What to Do Instead of Dips If You Are Overweight

Why Dips Hurt When You're Overweight (And the 3 Moves to Do Instead)

If you're wondering what to do instead of dips if you are overweight, the answer is to focus on 3 specific pressing movements-like the close-grip push-up-that build the exact same muscles without destroying your shoulder joints. Let's be honest: you probably tried a dip because a workout plan told you to. You got on the bars, lowered yourself down, and felt a sharp, grinding pain in your shoulders. It felt less like a workout and more like an injury waiting to happen. You're not weak; you're fighting physics. Dips force you to lift 100% of your bodyweight. If you weigh 240 pounds, that's a 240-pound lift putting immense stress on a very sensitive joint. A 160-pound person is only lifting 160 pounds. The risk isn't proportional. The heavier you are, the more dangerous the dip becomes for your shoulder capsule and rotator cuff. The good news is you can get all the chest and triceps-building benefits of dips without any of the risk. The solution is to replace dips with exercises that are scalable and work with your body's mechanics, not against them. The three best alternatives are the Incline Push-Up, the Close-Grip Dumbbell Press, and the Overhead Triceps Extension. These movements allow you to build foundational strength safely, so you can make progress week after week without getting sidelined by pain.

The Physics Problem: Why a 250-Pound Dip Is Not a 150-Pound Dip

The number one mistake people make is thinking all bodyweight exercises are created equal. They aren't. A dip puts your shoulder into significant internal rotation and extension at the bottom of the movement. For a person with a light frame, this might be fine. But when you add 50, 75, or 100+ pounds of extra body mass, that same position creates enormous shearing forces inside the joint. It's like trying to pry something open at a terrible angle-eventually, something has to give. Your rotator cuff and the front of your shoulder capsule take the brunt of this force. This is why you feel a pinching or grinding sensation. It's your body's warning signal that the structures are being overloaded beyond their capacity. Contrast this with a push-up. During a proper push-up, your shoulder blades are free to move. They can retract and glide across your ribcage, creating a stable platform for your shoulder joint to press from. This is a much stronger and safer position. The load is distributed across your chest, shoulders, and triceps more evenly. The same is true for a dumbbell press, which allows your hands, wrists, and elbows to find their most natural and comfortable path. Forcing your body into the fixed, unforgiving path of a dip station when you're overweight is a bad bet. The goal of training is to stimulate muscle, not stress joints. By choosing smarter exercises, you get all the muscle stimulation with a fraction of the joint stress. This is the key to long-term, pain-free progress.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 12-Week Protocol to Build a Powerful Chest and Triceps (No Dips Needed)

This isn't just about avoiding dips; it's about building real strength with a smarter plan. This 12-week protocol uses three key exercises to build your pressing power and triceps size. Perform this workout twice a week, for example on Monday and Thursday, with at least two days of rest in between.

Step 1: Master the Foundation (Weeks 1-12) - The Incline Push-Up

The incline push-up is your primary movement. It's a push-up with your hands elevated on a surface, which reduces the percentage of your bodyweight you have to lift. The higher the surface, the easier the exercise.

• How to do it: Place your hands on a kitchen counter, a sturdy desk, or the back of a sofa. Your hands should be slightly narrower than shoulder-width apart. Keep your body in a straight line from head to heels. Lower your chest to the surface, pause for a second, and press back up.
• The prescription: 3 sets of as many reps as possible (AMRAP) with perfect form.
• How to progress: When you can complete 3 sets of 15 reps on your current surface, find a lower one. Your progression might look like this over 12 weeks: Wall -> Kitchen Counter -> Sturdy Chair -> Low Step or Bench. The goal is to gradually work your way to the floor.

Step 2: Add Horizontal Pressing (Weeks 1-12) - The Close-Grip Dumbbell Press

This movement directly targets the triceps and inner chest, just like a dip, but in a much safer, more stable position. Using dumbbells allows your wrists and elbows to move in a natural arc, which is far more joint-friendly than a fixed barbell.

