Is Strict Press Better Than Push Press

Why "Better" Is the Wrong Question for Your Press

The answer to 'is strict press better than push press' is that you're asking the wrong question. It’s like asking if a hammer is better than a screwdriver. They are different tools for different jobs. The strict press is the superior tool for building raw shoulder muscle and pure pressing strength. The push press is the superior tool for developing explosive, total-body power, allowing you to move 20-30% more weight overhead. Choosing the right one depends entirely on your goal, not on which lift is arbitrarily "better."

If you're reading this, you've probably hit a wall. Your overhead press has been stuck at the same weight-maybe 95 pounds, maybe 155-for months. You see people in the gym using a little leg drive and hoisting huge weights, and you wonder if you're missing out. Or maybe you see a purist grinding out a slow, perfect strict press and think that's the only "real" way to build strength. The internet gives you conflicting advice, and you're left confused, stuck with the same numbers in your training log week after week. Let's clear that up right now. If your goal is bigger, stronger shoulders, the strict press is your primary lift. If your goal is athletic power and lifting the most weight possible, the push press is your focus. They aren't enemies; they are partners in building a powerful overhead press.

The 3-Inch Dip That Adds 50 Pounds to Your Press

The reason a push press feels so much stronger isn't magic; it's physics. The difference between the two lifts comes down to one simple action: the dip-and-drive. This tiny 3-to-4-inch bend in the knees completely changes the mechanics of the lift. In a strict press, 100% of the force comes from your deltoids and triceps. Your body is a rigid platform, and your shoulders do all the work. This is fantastic for isolating those muscles and forcing them to grow, but it creates a clear ceiling on how much you can lift.

Now, consider the push press. By dipping and explosively straightening your legs, you generate immense upward momentum on the barbell *before your arms even begin to press*. Your legs and hips are vastly stronger than your shoulders. That initial burst of power is what gets the bar past the most difficult part of the lift-the first few inches off your shoulders, often called the sticking point. Your shoulders and triceps then take over to lock out a weight they could never have started moving on their own. Think of it like pushing a stalled car. The hardest part is getting it to budge. Once it's rolling, it's much easier to keep it moving. The leg drive in a push press is the initial shove that gets the car rolling. This is why a person who can strict press 135 pounds might be able to push press 165 or even 175 pounds. You're not cheating; you're recruiting more muscle to contribute to a single, powerful effort.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 8-Week Protocol to Dominate Your Overhead Press

Stop guessing and start programming. This 8-week plan strategically combines both lifts to build a foundation of pure strength and then peak your power. It's designed for someone who trains 3-4 days per week and can dedicate two of those days to pressing.

Step 1: Find Your True Strict Press Numbers

Before you start, you need a baseline. Don't guess. Go to the gym, warm up thoroughly, and find your 5-rep max (5RM) on the strict press. This is the heaviest weight you can lift for 5 perfect reps without any leg drive or excessive back bend. For this example, let's say your 5RM is 115 pounds. This number is the foundation for the entire program. Write it down. Your estimated 1-rep max (1RM) is likely around 135 pounds, but we will work off the 5RM for safety and consistency.

Step 2: The Strength Foundation Block (Weeks 1-4)

For the first month, our priority is building the engine: your shoulders. We will use the strict press as the primary driver of strength and the push press to practice power and handle heavier loads.

• Day A (Primary Press Day):
• Strict Press: 3 sets of 5 reps @ 115 lbs (Your 5RM). Your goal is to complete all sets. If you fail, drop the weight by 5 lbs next week. If you succeed, add 5 lbs next week.
• Dumbbell Seated Press: 3 sets of 8-12 reps. Choose a weight that is challenging but allows for perfect form.
• Day B (Secondary Press Day):
• Push Press: 4 sets of 6 reps @ 115 lbs. Yes, the same weight as your strict press. This will feel light and explosive. Focus on the speed of the bar. The goal here is not to grind, but to move the weight as fast as possible.
• Lateral Raises: 3 sets of 15-20 reps with light weight to build shoulder width.

Step 3: The Power Peak Block (Weeks 5-8)

Now we flip the script. With a stronger base, we shift focus to expressing that strength as power. The push press becomes the primary lift.

