Overhead Press Stuck at Same Weight

Why Pressing the Same Weight Is Making You Weaker

If your overhead press is stuck at the same weight, the solution isn't to just try and lift heavier; it's to lift *more* total volume at 80-90% of your max. You need to accumulate reps until you hit a target of 25-30 total reps per session. It feels counterintuitive, but dropping the weight slightly is the fastest way to get stronger. That feeling of being pinned under the bar, failing the same rep at 135 pounds for the third week in a row, is not a sign you need to push harder. It's a sign your current strategy is failing. The overhead press (OHP) isn't like a deadlift, where you can often grind through a heavy single. It involves smaller, more delicate muscle groups-your deltoids and triceps-that fatigue quickly. Repeatedly failing reps does not build strength; it builds fatigue, drains your central nervous system (CNS), and reinforces a pattern of failure. You're essentially practicing how to fail. To break the cycle, you have to stop fighting the wall and instead build a bigger foundation so you can climb over it. This means shifting your focus from intensity (the weight on the bar) to volume (the total work done).

The Hidden Math That Explains Your OHP Plateau

The reason your overhead press is stuck is simple math. You are not performing enough work to signal to your body that it needs to adapt and grow stronger. Let's look at total tonnage, which is the truest measure of work in the gym (Sets x Reps x Weight).

Scenario A: The Plateau

You're trying to press 135 lbs for 5 reps. You get 4 reps, then fail the 5th. You rest and try again, maybe getting 3-4 reps.

• Set 1: 4 reps x 135 lbs = 540 lbs
• Set 2: 3 reps x 135 lbs = 405 lbs
• Set 3: 3 reps x 135 lbs = 405 lbs
• Total Volume: 1,350 lbs

You leave the gym feeling defeated, and your CNS is fried from the grinding effort.

Scenario B: The Breakthrough

You drop the weight by 10%, down to 120 lbs. The goal is no longer to hit a specific number of reps per set, but to accumulate 25 total reps.

• Set 1: 5 reps x 120 lbs = 600 lbs
• Set 2: 5 reps x 120 lbs = 600 lbs
• Set 3: 5 reps x 120 lbs = 600 lbs
• Set 4: 5 reps x 120 lbs = 600 lbs
• Set 5: 5 reps x 120 lbs = 600 lbs
• Total Volume: 3,000 lbs

In Scenario B, you lifted more than double the total weight. Even though the bar felt lighter, you performed significantly more productive work. This massive increase in volume is the stimulus your muscles actually need to grow. You completed every rep with good form, built confidence, and left the gym without crushing your nervous system. This is how you build the raw capacity needed to handle heavier weights in the future.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 8-Week Protocol to Break Your OHP Stall

Stop guessing and follow a structured plan. This protocol is designed to systematically build your overhead press over the next two months. Forget what you were doing before. For the next 8 weeks, this is your new pressing bible. It's not complicated, but it demands consistency.

Step 1: Find Your Real 5-Rep Max (Not Your Ego Max)

First, we need an honest baseline. Your 5-rep max (5RM) is the heaviest weight you can press for 5 complete, clean reps without your form breaking down. This means no excessive back arch, no bouncing from the knees, and a full lockout at the top. If your lower back is screaming and you have to turn it into a standing incline press, the weight is too heavy. Go to the gym, warm up thoroughly, and find this number. Be honest. If you hit 135 lbs for 3 reps and then fail the 4th, your 5RM is not 135. It's probably closer to 125 lbs. This number is the foundation for the entire program.

Step 2: The Volume Accumulation Phase (Weeks 1-4)

For the next four weeks, you will not try to hit a new 1-rep or 5-rep max. Your only goal is to accumulate volume. Take 85% of the 5RM you just found. If your 5RM was 125 lbs, your working weight is ~105 lbs. Your goal for each OHP session is to complete 25 total reps with this weight. How you get there doesn't matter as much as just getting it done.

• Week 1 Goal: 25 total reps at 105 lbs. Maybe you do 5, 5, 4, 4, 3, 2, 2. That's fine. Just get to 25.
• Week 2 Goal: 25 total reps at 105 lbs. Try to do it in fewer sets. Maybe you get 5, 5, 5, 5, 5.

