How to Choose the Right Deadlift Variation for You

The 2-Minute Test That Chooses Your Deadlift For You

The secret to how to choose the right deadlift variation for you isn't about your goals or what you see influencers doing; it's about your hip structure, which you can determine with a simple 2-minute test. You're probably frustrated because you tried the 'standard' deadlift, and it hurt your back or just felt incredibly awkward. You feel like you're doing something wrong, but you can't figure out what. The good news is, your body isn't broken, you're just trying to force a shape it wasn't built for. Your hip anatomy-specifically your femur length and hip socket depth-is the number one factor determining your ideal deadlift stance. Forget everything else for a moment and do this right now. Grab a light dumbbell or kettlebell (10-25 pounds is fine) and perform a goblet squat. Go as deep as you comfortably can while keeping your chest up. Now, look down. Where are your elbows in relation to your knees?

1. Elbows are inside your knees: Your anatomy is likely well-suited for a Conventional Deadlift. Your torso can stay upright enough without your knees getting in the way of your arms.
2. Elbows are bumping into your knees: Your body is fighting for space. This is a huge sign that a Conventional Deadlift will always feel awkward and potentially strain your lower back. You are a prime candidate for a Sumo or Trap-Bar Deadlift.

This simple test cuts through 90% of the confusion. It's not about being 'good' or 'bad' at a lift; it's about matching the exercise to your unique skeletal structure. Forcing a conventional stance when your body is built for sumo is like trying to write with your non-dominant hand-you can do it, but it will be messy, inefficient, and frustrating.

Why Your Body Fights the 'Wrong' Deadlift (It's Just Physics)

If you've ever felt your lower back scream during a deadlift, it's likely because you were using a variation that works against your body's natural leverage. The number one mistake lifters make is believing all deadlifts are created equal and then blaming their 'bad genetics' or 'weak back' when one feels terrible. The reality is much simpler: it's physics. Each variation changes the mechanics of the lift, placing stress on different parts of your body. Understanding this is the key to lifting heavy and staying pain-free. A 315-pound deadlift can feel light with the right mechanics or impossible with the wrong ones.

Think of your body as a crane. The position of the crane's arm (your torso) and the length of the cable (your arms) determine how much it can lift safely.

• Conventional Deadlift: This variation forces a more horizontal back angle. For someone with long legs and a short torso, this means their hips start very high, and their back is almost parallel to the floor. To lift the bar, they have to put immense shear force on their lumbar spine. It's a mechanically disadvantaged and risky position for this body type. This is why they feel it all in their lower back.
• Sumo Deadlift: By taking a wide stance, you effectively 'shorten' your legs and open up your hips. This allows your torso to be much more upright. A more vertical torso reduces the shear force on the lower back by as much as 10% compared to a conventional pull. It turns the lift from a pure 'pull' into a 'push' with your legs, which is a much stronger and safer position for many people.
• Trap Bar Deadlift: This is the ultimate biomechanical 'cheat code.' The handles are at your sides, not in front of you. This aligns the weight with your center of gravity perfectly. There is almost no shear force on the spine. It's a hybrid between a squat and a deadlift, making it the easiest to learn and the safest option for anyone with back concerns. A 225-pound lift on a trap bar puts significantly less strain on the spine than the same weight on a straight bar.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 4 Deadlift Variations: Your Personal Blueprint

Now that you've done the 2-minute test and understand the physics, let's build your blueprint. Don't try to master all four. Pick one primary strength variation based on your test results and goals. You can use another as an accessory, but focus is key. Trying to do everything at once means you'll get good at nothing.

### The Conventional Deadlift: For Raw Posterior Power

This is for you if: You passed the 'elbows inside knees' test, have decent mobility, and want to build a brutally strong posterior chain (glutes, hamstrings, and especially the spinal erectors). This is the classic test of raw strength.

How to execute: Stand with your feet hip-width apart, shins about 1 inch from the bar. Hinge at your hips and bend your knees to grip the bar just outside your shins. Keep your back flat, chest up, and pull the slack out of the bar. To initiate the lift, think 'push the floor away' with your legs. Your hips and shoulders should rise at the same time. Lock out by squeezing your glutes.

Starting point: An average male can start with 135 pounds. An average female can start with 65-95 pounds. Focus on perfect form for 5 reps.

### The Sumo Deadlift: For Long Legs and Bigger Glutes

This is for you if: Your elbows bumped your knees in the test. This is the best option for those with long femurs. It also emphasizes the glutes and quads more than conventional, making it a great choice for hypertrophy.

