Can You Do Deadlifts on a Smith Machine Reddit

Yes, You Can Deadlift on a Smith Machine (But It's Not a Deadlift)

To answer the question 'can you do deadlifts on a smith machine reddit,' yes, you physically can, but it forces your body into an unnatural, fixed path that removes nearly 100% of the stabilization work. This makes it a poor substitute for a real deadlift and, in many cases, more dangerous for your lower back. You're probably asking this because the free-weight area is intimidating, packed with people who look like they were born with a 45-pound plate in their hand. Or maybe your gym is a commercial one, full of machines and lacking barbells. You see the Smith machine as a safe middle ground, a way to do the “king of exercises” with training wheels. I get it. The problem is, those training wheels are bolted to the floor. A real deadlift with a barbell isn't just about lifting weight up and down. It's about controlling that weight in three-dimensional space. Your body makes thousands of micro-adjustments to keep the bar, and yourself, balanced. This is what builds true, functional strength. The Smith machine eliminates all of that. It turns a complex, full-body movement into a simple, two-dimensional hinge. It's not a deadlift; it's a different, less effective exercise that happens to share the same name. The biggest issue is the bar path. A proper barbell deadlift has a slight 'S' curve. The bar starts over your mid-foot, moves slightly back as it clears your knees, and then moves up and back as you lock out your hips. A Smith machine forces a perfectly straight vertical line. This means you either have to scrape your shins raw or your lower back has to round to get the bar around your knees, putting your spine in a compromised position. You're not learning the movement; you're just loading a bad pattern.

The Physics of Why a Fixed Path Makes You Weaker

The reason a Smith machine deadlift fails is simple physics. Your body is a system of levers, not a piston. It's designed to move naturally, not along a fixed track. When you lift a free barbell, your central nervous system fires up dozens of stabilizer muscles in your core, hips, and back to control the weight. These are the muscles that protect your spine and transfer force from your legs to the bar. They are what make you strong outside the gym. A Smith machine does their job for them. The guide rods provide all the stability. As a result, those crucial muscles go dormant. You can lift more weight on the Smith machine, which feels great for the ego, but it's fool's gold. You're building display strength, not functional strength. Imagine two people. Person A deadlifts 225 pounds on a Smith machine. Person B deadlifts 185 pounds with a free barbell. If you ask both to help you move a heavy couch, Person B will be stronger, more stable, and less likely to get hurt. Their body knows how to recruit and coordinate muscle to move an awkward, unstable object. Person A's body only knows how to move a bar that's already been stabilized for them. The fixed path also forces your joints into unnatural angles. Because the bar can only go straight up and down, you have to adjust your body to the machine, instead of the other way around. For many people, this puts unnecessary shear force on the knees and lumbar spine. Over time, lifting heavy weight through this compromised pattern is a recipe for chronic pain and injury. It's not safer; it just feels safer because you can't drop the bar. The real danger isn't dropping the bar; it's the thousands of reps you perform with bad mechanics. That's the damage you don't feel until it's too late.

Stop guessing if you're getting stronger.

Track your lifts. See your strength grow week by week.

The 3-Step Protocol If a Smith Machine Is Your Only Option

If you're stuck in a gym with only Smith machines, don't just give up. You can still build a strong posterior chain. You just need to use the machine for what it's good at and add other movements to fill the gaps. Forget trying to replicate a conventional deadlift. Instead, follow this protocol.

Step 1: Reframe It as a Smith Machine RDL

The Romanian Deadlift (RDL) is a much better fit for the Smith machine's fixed path. It's a pure hip-hinge movement focused on the hamstrings and glutes, with less knee bend. This minimizes the risk to your lower back.

• Setup: Position your feet directly under the bar, shoulder-width apart. Unlock the bar and hold it at thigh level. Your knees should have a slight, soft bend-about 15-20 degrees-and remain there for the entire set.
• Execution: Push your hips straight back as if trying to touch a wall behind you. Let the bar slide down your thighs. Keep your back perfectly flat. Go down until you feel a deep stretch in your hamstrings, usually when the bar is just below your knees. Do not round your back to go lower.
• Return: Drive your hips forward to return to the starting position, squeezing your glutes at the top.
• Volume: Perform 3-4 sets of 10-15 reps. The goal is muscle hypertrophy and feeling the stretch, not lifting maximum weight.