Once you can successfully complete 25 reps in 5 sets (5x5), you have earned the right to increase the weight. But you will not increase it yet. You will continue with the next step.

Step 3: Add The Right Accessories

Randomly doing lateral raises won't un-stick your press. You need specific accessory lifts that target the weak points in the OHP. Add these two exercises to your training days, preferably after your main OHP work.

1. Push Press: This is your overload movement. By using a slight dip and drive from your legs, you can handle about 10-20% more weight than your strict press. This gets your body accustomed to feeling heavier weight overhead and strengthens your lockout. Do 3 sets of 3-5 reps.
2. Z-Press: This is your stability builder. Sit on the floor with your legs straight out in front of you. This position removes all possible leg drive and forces your core and upper back to work overtime to stay stable. It is humbling but incredibly effective. Use a much lighter weight. Do 3 sets of 6-8 reps.

Step 4: Micro-load for Consistent Wins (Weeks 5-8)

After 4 weeks of volume work, it's time to test your 5RM again. It will have increased. Now, we translate that new strength into steady progress. This is where micro-plates (1.25 lb plates) become your best friend. A 5 lb jump on a 135 lb OHP is a nearly 4% increase in weight, which is often too much for your shoulders to handle week after week. A 2.5 lb jump is less than 2%. It's a small, manageable step that allows for consistent progress.

• Week 5: Take your new 5RM and add 2.5 lbs. Work on hitting 3-5 reps.
• Week 6: Once you hit 5 reps with that new weight, add another 2.5 lbs.

This slow, methodical progression is the secret to long-term OHP gains. You're making small, repeatable wins instead of failing at big, demoralizing jumps.

What Your OHP Will Look Like in 60 Days

Progress isn't a straight line, but if you follow the protocol, here is what you should expect. Understanding this timeline will keep you from getting discouraged when progress feels slow.

In the First 2 Weeks: The workouts will feel surprisingly easy. Using 85% of your max will feel light, and you might be tempted to add more weight. Don't. This is a deliberate deload period where your joints and nervous system recover from the previous cycle of grinding. You are building work capacity. Trust the process.

By the End of Month 1 (Week 4): The volume will have caught up to you. Completing those 25 total reps will feel challenging and productive. You will have successfully completed a 5x5 workout with a weight that you might have struggled with for single reps a month prior. You will feel stronger and more stable.

By the End of Month 2 (Week 8): You will have hit a new 5-rep max that is 5-10 lbs heavier than your starting point. More importantly, you will be on a clear path of adding 2.5 lbs to the bar every 1-2 weeks. Your overhead press will no longer be stuck at the same weight. You will have a repeatable system for progress. A 10-15 lb increase on your OHP in 8 weeks is a massive victory.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.

Frequently Asked Questions

OHP Frequency Per Week

Press twice a week for the best results. Use one day for your heavy volume work as outlined in the protocol (e.g., accumulating 25 reps). Use a second day, spaced 2-3 days apart, for lighter, dynamic work. On this day, use 60-70% of your 1RM and perform 6-8 sets of 3 fast, explosive reps.

Barbell vs. Dumbbell OHP

The barbell press is superior for building maximum strength because it allows for heavier loading. Dumbbell presses are an excellent accessory exercise for building stability and correcting muscle imbalances. Use the barbell OHP as your primary lift and add dumbbell presses afterward for 3 sets of 8-12 reps.

The Role of Micro-Plates

Micro-plates, such as 1.25 lb fractional plates, are not optional for serious OHP progress. A standard 5 lb jump is often too large and leads to plateaus. Making smaller, more frequent 2.5 lb jumps allows for consistent progressive overload, which is the key to long-term strength gains. They are one of the best investments you can make.

Correcting Common Form Breakdown

The most common mistake is excessive lower back arching to cheat the weight up. To fix this, actively squeeze your glutes and brace your abs throughout the lift. Think about pulling your ribcage down. This creates a rigid, stable torso from which you can press effectively.

Push Press vs. Strict Press

The strict press is a pure measure of upper body strength with no leg involvement. The push press uses a leg dip and drive to help initiate the movement, allowing you to handle 10-20% more weight. Use the strict press for your main volume work and the push press as an accessory to overload the top end of the lift.