How to execute: Stand with your feet very wide, toes pointing towards the weight plates. Your shins should be vertical when you grip the bar. Take a narrow grip, inside your legs. Drop your hips down, keeping your chest tall and torso upright. To initiate the lift, think 'spread the floor apart' with your feet and push. This engages your quads and glutes powerfully.

Starting point: Your sumo will feel weaker at first. Reduce your conventional weight by 20-30% and start there. If you pulled 225 lbs conventionally, start with 155-185 lbs for sumo.

### The Trap Bar Deadlift: The Safest Starting Point

This is for you if: You're a beginner, have a history of back issues, or are an athlete who wants power development with minimal injury risk. It's the most user-friendly variation.

How to execute: Step inside the bar. Your feet should be hip-width apart. Grab the neutral-grip handles, sit your hips back as if sitting in a chair, and keep your chest up. Drive through your feet and stand up. It's that simple. The high handles also reduce the range of motion, making it even safer.

Starting point: This is your strongest pull. You can likely lift 10-15% more on a trap bar than a conventional bar. A beginner male can often start with 135-185 lbs comfortably.

### The Romanian Deadlift (RDL): The Hamstring Builder

This is for you if: You want to specifically target your hamstrings and glutes for muscle growth. This is an *accessory* lift, not a primary strength movement. You do this *after* your main deadlift or on a separate day.

How to execute: Start by holding the bar at the top. With a soft bend in your knees (not locked), push your hips back as far as you can. Imagine trying to touch a wall behind you with your butt. Let the bar slide down your thighs until you feel a deep stretch in your hamstrings, usually to about mid-shin. Do not let your back round. Squeeze your glutes to return to the starting position.

Starting point: Go light. Use 30-40% of your main deadlift weight. For someone who deadlifts 315 lbs, their RDLs will be in the 95-135 lb range for 8-12 reps.

Your First 4 Weeks on a New Deadlift: What to Expect

Switching your deadlift variation feels like starting over, and that's exactly the point. Your ego will take a hit, but your body will thank you. Here is the honest timeline for what will happen when you commit to the right variation for your body.

Week 1-2: It Will Feel Weak and Awkward.

Expect a 20-30% drop in the weight you can lift. If you pulled 300 lbs conventionally, you might struggle with 225 lbs in a sumo stance. This is not a loss of strength. It's a lack of motor control. Your brain and nervous system are learning a completely new movement pattern. Your only job during these two weeks is to drill the form with lighter weight for sets of 5-8 reps. Do not test your 1-rep max. You will feel sore in new places; for sumo, this will be your adductors and glutes. This is a good sign.

Week 3-4: The 'Click'.

Sometime during this period, a rep will suddenly feel smooth and powerful. This is the 'click' where the motor pattern becomes ingrained. The weight will start to feel lighter, and you'll be able to add 5-10 pounds to the bar each session. Your confidence will grow as the movement feels natural instead of forced. By the end of week 4, you should be close to or even surpassing the weights you were struggling with on your old, incorrect variation.

Warning Signs vs. Progress:

Good progress is feeling muscle soreness in your glutes, hamstrings, and upper back 24-48 hours after lifting. Bad progress is sharp, shooting pain in your lower back or hips *during* the lift. Muscle soreness is a sign of growth; joint pain is a stop sign. If you feel joint pain, lower the weight by 50% and fix your form. If your lower back is rounding, the weight is too heavy, period.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.

Frequently Asked Questions

### The Best Variation for Glute Growth

For pure muscle growth in the glutes, the Sumo Deadlift and the Romanian Deadlift (RDL) are superior. The wide stance of the sumo deadlift increases glute activation, while the deep stretch of the RDL creates significant mechanical tension, a key driver for hypertrophy.

### Deadlifting with a History of Back Pain

Start with the Trap Bar Deadlift. Its mechanics, with the weight aligned at your sides, place the least amount of stress on the lumbar spine. Once you build a strong foundation and core stability, you can progress to the Sumo Deadlift, which is the next safest option.

### Conventional vs. Sumo for Raw Strength

Neither is universally better for strength. The best one for you is the one that fits your body's mechanics. A lifter built for sumo will always pull more with a sumo stance, and vice-versa. Don't choose based on what world-record powerlifters do; choose based on your 2-minute test.

### Using Lifting Straps for Deadlifts

Use straps strategically. Do not use them for your warm-up sets. Use them only for your heaviest 1-2 sets where your grip fails before your back or legs do. This allows you to overload your posterior chain while still training your grip strength with the lighter sets.

### How Often to Deadlift

For building maximum strength, performing your primary deadlift variation heavy once per week is the gold standard for most lifters. A second, lighter day can be used for an accessory like RDLs for 8-12 reps, but attempting two max-effort deadlift sessions a week is a fast track to burnout.