Why Are Pull Ups So Hard for Females Reddit

Why Your Pull-Up Progress Stalled (It's Not Your Fault)

If you're searching online for 'why are pull ups so hard for females reddit', the answer isn't a lack of effort or willpower-it's a combination of physics and anatomy. On average, women have about 40% less upper-body muscle mass than men. This means when you, a 140-pound woman, attempt a pull-up, you're asking a smaller muscle base to lift a significant portion of your body weight. It's not a question of being 'weak'; it's a question of leverage and relative strength. You're not failing because you're doing something wrong; you're struggling because the pull-up is one of the most demanding bodyweight exercises, especially given natural differences in muscle distribution. Most women carry more muscle mass in their lower body, which is great for squats and deadlifts but offers no help when your feet are off the floor. The frustration you feel is valid. You've probably tried the assisted pull-up machine or lat pulldowns for months with zero progress. That's because those exercises don't build the specific strength needed for a real pull-up. This isn't a permanent barrier. It's just a taller wall to climb, and you need a better ladder than the one you've been given.

The Two Mistakes Keeping You From Your First Pull-Up

Your inability to do a pull-up isn't a mystery. It’s the result of following conventional gym advice that fails to address the unique challenge of the movement. There are two primary mistakes that are holding you back, and almost everyone makes them.

First, you're training the wrong movement pattern. The two most common 'pull-up alternatives'-the lat pulldown and the assisted pull-up machine-are fundamentally flawed for this goal. The lat pulldown is an 'open-chain' exercise where you pull a weight *to* your stable body. A pull-up is a 'closed-chain' exercise where you pull your body *to* a stable object. This is a completely different neurological skill. The assisted pull-up machine is even worse. It gives you the most help at the bottom of the movement, the exact point where you are weakest and need to build the most strength. It teaches your body to be lazy at the hardest part of the lift.

Second, you're focusing on the wrong half of the exercise. Everyone is obsessed with the concentric phase-the 'up' part of the pull-up. But your muscles are approximately 1.75 times stronger during the eccentric phase-the 'down' part. By ignoring this, you're leaving your biggest strength gains on the table. Trying to conquer the 'up' without first mastering the 'down' is like trying to build a house starting with the roof. It will always collapse. The secret to your first pull-up is not in pulling up, but in controlling the descent.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 8-Week Protocol to Your First Unassisted Pull-Up

Stop trying to do a pull-up and start training for one. This isn't about 'trying harder'; it's about training smarter. Follow this 8-week progression 2-3 times per week, with at least one full day of rest between sessions. Progress is not measured by getting a pull-up in week one. It's measured by hitting the specific goals in each step.

Step 1: Master the Dead Hang (Weeks 1-2)

Your grip is the foundation. If you can't hang from the bar, you can't do a pull-up. Your goal is to accumulate 90 seconds of total hang time. Start with sets of 15-20 seconds. Once you can comfortably hold on for 45 seconds in a single set, your grip is strong enough to move on. This also builds crucial shoulder stability and endurance.

• Action: 3 sets of hanging for as long as possible. Rest 60-90 seconds between sets. Your forearms will burn. This is the point.

Step 2: Own the Negative (Weeks 2-5)

This is the most important step. The negative is where you build the raw strength for the pull-up. Use a box or bench to get your chin over the bar. Hold that top position for 1 second, then begin lowering yourself as slowly as you can. The goal is to make the descent last 5-8 seconds.

• Action: 4 sets of 3-5 negative reps. If you can't control the descent for at least 3 seconds, you are not ready. Go back to dead hangs and add scapular pulls. The moment you can do a 10-second negative, you are on the verge of your first pull-up.

Step 3: Activate Your Back with Scapular Pulls (Weeks 3-8)

Most people try to do pull-ups with just their arms. This will never work. A pull-up is a back exercise. Scapular pulls teach you how to initiate the movement correctly. From a dead hang, without bending your elbows, pull your shoulder blades down and back. Your body will rise an inch or two. Hold for a second, then lower back to the start.

• Action: 3 sets of 8-12 reps. Perform these after your hangs or as part of your warm-up. Feel the muscles in your upper back engage.

Step 4: Use Bands Correctly (Weeks 6-8)

Once you can perform a controlled 8-10 second negative, you can introduce banded pull-ups. But use them as a tool, not a crutch. Use the thinnest band that allows you to complete 3-5 reps. The goal is to use a progressively lighter band each week, not to do more reps with a heavy band. The band should assist, not launch you to the bar.

• Action: 3 sets of 3-5 banded pull-ups. Focus on a full range of motion, from a dead hang to chin over the bar. Combine this with continued negative training on separate days.

What Your First 60 Days of Pull-Up Training Will Actually Feel Like

Progress is not linear, and it won't be dramatic at first. Understanding the timeline will keep you from quitting when it feels like nothing is happening. This is what you should expect.

Weeks 1-2: Your hands and forearms will be the weakest link. The dead hangs will feel awkward and your grip will fail long before your back does. You will feel no closer to a pull-up. This is normal. You are building the non-negotiable foundation of grip strength. Without it, nothing else matters.

Month 1 (Weeks 3-4): You will start doing negatives. The first few will feel like a controlled fall. By the end of the month, you should be able to control the descent for 3-5 seconds. You will feel your lats-the big muscles on the sides of your back-in a way you never have before. This is a huge win, even though you still can't pull yourself up. This is the phase where most people give up because the goal still feels impossible. Do not stop.

Month 2 (Weeks 5-8): This is where the magic happens. Your 5-second negative will turn into an 8-second, then a 10-second negative. The movement will feel smooth and controlled. One day, after a warm-up, you'll attempt a pull-up from a dead hang and you will shock yourself. Your chin will clear the bar. It might not be pretty, but it will be a full rep. From there, your progress will accelerate. Getting the first rep is the hardest part. Going from 1 to 5 is ten times easier.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Chin-Ups vs. Pull-Ups for Beginners

A chin-up (palms facing you) is easier than a pull-up (palms facing away). It involves more bicep, a muscle that is already relatively strong for most people. Achieving your first chin-up is a fantastic stepping stone and builds confidence and strength that directly transfers to the pull-up.

The Role of Body Weight in Pull-Up Difficulty

Body weight is a massive factor. A pull-up is a relative strength exercise. If you weigh 150 pounds, you are lifting 150 pounds. If you lose 10 pounds of body fat, you are now lifting 140 pounds. It's simple math. Combining this training program with a sensible fat loss plan will dramatically speed up your progress.

Necessary Training Frequency

Train these pull-up progressions 2-3 times per week. Your muscles need time to recover and grow stronger. Training them every day is counterproductive and leads to burnout and injury. Give yourself at least 48 hours of rest between sessions. Quality over quantity is the rule.

Alternative Exercises If You Have No Bar

The single best alternative is the inverted row. Lie under a sturdy table, grab the edge, and pull your chest up to the table. This mimics the horizontal pulling motion and builds significant back and bicep strength. It's the closest you can get to a pull-up without a bar.

Grip Strength as the Limiting Factor

If your grip consistently fails before your back or arms, you need to add specific grip work. Farmer's walks are excellent. Grab the heaviest dumbbells you can hold and walk for 30-60 seconds. This, combined with the dead hangs in the program, will solve any grip strength issues.