Is My Fitness Pal Accurate Reddit

Is MyFitnessPal Accurate? The 20% Error Rate Reddit Users Expose

To answer the “is MyFitnessPal accurate reddit” question directly: the app's core database is about 80% accurate, but the way you're likely using it is closer to 50% accurate, which is why your fat loss has stalled. You’re not imagining it. You’re logging 1,800 calories, the app says you should be losing a pound a week, and the scale hasn’t moved in 21 days. It’s infuriating, and it makes you want to throw your phone-and your food scale-out the window. The problem isn't that you're not trying; it's that you're trusting a system with hidden flaws. MyFitnessPal is a powerful tool, but it's also a massive, chaotic library where half the books were written by strangers who can't spell. The app combines professionally verified food data with millions of entries created by other users. Many of those user-generated entries are flat-out wrong, listing incorrect calories, macros, or serving sizes. When you quickly scan and select the first option for “chicken breast,” you could be choosing an entry that’s off by 100 calories. Do that a few times a day, and your 500-calorie deficit vanishes. This is the truth Reddit users have uncovered through years of trial and error: MyFitnessPal is only as accurate as the person using it, and most people use it incorrectly.

The 500 "Invisible" Calories MFP Doesn't See (But Your Body Does)

That 500-calorie deficit you carefully planned isn't real. It exists on your screen, but not in your stomach. The discrepancy comes from a handful of common, seemingly small errors that compound throughout the day. This isn't a theory; it's simple math. Let's break down how 500 calories disappear. First is the User-Entry Trap. A search for “eggs” yields dozens of results. One verified entry for a large egg is 72 calories. A popular user-submitted one might say 90 calories, or even 60. Most people just tap the first one. That’s a 25% error on a single food. Second is the “Cup vs. Grams” disaster. You log “1 cup of oatmeal.” But did you pack it down or scoop it loosely? A level cup of rolled oats is about 80 grams (295 calories). A packed cup can be 110 grams (405 calories). That's a 110-calorie mistake before you’ve even added milk. Third, and most common, is Cooking Oil Blindness. The tablespoon of olive oil you used to cook your chicken and vegetables? That’s 120 calories. The pat of butter on your toast? 35-50 calories. These are almost never logged, yet they add up fast. Finally, you have Raw vs. Cooked Confusion. You weigh out 100g of cooked chicken breast and log it as “100g of chicken breast.” But the database entry is for raw chicken. 100g of raw chicken is about 165 calories. When you cook it, it loses water and shrinks to about 75g. So your 100g of cooked chicken is actually about 133g of raw chicken, or 220 calories. That's a 55-calorie error on one item. Add it up: a 20-calorie egg mistake, a 110-calorie oatmeal mistake, 120 calories of forgotten oil, and a 55-calorie chicken mistake. That’s 305 calories you ate but didn't log. Your 500-calorie deficit is now a measly 195-calorie deficit, leading to painfully slow or nonexistent weight loss.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 3-Step Audit: Forcing MyFitnessPal to Be 99% Accurate

You don't need to switch apps. You just need to take control of the data. This three-step audit will eliminate almost every error and force MyFitnessPal to reflect what you're actually eating. This turns it from a frustrating guessing game into a precision instrument.

Step 1: Buy a $15 Food Scale (This is Not Optional)

This is the single most important step. Stop using cups, tablespoons, and guesswork. A digital food scale costs less than two pizzas and is the only way to know your true portion sizes. From now on, everything that isn't a pre-packaged, single-serving item gets weighed. Weigh your bread, your fruit, your meat, your pasta, your peanut butter. Switch the unit to grams for the most precision. You will be shocked to learn that your idea of a “tablespoon” of peanut butter is actually 2.5 tablespoons, or that your “medium” apple is 100 grams larger than the database entry. This one change alone will likely increase your logged calories by 15-20%, revealing the deficit you thought you had was never there. This isn't about being obsessive; it's about being honest. The scale doesn't lie.

