to quit altogether. Let's settle this debate right now.

Key Takeaways

• Genetics determine your muscle shape and insertion points, but they do not set a hard limit on your potential arm size.
• Your training intensity, progressive overload, and consistency account for at least 70% of your arm growth results.
• To grow your arms, you must train your triceps just as hard, or harder, than your biceps, as they make up two-thirds of your upper arm mass.
• You must eat in a sustained calorie surplus of 300-500 calories per day to provide your body with the fuel to build new muscle tissue.
• Adding one full inch to your arms is a significant achievement that takes most intermediate lifters 6-12 months of dedicated, perfect training and nutrition.
• Focusing only on isolation curls is a failed strategy; heavy compound movements like rows and presses build the necessary strength foundation for arm growth.

How Much Do Genetics Actually Matter for Arm Size?

When you ask, "are arm size determined by genetics reddit," what you're really asking is, "Is my effort pointless?" You're doing the work, you're showing up, but the tape measure isn't moving. It feels like an invisible wall, and it's incredibly discouraging. The direct answer is that genetics play a role, but they are not the life sentence you think they are. Think of it as a 30/70 split: genetics account for about 30% of the outcome, while the other 70%-your training, nutrition, and recovery-is completely in your control.

Genetics primarily dictate two things: your muscle belly length and your insertion points.

Muscle Belly Length: This is the 'shape' of your muscle. Someone with a 'long' bicep belly will have a muscle that appears fuller and runs closer to the elbow. Someone with a 'short' belly will have a higher 'peak' but a larger gap between the end of their bicep and their forearm. You can't change this. A high-peak bicep can look incredibly impressive when flexed, but a long-belly bicep will look bigger in a t-shirt. Neither is better, just different.

Insertion Points: This is where your muscle's tendon connects to the bone. This can affect leverage and how 'big' a muscle looks relative to your frame. For example, someone with very small wrists and elbows will have arms that appear larger by contrast, even at the same measurement as someone with thicker joints.

Here's what genetics DO NOT determine: your ability to force hypertrophy (muscle growth). Every single person, regardless of muscle belly shape, can add inches to their arms by applying the correct stimulus and providing the right fuel. A person with 'bad' genetics who trains perfectly and eats perfectly will have much bigger arms than a person with 'elite' genetics who trains and eats poorly. Your work ethic is the great equalizer. Forget about your insertions. You can't change them. Focus on the 70% you can control.

Stop guessing if your arms can grow.

Track your lifts. See your strength go up every single week.

Start your 7 day free trial

Why Your Current Arm Workouts Are Failing

If you feel your genetics are holding you back, it's more likely that your strategy is flawed. Most people who complain about having small arms are making one of four critical mistakes. This isn't about training harder; it's about training smarter.

Mistake 1: You Only Care About Biceps

This is the single biggest mistake. Everyone wants a bicep peak, so they do endless sets of curls. Your triceps make up two-thirds of the mass of your upper arm. If you want bigger arms, you need to prioritize building massive triceps. Your arm workout should have at least as much volume for triceps as it does for biceps, if not more. A man with well-developed triceps and average biceps will have arms that look far bigger than a man with great biceps and weak triceps.

Mistake 2: You're Doing 'Junk Volume'

Swinging a 40-pound dumbbell for sloppy reps isn't building muscle; it's building ego and momentum. Ten perfect, controlled reps with a 25-pound dumbbell will build more muscle than 10 sloppy reps with a 40. Every rep should be focused. You should feel the target muscle contract and stretch. If you're just moving weight from point A to point B, you're wasting your time. Slow down, control the negative (the lowering part of the lift), and make the muscle do the work.

Mistake 3: You're Ignoring Compound Lifts

You cannot build 17-inch arms on a 135-pound body. Your body grows as a system. Heavy compound movements like weighted pull-ups, barbell rows, bench presses, and overhead presses are the foundation of strength and size. These lifts build a strong base and trigger a systemic growth response that isolation exercises simply can't match. Your arm isolation work is the finishing touch, not the whole construction project. Get your bench press to 185 lbs and your barbell row to 155 lbs, and your arms will have no choice but to grow.

Mistake 4: You're Not Eating to Grow

This is the non-negotiable rule of muscle building. You cannot build a house without bricks. If you are not in a calorie surplus, you will not build any significant amount of muscle. Period. 'Eating clean' is not enough. You need to be consuming 300-500 more calories than your body burns every single day. Along with that, you need at least 1 gram of protein per pound of bodyweight. For a 160-pound person, that's 160 grams of protein and roughly 2,800-3,000 calories daily, just to start.

The 3-Step Plan to Maximize Your Genetic Potential

Stop blaming genetics and start executing a plan that works. Building impressive arms isn't complicated, but it demands precision and consistency. Follow these three steps without deviation.

Step 1: Implement True Progressive Overload

Progressive overload is the absolute law of muscle growth. It means doing more over time. Not just lifting until you're tired, but systematically increasing the demand on your muscles. It's simple math.

• Track Every Lift: Write down the exercise, the weight, and the reps for every single set.
• Beat Your Logbook: Each week, your only goal is to do better than last week. If you did barbell curls with 60 lbs for 8 reps last Monday, this Monday you must do 9 reps, or you must use 65 lbs. There is no other option. This is how you force growth.