• Day A (Primary Press Day):
• Push Press: Work up to a heavy 3-rep max for the day. This is not a true 3RM test every week. It's about handling heavy weight. Start with the bar and make 20-30 lb jumps until the weight feels heavy, then make 5-10 lb jumps. Your final set should be tough but not a grinder. Based on our example, you might be working up to 145-155 lbs for 3 reps.
• Strict Press: 3 sets of 8 reps @ 95 lbs (around 80% of your original 5RM). This is now an accessory lift to maintain your strength base.
• Day B (Secondary Press Day):
• Dumbbell Push Press: 3 sets of 8 reps per arm. This helps with stability and identifying imbalances.
• Face Pulls: 4 sets of 15 reps to keep your shoulders healthy.

Step 4: Avoid These Common Pressing Mistakes

Your progress will stall if you make these errors. Film yourself to be sure.

• The Squat-Press: The dip in a push press is a short, sharp 3-4 inch drop. It is not a quarter squat. Dipping too low wastes energy and ruins the timing of the explosive upward drive.
• The Lean-Back: In a strict press, a slight layback from the hips is acceptable to clear your chin. Arching your entire back and turning it into a standing incline press is not. This puts stress on your lower back and takes work away from your shoulders.
• The Push-Jerk: A push press involves one bend of the knees (the dip). If you are bending your knees a second time to drop *under* the bar, you are doing a push jerk. This is a different, more technical lift. For now, keep your legs locked straight after the initial drive.

What Your Press Will Look Like in 60 Days

Progress isn't a straight line, and the first couple of weeks will feel strange. Here is a realistic timeline of what to expect if you follow the protocol.

• Week 1-2: The Awkward Phase. The timing of the push press will feel off. You'll either drive too early or too late. Your strict press might feel unusually heavy as your body adapts to the new volume. This is normal. Do not add weight. Focus entirely on perfect technique. Your job is to master the movements, not set records.
• Month 1 (End of Week 4): The Click. By the end of the first block, something will click. Your strict press 5-rep sets at 115 lbs will feel solid, and you'll likely have added 5-10 lbs to the bar. The push press will feel powerful and rhythmic. You'll feel the transfer of energy from your legs to the bar. You are now stronger.
• Month 2 (End of Week 8): The Payoff. After completing the power block, it's time to re-test. Your new strict press 1RM should be 10-20 pounds heavier than your starting estimate. The lifter who started with a 135 lb 1RM is now pressing 145-155 lbs. Your push press will be even more impressive, likely hitting 175-185 lbs. You have not only built bigger, stronger shoulders but have also taught your body how to use its full power.
• Warning Sign: If you feel a sharp, pinching pain in the front of your shoulder during any press, stop. This is often a sign of elbow flare or internal rotation. Lower the weight, tuck your elbows slightly forward (think 45 degrees, not 90), and focus on keeping your chest up.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Strict Press vs. Push Press Form Differences

In a strict press, your entire body from the neck down is rigid. Your legs and hips are locked, and only your shoulders and arms move the weight. In a push press, you initiate the lift with a quick 3-4 inch dip and explosive drive from your legs.

Programming for Shoulder Size (Hypertrophy)

The strict press is your primary tool. Focus 80% of your overhead work on strict barbell and dumbbell presses in the 6-12 rep range. Use the push press occasionally for a low-rep (3-5) set to provide a unique overload stimulus for your nervous system.

Programming for Athletic Power

The push press is your primary tool. It directly trains explosive hip extension, a key component of jumping, sprinting, and throwing. Use the push press for heavy, low-rep sets (1-5) and the strict press as an accessory lift to build foundational shoulder strength.

Push Press vs. Push Jerk

A push press has one leg action: the dip and drive. Your legs then stay straight. A push jerk has two leg actions: the dip and drive, followed by a second, faster dip under the bar to catch it with locked arms. The jerk allows for even heavier weight.

Using Dumbbells Instead of a Barbell

All the principles apply. A dumbbell strict press is excellent for building stability and fixing strength imbalances between your left and right sides. A dumbbell push press is a great way to develop single-leg power and coordination, but the timing can be trickier to learn.