Step 2: Add Smith Machine Rack Pulls

To target your upper back and traps, which get a lot of work in a real deadlift, use the Smith machine for rack pulls. This shortens the range of motion to the strongest, safest part of the lift.

• Setup: Set the safety stops on the Smith machine so the bar rests just below your kneecaps. Stand with your feet shoulder-width apart.
• Execution: Hinge at your hips and grab the bar with an overhand grip. Your back should be flat. Drive your hips forward and pull the bar up, standing tall and squeezing your shoulder blades together. Think about pulling with your back, not just your arms.
• Return: Control the weight back down to the safety stops. Let it come to a dead stop before starting the next rep.
• Volume: Perform 3 sets of 8-10 reps. You can go heavier on these than on the RDLs.

Step 3: Compensate with Unilateral and Core Work

Since the Smith machine robs you of all stabilization work, you must add it back in. This is not optional. This is what makes the program work.

• Dumbbell Lunges: These force each leg to work independently and require significant core stability to keep your balance. Perform 3 sets of 10-12 reps per leg. If your gym has dumbbells, it has a floor. No excuses.
• Planks: This is direct core training. Your core is the bridge between your upper and lower body. A weak core on a deadlift is like a bridge made of rope. Hold a standard plank for 3 sets, aiming for 45-60 seconds per set. If that's easy, do plank variations like lifting one leg.

Your First Month: From Smith Machine to Barbell

Using the Smith machine is a temporary solution. The real goal is to build the confidence and base strength to move to a free barbell. Here’s what your transition plan looks like. Don't expect your strength to transfer 1-to-1. Your 250-pound Smith machine 'deadlift' might translate to a shaky 135-pound barbell deadlift. This is not a step back; it's a step toward real strength.

• Weeks 1-2: Master the Compromise

Follow the 3-step protocol from the previous section. Do this twice a week. Your focus is not on weight, but on feel. You should feel a powerful stretch in your hamstrings during the RDLs and a strong contraction in your upper back during the rack pulls. Your core should feel worked from the planks and lunges. You are learning the individual components of the deadlift in a controlled environment.

• Week 3: Meet the Barbell

Find a standard 45-pound Olympic barbell. Forget the Smith machine for today. Your only goal is to practice the form of a conventional deadlift with an empty bar. Stand with the bar over your mid-foot. Hinge down, grab the bar, flatten your back, and lift by driving your feet through the floor. It will feel wobbly and awkward. This is your stabilizer muscles waking up for the first time. Film yourself from the side to check your form. Do 3-5 sets of 8 reps with just the bar. It's about motor learning, not load.

• Week 4 and Beyond: Progressive Overload

Stick with the barbell. Add 5 or 10 pounds to the bar each week. Your progress will feel slow compared to the Smith machine, but it's real. A 5-pound increase on a barbell deadlift is a bigger win than a 20-pound increase on a Smith machine. Within 2-3 months, you'll have built a solid foundation and a deadlift you can be proud of. You'll feel stronger not just in the gym, but in everyday life. That's a feeling no machine can give you.

Weeks of progress. All in one place.

Every workout logged. Proof you're getting stronger.

Frequently Asked Questions

Smith Machine Deadlifts vs. Barbell Deadlifts

A barbell deadlift is a superior full-body strength builder. It engages more muscles, including crucial stabilizers in your core and back, and allows for a natural bar path. A Smith machine deadlift uses a fixed path, which can create unnatural stress on the joints and builds less functional strength.

Safety of Smith Machine Deadlifts

While it prevents you from dropping the bar, the fixed vertical path can be riskier for your lower back and knees over the long term. It forces your body into a compromised position to move the bar around your knees, which is a fundamental flaw. Proper form with a lighter barbell is safer.

Muscles Worked in a Smith Machine Deadlift

It primarily targets the hamstrings and glutes. However, it significantly underutilizes the stabilizer muscles of the core, the lats (which help keep the bar close), and the smaller muscles in your back that are critical for spinal stability. You get maybe 70% of the muscular benefit.

Better Alternatives to Smith Machine Deadlifts

If you don't have access to a barbell, Dumbbell Romanian Deadlifts are an excellent alternative. They allow for a natural hinge pattern and require stabilization. Kettlebell swings are also fantastic for building explosive hip power. If you must use a machine, a 45-degree leg press is a better option for leg development.