This small, incremental progress is what adds up to inches on your arms over a year. Without tracking, you're just guessing and staying stagnant.

Step 2: Structure Your Training for Frequency and Intensity

Stop doing one 'arm day' a week. Muscles grow better when stimulated more frequently. Train arms directly 2 times per week, with at least 48 hours of rest in between. A good split is Upper/Lower or Push/Pull/Legs.

Here is a sample arm-focused routine to add to your workouts:

Workout A (e.g., Monday - Upper Body Day)

• Close-Grip Bench Press: 3 sets of 6-10 reps (Triceps focus)
• Barbell Curls: 3 sets of 6-10 reps (Biceps focus)
• Tricep Pushdowns: 3 sets of 10-15 reps (Triceps)
• Incline Dumbbell Curls: 3 sets of 10-15 reps (Biceps)

Workout B (e.g., Thursday - Upper Body Day)

• Overhead Tricep Extensions: 3 sets of 8-12 reps (Triceps long head)
• Hammer Curls: 3 sets of 8-12 reps (Biceps & Brachialis)
• Dips (or Bench Dips): 3 sets to failure (Triceps)
• Concentration Curls: 3 sets of 12-15 reps (Biceps peak)

This provides 12 total work sets for both biceps and triceps per week, hitting them with both heavy compound movements and lighter, high-rep isolation work. This is the sweet spot for growth for most people.

Step 3: Fuel for Growth With Specific Numbers

Your training is the signal, but food is the resource for building. You must eat for the arms you want.

• Find Your Maintenance Calories: Use an online TDEE (Total Daily Energy Expenditure) calculator. Be honest about your activity level.
• Create Your Surplus: Add 300-500 calories to that number. If your maintenance is 2,500, you will eat 2,800-3,000 calories every day.
• Hit Your Protein Target: Eat 1 gram of protein per pound of your target body weight. If you weigh 160 lbs and want to be 170 lbs, eat 170 grams of protein daily.

This is not optional. If you fail to do this, your workouts will not produce the size you want. You will get stronger, but you will not get significantly bigger.

Your arm growth. All in one place.

Every curl and pushdown logged. Proof you are getting bigger and stronger.

Start your 7 day free trial

What to Expect: A Realistic Arm Growth Timeline

Building muscle takes a frustratingly long time. Setting realistic expectations is crucial to staying motivated when you don't see changes overnight. Your body doesn't work on your schedule.

The First 3-6 Months (Newbie Gains):

If you are a beginner or have been training improperly, this is your golden window. By implementing the plan above, you can realistically expect to add 0.5 to 1 full inch to your arms. Your body is hyper-responsive to the new stimulus. Enjoy it, because it won't last forever.

Months 6-18 (Intermediate Phase):

Growth slows down dramatically. At this point, your body has adapted. Gaining another 0.5 to 1 inch on your arms during this entire year is a fantastic result. This is where most people get discouraged and quit. It requires near-perfect consistency with your training and diet. Every missed workout and every week of poor eating stalls this progress.

Year 2 and Beyond (Advanced Lifter):

Progress is measured in millimeters, not inches. Adding a quarter-inch to your arms in a year is a monumental achievement for an advanced lifter. This is the reality of natural muscle building. The guys on magazine covers with 20-inch arms have been training for over a decade with world-class genetics and, in many cases, pharmaceutical assistance.

A Note on Measurement:

Always measure your arms 'cold' (before a workout), flexed, at the same time of day. A 'pumped' arm after a workout can be 0.5-1 inch larger due to blood flow, which is temporary and not real growth. Don't fool yourself with a post-workout measurement.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a good arm size for my height?

A good natural arm size for a lean individual is often related to wrist size. A common benchmark is that your flexed arm measurement can be about 10 inches larger than your wrist measurement. For most men between 5'8" and 6'0", achieving a lean 16-17 inch arm is an excellent and realistic long-term goal.

Do I need to train arms directly if I do compound lifts?

Yes. While heavy rows, pull-ups, and presses provide a great stimulus, they are not enough to maximize arm growth. Direct isolation work is necessary to provide the targeted volume and intensity needed to force your biceps and triceps to their full potential. Think of compounds as the foundation and isolation as the detailed sculpting.

How often should I train arms for maximum growth?

For most natural lifters, training arms directly 2 times per week is the sweet spot. This allows for sufficient stimulus to trigger growth and enough recovery time (at least 48 hours) before the next session. Any more than 3 times per week often leads to recovery issues and diminishing returns.

Is it better to use heavy weight or high reps for arms?

Both. Your arms, like other muscles, are composed of different fiber types that respond to different stimuli. You should include heavy work in the 6-10 rep range (like barbell curls and close-grip bench) and lighter work in the 12-20 rep range (like cable pushdowns and concentration curls) for complete development.

Can I get big arms with just dumbbells at home?

Absolutely. You can build impressive arms with just a set of adjustable dumbbells and a bench. The key isn't the equipment, but the principle of progressive overload. As long as you can continue to add weight or reps over time, you can force your muscles to grow, regardless of where you train.