If My Lifts Are Stalling Should I Eat More or Deload

The 3-Session Rule: Your Answer to "Eat More or Deload?"

If your lifts are stalling and you're wondering whether you should eat more or deload, the answer for 90% of people is to deload first, but only after you fail to progress on the same lift for 3 consecutive sessions. You're stuck. The weight on the bar hasn't budged in weeks. You see other people in the gym getting stronger, but your bench press, squat, or deadlift feels glued to the floor. You've heard two pieces of advice: "You gotta eat more to grow!" and "You're overtrained, you need to rest!" Making the wrong choice feels risky. Eating more could just make you gain unwanted fat, while deloading feels like giving up and getting weaker. The frustration is real, and it's the number one reason people quit their programs.

Here’s the simple diagnostic tool that cuts through the confusion: The 3-Session Rule.

1. Fail Session #1: You attempt a new personal record or your prescribed weight for the day (e.g., 225 lbs for 5 reps) and you only get 4. Don't panic. This could be anything: a bad night's sleep, a stressful day at work, or not eating enough beforehand. It's just data.
2. Fail Session #2: Your next session for that same lift comes around. You attempt 225 lbs for 5 again, and you still only manage 4 reps. Now it's a pattern, not a fluke. Something is holding you back.
3. Fail Session #3: The third time you attempt 225 lbs for 5, you hit a wall at 4 reps again, or maybe even just 3. This is it. This is a true stall. You have officially accumulated more fatigue than your body can recover from between workouts.

At this point, the answer is not to eat more. Eating an extra 500 calories tonight won't magically fix the deep fatigue that took weeks to build up. The answer is to deload. A deload is a strategic, short-term reduction in training stress that allows your body to shed fatigue, repair tissue, and come back stronger. Eating more is a long-term strategy to fuel future progress, not a quick fix for a current stall.

Stop guessing. Start progressing.

Track your lifts. Know exactly when to push and when to deload.

The Fatigue Mask: Why Your "Stall" Isn't a True Strength Limit

That feeling of being “stuck” at a certain weight isn’t because you’ve hit your genetic strength ceiling. For 99% of lifters, a plateau is just your true strength being masked by accumulated fatigue. Think of your strength potential as a 100-watt lightbulb. It’s always capable of shining brightly. Fatigue is a dimmer switch. Every hard workout turns the dimmer switch down a little. Good sleep, nutrition, and rest days turn it back up. But over 4-8 weeks of consistent, hard training, the switch gets turned down more than it gets turned up. Eventually, your 100-watt bulb is only shining at 60 watts. You’re still a 100-watt lifter, but the fatigue is hiding it.

When you try to push through a plateau by grinding out reps, you're just turning the dimmer switch down even further. This is where people make the biggest mistake. They think the solution to not being strong enough is to train harder, but this only digs a deeper recovery hole. This is explained by the Stimulus-Recovery-Adaptation (SRA) curve. You apply a stimulus (workout), your body recovers, and then it adapts by getting stronger. A stall happens when your recovery phase is too short or incomplete before you apply the next stimulus. You're interrupting the process before the adaptation can happen.

A deload is simply a planned period to let the recovery phase complete. It turns the dimmer switch all the way back up. You’re not getting weaker; you’re just revealing the strength that was already there, hidden under layers of fatigue. Eating more calories can help turn the switch up faster, but it can't override a massive fatigue debt on its own. The deload is the reset button. It guarantees your nervous system and muscles get the break they need to perform at 100% again.

You now understand the SRA curve and the fatigue mask. But theory is one thing, execution is another. Look back at your last 12 workouts. Can you pinpoint the exact day your fatigue started to outpace your recovery? If you can't see the trend, you're flying blind, waiting for the next stall instead of preventing it.

Your strength gains. All in one place.

Every workout logged. See the proof you're getting stronger week after week.

The Mofilo 7-Day Deload Protocol to Break Your Plateau

Stop guessing and stop grinding. A deload isn't a week off, and it isn't just “going easy.” It’s a precise tool. Follow this 7-day protocol exactly. It’s designed to shed fatigue while maintaining your technique and momentum, so you come back stronger, not rusty. This protocol runs for one full week of your training schedule.

Step 1: Choose Your Method: Volume or Intensity Reduction

You have two primary options for a deload. Pick one and stick with it for the week.

• Intensity Reduction (Recommended): Keep your sets and reps the same, but reduce the weight on the bar to 50-60% of your normal working weight. If you normally squat 250 lbs for 3 sets of 5, you will squat 125-150 lbs for 3 sets of 5. Each rep should feel fast and explosive. This is our preferred method because it allows you to practice perfect form without any strain.
• Volume Reduction: Keep the weight on the bar the same, but cut your total number of sets in half. If you normally do 4 sets of 8 on the bench press, you will do just 2 sets of 8. This method works, but can still feel heavy for some. For your first deload, stick with the intensity reduction method.

Step 2: Stop All Sets 3-4 Reps from Failure

Regardless of the method you choose, the goal is zero struggle. Every single set you perform during a deload week should end feeling easy. You should feel like you could have done another 4, 5, or even 6 reps if you had to. This is called leaving “reps in reserve” (RIR). During a deload, your RIR should be 4+. If you have to grind at all, the weight is too heavy or you’re doing too many reps. The purpose is to stimulate, not annihilate.

Step 3: Keep Your Diet and Sleep Consistent

This is critical. Do not use your deload week as an excuse to cut calories or stay up late. Changing too many variables at once makes it impossible to know what worked. Your body repairs and recovers most effectively when it has adequate fuel and rest. Keep your protein intake high (around 0.8-1.0 grams per pound of bodyweight) and aim for 7-9 hours of quality sleep per night. The deload handles the training stress; your job is to give your body the resources it needs to heal.

Step 4: Plan Your Return Workout

After your 7-day deload is complete, you don’t jump straight back to the weight you failed at. This sets you up for failure again. Instead, you work back up. Let’s say you stalled at 225 lbs for 5 reps on the bench press. Your first session back should be at about 95% of that weight. So, you would aim for 215 lbs for 5 reps. It should feel significantly easier and more powerful than before the deload. If that moves well, then in the following session, you can confidently attack 225 lbs again and break through the plateau.

Your First Workout Back Will Feel Too Easy. That's the Point.

Let's be clear: the deload week itself will feel unproductive. You'll leave the gym feeling like you didn't do anything. You might feel restless or even a little lazy. This is the entire point. If you leave a deload workout feeling tired, you did it wrong. You are actively managing fatigue, and the sign that it's working is that you feel fresh, not sore.

Your first workout after the deload is the real test. When you approach the bar for that first heavy-ish set (e.g., the 215 lbs from our example), it should feel lighter than you remember. The bar should move faster. This is the feeling of your true strength being unmasked. This is the payoff.

So, when should you eat more?

This is the question that started it all. You eat more *after* a successful deload proves that fatigue was the issue. If you break your plateau and continue to make progress for another 2-4 weeks but then stall again, that is the signal that your body needs more resources to support your new, higher level of strength. Your recovery capacity has become the new bottleneck.

At that point, increase your daily calories by a modest 200-300. Don't add 1,000 calories overnight. A small, controlled surplus, primarily from carbohydrates and protein, will provide the fuel needed to recover from harder training and build new muscle tissue without adding excessive body fat. The deload fixes the immediate stall; eating more prevents the next one from happening so soon.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Should a Deload Last?

A standard deload lasts for one full training week (typically 7 days). This allows you to hit each of your main lifts once with the reduced load, ensuring your nervous system stays primed while systemic fatigue drops off. A deload shorter than 4-5 days is often not enough to dissipate weeks of accumulated fatigue.

Can I Do Cardio During a Deload?

Yes, but keep it low-intensity and low-impact. Think walking on an incline, light cycling, or swimming. This is not the week for high-intensity interval training (HIIT) or long, grueling runs. The goal is to reduce overall stress, not add more from a different source. 20-30 minutes of light cardio is fine.

What If I'm Still Stalled After a Deload?

If you deload correctly and are still stuck at the same weight, it's a sign the problem isn't just fatigue. Look at other variables: Is your sleep consistently poor (under 7 hours)? Is your protein intake too low? Is your form breaking down at heavier weights? Or is your program itself no longer appropriate for you? This is the time to analyze your technique and overall program structure.

Should I Deload If I'm Trying to Lose Weight?

Yes, absolutely. Deloading is even more important when you're in a calorie deficit. A deficit is an added stressor on your body, which reduces your recovery capacity. Strategic deloads are crucial for preserving muscle mass and strength while you're cutting. It prevents you from burning out and losing the strength you've worked hard to build.

Is Taking a Full Week Off the Same as a Deload?

No, they are different tools for different purposes. A full week off can be great for mental and physical recovery, but an active deload is superior for breaking a specific lifting plateau. By training with lighter weights, you maintain and rehearse your motor patterns and technique, so you don't feel rusty or uncoordinated when you return to heavy lifting.