Overhead Press Plateau Reddit

Why Your Overhead Press Is Stuck (It's Not Your Strength)

If you're stuck in an overhead press plateau like so many on Reddit, the fix isn't just trying harder; it's increasing your total weekly volume by 10-20% using weights you can actually handle. You're likely stuck at a number-95, 135, maybe 155 pounds-and it hasn't budged in months. Every week you load the bar, give it everything you have, and either fail the last rep or grind it out so ugly you know you can't add more weight. It's the most frustrating lift to stall on because progress feels impossible.

The overhead press (OHP) is not like your squat or deadlift. It's a sensitive lift that uses smaller, more delicate muscle groups. Adding 5 pounds to a 315-pound squat is a 1.5% increase in weight. Adding 5 pounds to a 135-pound OHP is a 3.7% increase-more than double the relative jump. Your shoulders, triceps, and stabilizer muscles can't handle that kind of leap week after week. Trying to force it by adding 5-pound plates is a recipe for failure, frustration, and potential shoulder injury. The secret isn't adding more weight to the bar right now. It's adding more *work* over the course of the week.

The Volume Mistake 90% of Lifters Make on Their OHP

The reason your overhead press plateau feels unbreakable is that you're focused on the wrong variable. You're obsessed with *intensity* (the weight on the bar), when you should be obsessed with *volume* (total weight lifted across all sets and reps). Volume is what builds muscle and strength. Intensity is how you test it.

Volume is calculated with a simple formula: Sets x Reps x Weight.

Let's look at two lifters, both trying to break a 135-pound OHP plateau.

• Lifter A (The Grinder): Tries to hit 135 lbs for 3 sets of 5. They get the first two sets, but fail on the 4th rep of the last set. Their form breaks down, and they end the workout feeling defeated.
• Total Volume: (2 sets x 5 reps x 135 lbs) + (1 set x 3 reps x 135 lbs) = 1350 + 405 = 1,755 lbs.
• Lifter B (The Strategist): Drops the weight to 120 lbs, a weight they can handle with perfect form. They do 5 sets of 5 reps.
• Total Volume: 5 sets x 5 reps x 120 lbs = 3,000 lbs.

Lifter B did over 1,200 pounds more work than Lifter A. They completed every rep, practiced perfect form, and sent a powerful signal to their muscles to grow stronger. Lifter A just practiced failure. To break your plateau, you must be willing to take a small step back in weight to take a huge leap forward in volume. Your ego will object for about two weeks. Your results after four weeks will silence it for good.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 4-Week Protocol to Break Any Overhead Press Plateau

This is not a theoretical plan. This is a 4-week microcycle designed to accumulate volume, increase strength, and smash through your current sticking point. You will press twice a week: one main OHP day and one variation/volume day.

Step 1: Find Your Real Training Max (TM)

Your Training Max is not your one-rep-max (1RM). It's a weight you can lift for 3-5 clean reps with no form breakdown. If your absolute max OHP is 135 pounds, you probably can't hit it for 3-5 reps. Your TM might be closer to 120 or 125 pounds. A simple way to set it is to take 90% of your current estimated 1RM. For this example, we'll use a TM of 125 pounds.

Step 2: The Volume Accumulation Phase (Weeks 1-2)

The goal here is simple: get the reps in. The weight will feel manageable, even easy, on week one. That is the point. Focus on moving the bar as fast as possible during the upward press.

• Day 1 (e.g., Monday): Main OHP
• Movement: Barbell Overhead Press
• Programming: 5 sets of 5 reps @ 80% of your TM. (125 lbs x 0.80 = 100 lbs). So, 5x5 @ 100 lbs.
• Day 2 (e.g., Thursday): Variation & Accessory Day
• Movement: Seated Dumbbell Press
• Programming: 4 sets of 8-10 reps. Pick a weight that is challenging for the last 2 reps of each set.
• Accessory Work (Both Days): After your main press, do 2 of the following:
• Lateral Raises: 3 sets of 15-20 reps.
• Tricep Pushdowns: 3 sets of 10-12 reps.
• Face Pulls: 3 sets of 20 reps.

Step 3: The Intensity Phase (Week 3)

Now we ramp up the intensity to see how the volume work has paid off. We will introduce an AMRAP (As Many Reps As Possible) set. This is your test.

• Day 1 (e.g., Monday): Main OHP + AMRAP
• Movement: Barbell Overhead Press
• Programming: 3 sets of 3 reps @ 85% of your TM (125 lbs x 0.85 = ~105 lbs). After your last set, rest 2-3 minutes, then do one AMRAP set at the same weight (105 lbs). Your goal is to get 5 or more reps. If you hit 8 reps, you know you've gotten significantly stronger.
• Day 2 (e.g., Thursday): Overload Variation
• Movement: Push Press
• Programming: 5 sets of 3 reps. Use a weight that is 10-15% heavier than your strict press TM. This gets your body used to holding heavier weight overhead.

Step 4: The Test and Reset (Week 4)

This week is about realizing your new strength. You will deload slightly and then test for a new personal record.

• Day 1 (e.g., Monday): Deload
• Movement: Barbell Overhead Press
• Programming: 3 sets of 5 reps @ 60% of your TM (75 lbs). The goal is recovery and feeling fresh.
• Day 2 (e.g., Thursday): Test Day
• Warm up thoroughly. Work your way up in weight, doing single reps.
• Example: 45x10, 75x5, 95x3, 115x1, 125x1...
• Then, attempt your new max. Try for 140 or 145 pounds-a 5-10 pound jump from your old max of 135. You should find it moves cleaner and feels more stable than ever before.

After this test, you take your new max, calculate 90% to find your new TM, and begin the 4-week cycle again.

What to Expect: Your OHP Progress in the Next 30 Days

Progress isn't just about the number on the bar. Here is what this 4-week cycle will actually feel like and what to look for.

• Week 1: This will feel wrong. The weight (5x5 @ 100 lbs) will feel too light, and your ego will tell you to add more. Do not listen. Your job this week is to own that weight. Make every rep explosive and perfect. You are building momentum and letting your joints recover from the constant grinding.
• Week 2: The volume starts to catch up. The 4th and 5th sets of your 5x5 will begin to feel challenging. This is the signal that adaptation is happening. You are accumulating fatigue and stimulating growth. You should feel a deep connection to your shoulders and triceps.
• Week 3: This is the breakthrough. The AMRAP set at 105 pounds will tell you everything. When you hit 6, 7, or even 8+ reps with a weight that used to be a struggle, you will finally understand that the process works. This is the confidence boost that proves the program.
• Week 4: Test day. A 5-10 pound increase on your OHP in one month is a huge win. Do not be disappointed if you don't add 20 pounds. The OHP is a marathon, not a sprint. A consistent 5 pounds every 4-6 weeks will turn a 135-pound press into a 200-pound press in a year. That is elite progress.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.

Frequently Asked Questions

OHP Frequency Per Week

Press twice a week. One day should be your primary barbell OHP focused on the prescribed progression (like the 5x5). The second day should be a lighter variation, like a seated dumbbell press or Z-press, to add volume and work on stability without burning out your central nervous system.

Top 3 OHP Accessory Lifts

The three best accessories to build a bigger press are: 1) Seated Dumbbell Press, which builds raw shoulder and tricep strength without requiring core stability. 2) Lateral Raises, which build the side delts, creating a wider and more stable base to press from. 3) Dips or Close-Grip Bench Press, which build powerful triceps to help you lock out the weight overhead.

Fixing Form vs. Strength

If your lower back arches dramatically or the bar drifts forward away from your face, your problem is likely form or a weak core. Record a video of your lift from the side. The bar path should be almost perfectly vertical. If your form is solid and the bar just stops moving, your problem is raw strength, and you need to follow the volume protocol.

Barbell vs. Dumbbell OHP

The barbell OHP is king for maximal overload and building absolute strength. Dumbbells are superior for correcting muscle imbalances between your left and right side and improving shoulder stability. A good program uses both: the barbell for your main strength work and dumbbells as a key accessory.

Using Push Press to Break a Plateau

Yes, the push press is an excellent tool. By using a little leg drive, you can handle 10-20% more weight than your strict press. This overloads the top half of the movement and strengthens your triceps and lockout. It also builds your confidence with heavier weight. Use it as a secondary movement, not a replacement for your strict press.