• How to do it: Lie on a flat bench with a dumbbell in each hand. Hold the dumbbells over your chest with your palms facing each other (a neutral grip). Lower the weights down and slightly back until they are just outside your chest. Your elbows should be tucked in at about a 45-degree angle, not flared out. Press back to the starting position.
• The prescription: 3 sets of 8-12 reps.
• How to progress: Start with a weight you can handle for 8 clean reps. For many, this will be 15-25 pound dumbbells. When you can perform 3 sets of 12 reps with that weight, increase the weight by 5 pounds. A 5-pound jump every 3-4 weeks is excellent progress.

Step 3: Isolate the Triceps (Weeks 1-12) - The Dumbbell Overhead Extension

This exercise finishes the triceps by working them in a stretched position, which is crucial for building size and strength. It complements the pressing movements perfectly.

• How to do it: You can do this seated or standing. Hold one dumbbell with both hands over your head. Lower the dumbbell behind your head by bending your elbows. Keep your upper arms stationary and pointed toward the ceiling. Go as low as you can without pain, then extend your arms to lift the dumbbell back to the start.
• The prescription: 3 sets of 10-15 reps.
• How to progress: Choose a weight where the last few reps are a serious challenge. If you're using a 20-pound dumbbell and can hit 15 reps, it's time to try a 25-pounder. The goal is muscular failure within the 10-15 rep range, not just moving weight.

Your First 30 Days Will Feel Different. Here's What to Track.

Progress isn't always linear, and it isn't always measured on the scale. When you start this program, you need to track the right things to stay motivated and know it's working. Forget about trying dips for now. Your only job is to get better at these three exercises.

• Week 1-2: The 'No Pain' Victory. Your main goal in the first two weeks is to complete the workouts without any joint pain. You will feel your triceps and chest working, and you will be sore. This is good. The absence of shoulder pain is your first major win. Write down the incline height, weights, sets, and reps for every workout in a notebook. This is your starting point.
• Month 1 (Weeks 3-4): The Logbook Gains. You will not see dramatic changes in the mirror yet. Your progress is in your logbook. You should be able to add 1-2 reps to each set of your push-ups and presses. You might even be ready to lower your incline height for push-ups. This is tangible proof that you are getting stronger. A 5-pound increase on your dumbbell press in the first month is a huge success.
• Month 2-3 (Weeks 5-12): Visible Changes Begin. This is when the work starts to show. Your arms will feel denser, and your shirts might fit a little tighter in the chest and shoulders. Your strength will take a noticeable leap. Your incline push-ups might be on a low step, or you might even be attempting them on your knees on the floor. Your dumbbell press weight will have gone up by 10-15 pounds from where you started. This is the momentum that builds a strong, capable physique.

The Warning Sign: If you feel any sharp, pinching, or stabbing pain in your shoulders, elbows, or wrists, stop that exercise immediately. Regress to an easier version (e.g., higher incline, lighter weight) or substitute it. Pain is a signal to stop, not a challenge to push through.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Role of Push-Ups as a Dip Alternative

Close-grip push-ups are the single best alternative to dips. They target the same primary muscles-chest, shoulders, and triceps-but allow your shoulder blades to move naturally. This scapular movement creates a stable and safe position for the shoulder joint, drastically reducing injury risk.

Why Bench Dips Are Also a Bad Idea

Avoid bench dips, especially if you are overweight. This variation forces your shoulders into an even more extreme and compromised position of internal rotation than parallel bar dips. It places immense stress on the small tendons and ligaments in the front of your shoulder, making it a high-risk, low-reward exercise.

Building Up to a Full Bodyweight Dip

Once you can perform 15-20 perfect, full-range-of-motion push-ups on the floor and have lost 20-30 pounds of body weight, you can consider re-introducing dips. Start with band-assisted dips. Loop a heavy resistance band over the bars and place your knees in it to offload a portion of your bodyweight.

The Best Rep Range for Building Muscle

For building muscle size (hypertrophy), the most effective range is 8-15 repetitions per set. In this range, the last 2-3 reps of each set should be very difficult to complete with good form. This provides the mechanical tension and metabolic stress necessary to signal muscle growth.

How Weight Loss Affects Dip Performance

Every pound of fat you lose is like adding a pound of strength to your bodyweight exercises. Losing 25 pounds makes a dip 25 pounds easier. This is why combining a smart strength program with a consistent calorie deficit is the fastest and safest way to achieve your first unassisted dip.