Why Do I Feel Hamstrings More on Leg Press Than Leg Curl

Why “Feeling” Your Hamstrings Is Lying to You

The reason why you feel hamstrings more on leg press than leg curl is because the leg press creates a deep, loaded stretch that causes more muscle damage and soreness, while the leg curl provides a better peak contraction but less stretch. You're not doing it wrong, and your body isn't strange. You've just discovered the difference between two powerful types of muscle stimulus, and the soreness you're feeling is misleading you.

It’s one of the most confusing feelings in the gym. You finish a set of leg curls-the exercise supposedly designed *specifically* for hamstrings-and feel almost nothing. Then you move to the leg press, aiming for your quads, and the next day your hamstrings are screaming. It makes you question if you even know how to train. The truth is, the sensation of Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness (DOMS), which most of us call "feeling it," is more strongly associated with a muscle being stretched under load than it is with the muscle simply contracting.

The leg press, when you use a high foot position and a deep range of motion, puts your hamstrings through a massive loaded stretch at the hip. This process creates tiny micro-tears in the muscle fibers, which is a primary driver of muscle growth and the main reason for that deep soreness you feel 24-48 hours later. The leg curl, on the other hand, isolates the *other* function of the hamstring-bending the knee. It creates an intense squeeze or "peak contraction" at the top, but it doesn't stretch the muscle belly in the same way. Both are valuable, but only one gives you that profound next-day soreness you're interpreting as a better workout.

Stop guessing if your workout is working.

Track your lifts and reps. See your strength grow week by week.

The Two Jobs of Your Hamstrings (And Why Leg Curls Only Do One)

To finally solve this puzzle, you have to understand that your hamstrings aren't one simple muscle; they're a group of muscles with two distinct jobs. The reason you're confused is that you've been using two exercises that each focus on only one of those jobs. Your hamstrings don't just bend your knee-that's only half the story.

The two primary functions of the hamstring muscle group are:

1. Knee Flexion: Bending your knee, like bringing your heel toward your glute. This is the *only* function a leg curl machine trains.
2. Hip Extension: Straightening your hip, like when you stand up from a squat, push your hips forward in a deadlift, or drive the sled up on a leg press.

The leg curl is a pure isolation exercise for knee flexion. It's fantastic for creating a powerful squeeze at the top of the movement and forcing blood into the muscle. However, it completely ignores the hip extension function. This is why it can feel less impactful, especially if your form isn't perfect.

Conversely, the leg press (with high foot placement) is a compound movement that heavily involves hip extension. As you lower the weight, your knee comes toward your chest, and your hip flexes. This puts the hamstring into a deep, loaded stretch. When you press the weight back up, you are performing hip extension. This stretch under load is known as stretch-mediated hypertrophy, and it's an incredibly powerful signal for muscle growth. It's also what causes the most significant muscle soreness, which is precisely what you are feeling.

Think of it this way: the leg curl is like a bicep concentration curl, focusing on a tight squeeze. The leg press is like the bottom half of a heavy chin-up, where your bicep is stretched under the full weight of your body. Both build muscle, but they create very different sensations. You need both to fully develop the muscle.

Your progress. Proven in the numbers.

Every workout logged. Proof you're getting stronger, not just trying harder.

The 2-Part Protocol for Complete Hamstring Growth

Knowing the theory is one thing; building bigger, stronger hamstrings is another. You need to stop thinking of it as "leg press vs. leg curl" and start thinking of it as a complete program that masters both knee flexion and hip extension. This two-part protocol will force your hamstrings to grow by targeting both functions with perfect technique. Stop guessing and follow these steps precisely.

Part 1: Master the Leg Curl for Peak Contraction

Most people perform leg curls with sloppy form, turning it into a useless momentum-based exercise. We're going to fix that. The goal here isn't to lift the entire weight stack; it's to force the hamstring to do 100% of the work.

1. Anchor Your Hips: On a lying or seated leg curl, your hips will try to lift off the pad as the weight gets heavy. This is your body cheating by using your lower back and glutes. Actively drive your hips down into the pad throughout the entire set. This is the most important cue.
2. Use a 3-Second Negative: The eccentric (lowering) phase is where you build muscle and control. Curl the weight up in 1 second, squeeze hard at the top, and then take a full 3 seconds to lower it back to the start. If you just let the weight drop, you're wasting half the rep.
3. Point Your Toes (Slightly): Pointing your toes away from you (plantar flexion) can help disengage the calf muscles, which often try to assist in the movement. Focus on pulling with the muscle right under your glute.