Step 2: Master the Barcode Scanner & Verified Entries

Not all entries in MyFitnessPal are created equal. You need to become a librarian, not just a browser. For any packaged food with a barcode, use the app's barcode scanner. This is the most reliable feature, as it pulls data directly from the manufacturer's label. It's about 99% accurate. For whole foods without a barcode (like chicken, apples, or potatoes), your process is different. When you search, look for entries with a green checkmark next to them. These are “Verified” entries that MyFitnessPal has vetted for accuracy. Prioritize these above all else. If you search for “Apple” and see a verified entry for “Apple - 100g,” use that one. Weigh your apple, and if it's 180g, log 1.8 servings of the 100g entry. Never, ever choose a user-submitted entry like “1 medium apple” again. That entry is useless.

Step 3: Create Your "Personal Foods" Library

If you followed Steps 1 and 2, your tracking is already 90% better. This last step gets you to 99% and saves you a massive amount of time. For meals you cook and eat regularly, use the “My Recipes” or “My Meals” feature. The first time you make your go-to chili, weigh every single ingredient in grams: the ground beef, the beans, the onions, the canned tomatoes, everything. Input it all into the recipe creator and tell it how many servings the recipe makes. Now, you have a perfectly accurate entry for “My Famous Chili.” The next time you eat it, you just log one serving. It takes 10 minutes to set up a recipe, but it saves you that time over the next month and guarantees your numbers are perfect. Do this for your 5-10 most common meals. This creates your own personal, 100% verified food database inside the app, eliminating nascost user-generated data for the foods you eat most.

Week 1 Will Be Shocking: What Accurate Logging Actually Feels Like

Prepare for a reality check. When you implement this 3-step audit, the first week of logging will feel completely different, and you will probably feel discouraged. This is a critical sign that you're finally doing it right. First, you'll experience the “Calorie Shock.” You will log your normal day of eating, but this time with 100% accuracy. The number at the end of the day will be 300, 500, maybe even 800 calories higher than you're used to seeing. Your “1,800 calorie” diet was actually 2,600 calories all along. This is the most important moment in your fitness journey. It's not a failure; it's the discovery of the truth. Now you know the real enemy. For the first two weeks, as you adjust your portions to hit a *true* calorie target, you will feel hungrier. This is normal. You are in a real energy deficit for the first time. Your body is noticing. Stick with it. By the end of the first month, the results will speak for themselves. You will see consistent, predictable weight loss of 0.5 to 1.5 pounds per week. The scale will finally start to match the app's predictions. From this point forward, you can trust the data. If your weight loss stalls, you know it's not a tracking error. You can confidently lower your calorie target by 100-200 and know it will work.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Accuracy of the Barcode Scanner

The barcode scanner is the most accurate feature in MyFitnessPal, pulling data directly from manufacturer labels. It's about 99% reliable for packaged foods. Always double-check that the serving size on the physical package matches the default serving size in the app before you log it.

Cronometer vs. MyFitnessPal for Accuracy

Cronometer is more accurate out-of-the-box because its database is professionally curated, unlike MFP's which is filled with user-generated entries. However, if you follow the 3-step audit in this guide, you can make MyFitnessPal just as accurate. MFP's main advantage is a larger database of foods.

Logging Restaurant Meals Accurately

Logging restaurant food is always an estimate. The best method is to find a similar entry from a large chain restaurant (e.g., search for 'Cheesecake Factory Grilled Salmon' even if you're at a local spot) and use that as a proxy. Assume it has 20-30% more calories than you'd guess due to hidden oils and butter.

Choosing Between Raw and Cooked Weights

Always weigh and log your food raw whenever possible. Nutrition information on packaging and in verified databases refers to the food's uncooked state. Cooking changes the weight by removing water, which makes using cooked weights inconsistent and a primary source of tracking errors.

Fixing Incorrect Entries in MyFitnessPal

You cannot directly edit or fix a public, incorrect entry created by another user. Instead, create your own correct version. Use the 'Create a Food' feature, input the correct nutrition information from the USDA food database or a verified package, and save it. Name it something clear like 'Chicken Breast - RAW - USDA'.