Should I Trust Fitness Data or How I Feel

Why Your Feelings Are Lying (But So Is Your Watch)

The answer to the question of whether you should I trust fitness data or how I feel is to use the 80/20 rule: trust objective performance data 80% of the time for long-term trends and your subjective feelings 20% of the time for in-the-moment adjustments. You're stuck because you think it's a choice between one or the other. It's not. Your fitness watch is a liar of convenience, and your feelings are an unreliable narrator. The real path to progress is using both, but in the right proportions.

Let's be clear. When your watch says your recovery is at 95% but you feel like you were hit by a truck, who do you listen to? When you feel amazing but your watch claims you only got 4 hours of “restorative sleep,” do you skip your workout? This conflict is where most people get stuck, either pushing into overtraining by blindly following data or stagnating by only ever training when they “feel like it.”

Data is objective but lacks context. It can tell you your heart rate was 150 bpm, but it can't tell you if that was because you were running or because you were stressed about a work email. Feelings provide that context but are wildly subjective. A bad night's sleep can make an easy workout feel like a max-effort lift. The solution is to stop treating them as competing sources of truth and start using them as a system of checks and balances. Your logbook tells you the long-term story; your body tells you how to act today.

The Hidden Biases That Skew Your Feelings and Data

To use the 80/20 rule, you first have to understand why both data and feelings are flawed. Trusting either one 100% of the time is a guaranteed way to stall your progress. The real “data” that matters most isn't the recovery score on your wrist; it's the numbers in your training log.

First, let's talk about feelings. Your subjective sense of energy is influenced by dozens of factors that have nothing to do with your actual physical readiness. Did you argue with your partner? Are you stressed about a deadline? Did you eat a heavy meal? All of these can make you “feel” weak, even if your muscles are fully recovered and ready to work. Conversely, a great song or a shot of pre-workout can make you feel invincible, tempting you to push too hard on a day your body actually needs a break. Your feelings are a lagging indicator, reflecting the last 12 hours of your life, not just your training recovery.

Now, for the data from your wearable. That “calories burned” number? It can be off by 20-40%. It's an estimate based on a generic algorithm. Your sleep score? It's a proprietary black box. It can't distinguish between a night of deep sleep and a night where you were just lying very still. A single alcoholic drink can tank your HRV score, making the device think you’re on the verge of collapse when you’re perfectly fine to train. This data is interesting, but it's not gospel.

The only data that is 100% true is your performance log. Did you lift 135 pounds for 5 reps last week? And did you lift it for 6 reps this week? That is an undeniable, objective fact. That is progress. This is the 80% you trust.

You now know the difference between watch data and real performance data. But knowing your deadlift was 225 lbs for 5 reps is only half the story. What was it 8 weeks ago? Can you prove, with numbers, that you are stronger today than you were two months ago? If the answer is "I'm not sure," you're just exercising, not training.

Stop guessing if you're getting stronger.

Track your lifts. See your strength grow week by week.

The 3-Step Checklist for Any Training Day

This is the practical system for ending the confusion. Before every single workout, you will run through this three-step checklist. It takes less than 60 seconds and provides a clear, logical path forward, removing emotion and guesswork from the equation.

Step 1: Review the Objective Data (The Plan)

Before you even think about how you feel, open your training log. Look at the last time you performed the main exercises for today's session. Let's say today is a squat day, and last week you squatted 185 pounds for 3 sets of 8 reps. Your objective, data-driven plan for today is to beat that. That could mean aiming for 185 pounds for 3 sets of 9 reps, or increasing the weight to 190 pounds for 3 sets of 8 reps. This is your starting plan. It is based on proven, historical performance, not a vague feeling.

Step 2: Check Your Subjective Feelings (The Reality Check)

Now, and only now, do you consult your feelings. Rate your overall state on a simple 1-to-5 scale. Be brutally honest.

• 5/5 (Excellent): You feel fantastic, slept great, high energy. Execute the plan from Step 1. You might even feel good enough to push for an extra rep or two on your final set.
• 4/5 (Good): You feel solid. No complaints. Execute the plan from Step 1 without modification.
• 3/5 (Okay): You're a bit tired, maybe some minor soreness or life stress. The warm-up is your final test. Start the workout with the original plan. More often than not, once you start moving, you'll feel better and be able to complete the workout as planned. Don't let a “meh” feeling derail you before you even start.
• 2/5 (Poor): You're dragging. Sore, tired, didn't sleep well. Today is not the day to push for a personal record. