Tips for Using My Past Workout Data to Decide When to Deload or Push Harder

The Data Signal You're Missing That Stalls Your Progress

Here are the only tips for using my past workout data to decide when to deload or push harder that you'll ever need: when your total weekly volume for a key lift drops by 10% or more for two consecutive weeks, it is time to deload, not push harder. You're feeling stuck because you're caught between two bad pieces of advice: the Instagram motivation that screams "go harder" and the vague suggestion to "listen to your body." One leads to burnout, and the other is useless when your body and your ego are lying to you. The frustration of adding a 5-pound plate only to fail the same number of reps as last week is real. You're not weak or lazy; you're flying blind. Your workout notebook or app isn't just a diary of what you did; it's a predictive tool. It holds the objective truth that cuts through the noise of how you *feel*. The data tells you when you've earned the right to push and when your body is screaming for a strategic retreat. Ignoring it is the number one reason intermediate lifters stay intermediate forever. The secret isn't a new exercise or a magic supplement; it's learning to read the story your numbers are already telling you.

Stop guessing. Start getting stronger.

Track your lifts with Mofilo. See your strength grow week by week.

Why 'Training Harder' Is Actually Making You Weaker

Your body gets stronger during recovery, not during the workout itself. The workout is the signal, and the recovery is the response. This is the General Adaptation Syndrome (GAS), a three-stage process: Alarm, Resistance, and Exhaustion. Pushing harder and harder without adequate recovery keeps you in a perpetual state of alarm, preventing you from ever reaching the adaptation phase where you actually get stronger. You're just digging a deeper recovery hole. This is where most people get it wrong. They have a week where their bench press feels heavy, so they assume they need to attack it with more sets, more reps, more intensity. In reality, they've accumulated so much fatigue that their performance is compromised. Adding more work on top of that fatigue is like trying to put out a fire with gasoline. It only leads to the exhaustion phase: stalled lifts, nagging joint pain, low motivation, and eventually, a forced break. Contrast this with a lifter who tracks their data. They see their bench press volume drop 5% one week. They note it. The next week, it drops another 5%. Instead of panicking, they see the signal. They initiate a planned, one-week deload, cutting volume by 50% but keeping the weights heavy enough to feel good. They come back the following week, fully recovered, and hit a new personal record. One lifter is stuck in a cycle of two steps forward, two steps back. The other is making consistent, predictable progress. You understand the concept now: track your key metrics and watch for the drop. But theory is easy. Look at your last 8 weeks of training. Can you calculate, with certainty, your total volume for squats in week 3 versus week 7? If the answer is 'no' or 'I think so,' you don't have data. You have a diary.

Weeks of progress. All in one place.

Every workout logged. Proof you are actually getting stronger.

The 3-Metric System to Decode Your Workout Log

Stop guessing and start calculating. Your path to consistent strength gains is paved with data, but you only need to focus on three specific numbers. This system works whether you're a powerlifter, a bodybuilder, or just someone who wants to get stronger. It turns your workout log from a historical document into a predictive roadmap.

Step 1: Track These Three Numbers (No Exceptions)

For every single workout, you must log these metrics for your main compound lifts (like squats, bench press, deadlifts, and overhead press).

1. Volume Load: This is the total amount of weight you've lifted in a session for a specific exercise. The formula is simple: Sets x Reps x Weight. If you benched 3 sets of 5 reps at 185 pounds, your volume load is 3 x 5 x 185 = 2,775 pounds. This is your primary indicator of total work.
2. Estimated 1-Rep Max (e1RM): This tracks your top-end strength without requiring you to perform a risky, true 1-rep max. Use your heaviest set of the day and plug it into a simple formula. The Brzycki formula is reliable: Weight / (1.0278 - (0.0278 × Reps)). For example, if your top set was 185 lbs for 5 reps, your e1RM is 185 / (1.0278 - (0.0278 x 5)) = 208 lbs. This tells you if your peak strength is trending up or down.
3. Rate of Perceived Exertion (RPE) or Reps in Reserve (RIR): This is your subjective difficulty score. RPE is a scale of 1-10, where 10 is a maximum effort lift. RIR is how many more reps you could have done. An RPE of 8 is the same as an RIR of 2. This metric gives context to your numbers. Lifting 225 for 5 reps at RPE 7 is a much better performance than doing it at RPE 9.

Step 2: Identify the "Deload Signal"

This is the rule that removes all guesswork. A deload is mandatory when you see this pattern:

• The Signal: Your weekly Volume Load or your top set e1RM for a core lift drops by 10% or more from its peak, and this trend continues for two consecutive weeks.

Here’s an example for your squat:

• Week 4 (Peak): Volume Load = 15,000 lbs. Top set e1RM = 315 lbs.
• Week 5: Volume Load = 14,250 lbs (a 5% drop). e1RM = 310 lbs. This is an alert, not a panic. It could be a bad day.
• Week 6: Volume Load = 13,400 lbs (now down 11% from peak). e1RM = 300 lbs. This is the signal. You have now had two straight weeks of declining performance. It's time to deload, not to try and force a 320 lb squat.

