Is It Better to Follow a Program or Do My Own Workouts

Why "Doing Your Own Workouts" Guarantees You Stay Stuck

When deciding is it better to follow a program or do my own workouts, the answer is brutally simple: following a structured program will produce at least 300% more results than 'doing your own thing.' This isn't an opinion; it's the foundational law of getting stronger and building muscle. If you feel like you're putting in hours at the gym but your body hasn't changed in the last 6 months, this is why. You're likely caught in a loop of comfortable, repetitive movements without a system for forcing adaptation. You go in, do what you feel like, get a pump, and leave. It feels productive, but it's the fitness equivalent of running in place. A program replaces guesswork with a roadmap. It removes emotion and daily fatigue from the equation and replaces it with a clear, mathematical path to getting stronger. Without a program, you are the pilot flying without instruments, hoping you land at the right destination. A program is your GPS, your flight plan, and your black box recorder all in one.

The Unseen Force That Builds Muscle (And Why Your Workouts Lack It)

The single reason a program works and random workouts fail is a principle called Progressive Overload. It’s the entire game. It means that to force your muscles to grow bigger or get stronger, you must consistently challenge them with a stimulus that is greater than what they are used to. Your body is an adaptation machine; it will only change if you give it a compelling reason to. 'Doing your own workouts' almost never provides this reason consistently.

Let’s compare two scenarios for a 180-pound man trying to improve his bench press:

Scenario 1: Doing His Own Workout

• Week 1: Feels good. Bench presses 155 lbs for 3 sets of 8, 7, and 5 reps.
• Week 4: A little tired. Bench presses 155 lbs for 3 sets of 6, 6, and 5 reps.
• Week 8: Feels strong. Pushes it and gets 165 lbs for 1 set of 4 reps, then drops back to 135 lbs.

There is no plan. The total volume (Weight x Sets x Reps) is stagnant. He lifted a total of 3,100 lbs in Week 1 and only 2,790 lbs in Week 4. He's actually getting weaker.

Scenario 2: Following a Program

His program calls for 3 sets of 5-8 reps. The rule is simple: once he hits 3 sets of 8, he adds 5 pounds the next week.

• Week 1: Bench presses 155 lbs for 3 sets of 6, 5, 5. (Total: 2,480 lbs)
• Week 2: The program demands he beat last week. He gets 155 lbs for 3 sets of 7, 6, 5. (Total: 2,790 lbs)
• Week 4: After consistent effort, he gets 155 lbs for 3 sets of 8, 8, 7. (Total: 3,565 lbs)
• Week 5: He hit his rep target. The program dictates he now moves to 160 lbs. He gets 3 sets of 6, 5, 5.

This is progressive overload in action. The program provides the structure that forces the increase in volume. It's not about how you feel; it's about what the logbook says you need to do. This methodical, planned progression is the only thing that separates people who transform their bodies from those who look the same year after year.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 4-Part Blueprint for a Workout Program That Actually Works

A good program isn't complicated. It doesn't need 17 exotic exercises. It needs a logical structure that ensures progressive overload. Any effective program you find or create will have these four components. If a program is missing one of these, it's incomplete.

Step 1: Choose Your Split (The Weekly Schedule)

Your split is how you organize your training throughout the week. Don't overthink it. For 90% of people, one of these three is the best choice.

• Full Body (3 days/week): You train your entire body in each session. This is ideal for beginners as it maximizes frequency for learning movements. Example: Monday, Wednesday, Friday.
• Upper/Lower (4 days/week): You split your training into upper body days and lower body days. This is a fantastic choice for intermediates who can handle more volume. Example: Monday (Upper), Tuesday (Lower), Thursday (Upper), Friday (Lower).
• Push/Pull/Legs (3-6 days/week): You train pushing muscles (chest, shoulders, triceps), pulling muscles (back, biceps), and legs on separate days. This is great for more advanced lifters.

Your Action: If you're starting out or getting back into it, choose a 3-day full-body split. If you've been training for over a year, try a 4-day upper/lower split.

Step 2: Select Your Core Lifts (The 80/20 Rule)

About 80% of your results will come from getting brutally strong on 4-6 core compound movements. These exercises use multiple muscle groups and give you the most bang for your buck. Your program must be built around them.