Your new prescription: 3 sets of 12-15 reps with a 3-second negative on every single rep. The weight you use will drop by 20-30%, and that's the point. It will burn in a way you've never felt before.

Part 2: Optimize the Leg Press for a Loaded Stretch

Now, let's take the exercise you already "feel" and make it even more effective for targeting the hamstrings and glutes. Small adjustments make a huge difference.

1. High and Wide Foot Placement: Place your feet as high on the platform as you can without your heels lifting off. Position them slightly wider than shoulder-width with your toes pointed out about 15 degrees. This shifts the emphasis from your quads to your posterior chain (hamstrings and glutes).
2. Control the Descent: Don't just let the sled crash down. Control the negative over 2-3 seconds, focusing on the deep stretch you feel in your hamstrings as your knees come towards your shoulders.
3. Drive Through Your Heels: Initiate the push by thinking about driving your heels through the platform. This ensures you're leading with your hamstrings and glutes, not just your quads.

Your new prescription: 4 sets of 8-12 reps. Go as deep as you can *without* your lower back rounding and lifting off the seat pad. The stretch is the goal.

Your New Hamstring Workout

Combine these for a complete session, performed twice a week:

• Leg Press (Hamstring-Focused): 4 sets x 8-12 reps
• Lying or Seated Leg Curl: 3 sets x 12-15 reps (with 3-second negative)
• Romanian Deadlift (RDL): 3 sets x 8-10 reps (This is the ultimate hip extension exercise and is non-negotiable for hamstring development)

Your First 4 Weeks: Less Confusion, More Growth

When you switch to this intentional style of training, things will feel different. You need to know what to expect so you don't get discouraged and revert to your old habits. The goal is to trade confusing soreness for predictable progress.

Week 1-2: Your leg curls will feel incredibly difficult with the slow, controlled 3-second negative. You will use significantly less weight-maybe 50-60% of what you used before. This is a sign you're doing it right. You are removing momentum and forcing the hamstring to work in isolation. The soreness from leg curls will be a sharp, localized burn, while the leg press will still give you that deep, achy feeling. This is the feeling of targeting both functions correctly.

Month 1: By week 4, you will feel a much stronger mind-muscle connection on your leg curls. You'll be able to mentally "find" the hamstring and make it fire. You should have already increased the weight on your controlled leg curls by 5-10 pounds from where you started in week 1. Your RDL form will feel more stable, and the weight will start moving up.

Month 2-3: This is where the visual changes happen. You'll notice more separation between your hamstring and quad, and a fuller look to the back of your leg, often called the "hamstring sweep." You're no longer just building the lower part of the muscle with leg curls; you're building the thick upper portion near the glute with heavy hip extension on the leg press and RDLs. The confusion is gone. You now have a system that works.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Role of Soreness in Muscle Growth

Soreness (DOMS) is a sign that you've subjected your muscles to a novel stimulus or significant stress, often from a loaded stretch. It is correlated with muscle damage, which can lead to growth, but it is not a requirement. You can absolutely build muscle without being cripplingly sore after every workout. Consistent, progressive overload is far more important than chasing soreness.

Seated vs. Lying Leg Curls

The main difference is the position of your hip. In a seated leg curl, your hip is flexed, which puts the hamstring in a more lengthened position from the start. This can lead to slightly better muscle growth for some people. However, the best machine is the one that allows you to anchor your hips and execute the movement with perfect, controlled form. Both are excellent choices.

Hamstring Training Frequency

Because they are a large, powerful muscle group composed of fast-twitch fibers, hamstrings respond well to heavy training and recover relatively quickly. For most people, training them directly with intensity 2 times per week provides the best balance of stimulus and recovery for optimal growth. For example, a Monday and a Thursday session.

Why Romanian Deadlifts Are Essential

While the leg press trains hip extension, the Romanian Deadlift (RDL) is the gold standard. It allows you to overload the hamstrings in their stretched position with heavy free weights, which is crucial for building density and strength. It perfectly complements the knee flexion work from leg curls, making it a non-negotiable part of any serious hamstring program.

Feeling Calves or Glutes Instead

If you feel your calves taking over on leg curls, focus on pointing your toes away from you (plantar flexion) to deactivate them. If you feel your glutes too much on a hamstring-focused leg press, make sure your lower back and hips are staying glued to the pad. If your hips lift at the bottom, your glutes are taking over to compensate for poor positioning.