Step 3: Execute a Productive Deload (Not a Vacation)

A deload is not a week off. It's a week of strategic, active recovery. The goal is to shed fatigue while retaining your strength adaptations. The rule is simple:

• The Rule: Reduce your total Volume Load by 40-50% while maintaining intensity (the weight on the bar).
• How to do it: The easiest way is to cut your number of sets in half. If you normally squat 4 sets of 5 at 275 lbs, you will now squat 2 sets of 5 at 275 lbs. The weight on the bar feels the same, which helps you stay neurologically dialed in, but the total work is drastically reduced, allowing your body to supercompensate.

Step 4: Know When to "Push Harder"

Pushing harder is the reward for smart recovery. You've earned the right to push when you see these signs:

1. Post-Deload Rebound: In the first week back from a deload, your Volume Load and e1RM should easily match or exceed your numbers from before the slump. You'll feel strong, explosive, and motivated.
2. Decreasing RPE: If you are hitting your target reps and sets, and your RPE is consistently *lower* than planned, it's time to add weight. If a set of 5 that was an RPE 9 three weeks ago now feels like an RPE 7, you are stronger. Add 5-10 pounds to the bar next week. This is the green light you've been looking for.

What Your Progress Will Look Like in the Next 8 Weeks

Following a data-driven approach feels different from just going to the gym and winging it. Here’s what to expect from a typical 8-week cycle of pushing, reading the data, and deloading.

Deload Week (Week 1): This week will feel wrong. You will finish your workouts feeling like you could have done twice as much. This is the entire point. You are not trying to build fitness this week; you are shedding accumulated fatigue. You might feel restless or even a little lazy. Trust the process. By the end of the week, your joints should feel better, and you should feel a renewed psychological hunger to lift heavy again.

The Rebound (Week 2): Coming out of the deload, this is your first week back to a full workload. You should feel strong, sharp, and explosive. Your goal is to match the performance of your peak week before the slump. Most people find they can hit their old numbers with a lower RPE, which is a clear sign the deload worked. This week confirms you are fully recovered and ready to push for new PRs.

The Growth Phase (Weeks 3-5): This is where you push. You should be adding small amounts of weight to the bar (2.5-5 lbs on upper body, 5-10 lbs on lower body) or adding an extra rep to your sets. Your Volume Load and e1RM should be climbing to new all-time highs. This is the period of progressive overload where you are building new muscle and strength. Enjoy it, because it doesn't last forever.

The Plateau Warning (Weeks 6-8): Progress will inevitably begin to slow. The weights will feel heavier. An RPE 8 will start to feel like an RPE 9. Your Volume Load might flatten out or even dip slightly. This is not failure; it is the predictable accumulation of fatigue. You are now on high alert, watching your data closely for that 10% drop over two consecutive weeks. Once you see it, you know exactly what to do: start the cycle over with another productive deload.

Frequently Asked Questions

What If I Only Have One Bad Week?

One bad week is not a trend. It's just noise. Poor sleep, a stressful day at work, or a slight change in nutrition can all cause a temporary dip in performance. Do not deload after one bad week. Note the data, focus on recovery, and approach the next week's training as planned. If performance drops again, then you have a signal. If it bounces back, it was just a fluke.

How to Deload a Single Lift vs. the Whole Body?

If your squat is stalling but your bench press and deadlift are still climbing, you can perform a localized deload. For that week, only apply the deload protocol (50% volume reduction) to your squat and its accessory movements. Train everything else as normal. However, if a major lift like the squat or deadlift is stalling, it's often a sign of systemic fatigue, and a full-body deload is usually the better choice.

Can I Use RPE Alone to Decide?

You can, but it's less precise than combining it with volume. A clear signal would be if the RPE for your main work sets jumps by 1-2 points for the same weight and reps, for two weeks in a row. For example, if 225 lbs for 5 reps goes from an RPE 7 to an RPE 9, your body is struggling to recover. Using RPE with Volume Load gives you both the objective and subjective picture.

How Long Should a Training Block Be Before a Deload?

There is no magic number. It's typically between 3 to 8 weeks, but you should let your data tell you when it's time. A beginner might go 10-12 weeks before needing a deload, while a very advanced lifter pushing their limits might need one every 3-4 weeks. Stop planning your deloads on a calendar and start planning them based on your performance data.

What About Cardio and Conditioning?

During a deload week, you should reduce the intensity and duration of your cardio as well. This contributes to overall systemic fatigue. A good rule of thumb is to cut your cardio volume in half. If you normally run 4 miles three times a week, do an easy 2-mile jog instead. If you do 20 minutes of HIIT, do 10 minutes of low-intensity steady-state cardio.