• Upper Body Push: Bench Press, Overhead Press, Dumbbell Press, Dips
• Upper Body Pull: Pull-ups/Chin-ups, Barbell Rows, Lat Pulldowns
• Lower Body Squat: Barbell Back Squat, Goblet Squat, Leg Press
• Lower Body Hinge: Deadlift, Romanian Deadlift (RDL)

Your Action: Pick ONE primary lift from each category. This is the foundation of your workout. For example, on a full-body day, you might do a Goblet Squat, a Dumbbell Bench Press, and a Barbell Row.

Step 3: Define Your Reps and Sets (The Progression Model)

A program needs a rule for how to get stronger. Without it, you're just guessing. A simple and effective model is Double Progression.

1. Choose a rep range: For strength and muscle growth, 3-4 sets in the 5-8 rep range is perfect.
2. Work within the range: Start with a weight you can lift for 3 sets of 5 reps (3x5).
3. Progress the reps: Each week, try to add reps. Your goal is to get to 3 sets of 8 reps (3x8) with that same weight.
4. Progress the weight: Once you successfully hit 3x8, add 5 pounds to the bar next week. You will likely drop back down to 3x5 or 3x6 with the new, heavier weight. Repeat the process.

Your Action: Apply this model to your core lifts. Write it down. This is your non-negotiable rule for getting stronger.

Step 4: Track Everything (The Non-Negotiable)

This is the step that ties it all together. Buy a cheap notebook and a pen. Before each set, write down the exercise, the weight, and the reps you're aiming for. After the set, record what you actually did. That's it.

Your logbook is your source of truth. It tells you what you did last week so you know what you have to beat this week. It turns an abstract goal (“get stronger”) into a concrete, numerical target (“I need to do 135 lbs for 6 reps today because I did 5 last week”). People who don't track their workouts are destined to repeat them.

What to Expect in the First 60 Days (It Won't Be Easy)

Switching from 'doing your own thing' to following a strict program is a shock to the system, both mentally and physically. Knowing what to expect will keep you from quitting when it feels weird or difficult.

Week 1-2: The Humbling Phase

You will likely feel weaker. The weights you used to throw around might feel heavy when you're forced to use strict form and a specific tempo. You will be sore in places you haven't felt before. This is a good sign. It means you're finally training muscles you were neglecting. Your job is not to lift heavy; your job is to execute the program, learn the movements, and establish a baseline in your logbook. Trust the process.

Month 1: The 'Clicks' Start Happening

By week 3 or 4, things start to click. The soreness subsides. The movements feel more natural. You'll look at your logbook and see that the weight you struggled with for 5 reps in week 1, you're now hitting for 8 reps. These are your first real, measurable Personal Records (PRs). You might not see dramatic changes in the mirror yet, but you have concrete proof on paper that you are getting stronger. This is the fuel that keeps you going.

Month 2-3: The Visible Proof

This is where the consistency pays off. After 8-12 weeks of methodical, progressive overload, the changes become undeniable. You will have added 10-25 pounds to your core lifts. Your bench press might go from 135 lbs for 5 reps to 155 lbs for 5 reps. Your squat will feel more powerful. You'll see more shape and definition in your shoulders, back, and legs. This is the lagging indicator of the hard work you logged in weeks 1 through 8. This is the transformation that random workouts can never deliver.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Best Program for a True Beginner

A 3-day per week, full-body routine is the gold standard. Focus on one main push, pull, and squat movement each session, using the double progression model (e.g., 3 sets of 5-8 reps). Add 2-3 accessory exercises for 8-12 reps. That's it. Complexity is the enemy of consistency.

How Long to Follow One Program

Stick with a program for a minimum of 8-12 weeks. Program-hopping is a common mistake that kills progress. You need to give the plan enough time to work. As long as you are still adding weight or reps to your core lifts over time, the program is working. Don't change it.

Substituting Exercises in a Program

Yes, you can substitute exercises, but you must swap a similar movement pattern. If the program calls for barbell back squats and your gym doesn't have a rack, a leg press or a heavy goblet squat is a good substitute. Do not swap a squat for a leg extension. That changes the entire stimulus.

When "Doing Your Own Thing" Is Okay

After you have followed structured programs for a few years, you will internalize the principles of progressive overload, recovery management, and exercise selection. At that point, you can create your own effective programs. This is not 'doing your own thing' in the random sense; it's being your own coach, which is an advanced skill earned through discipline.

What If I Miss a Workout

Don't panic. If you miss a day, just pick up where you left off. If you miss an entire week due to vacation or illness, reduce your working weights by about 10% for your first week back to ease into it, and then resume your progression. The key is consistency over the long term, not perfection in the short term.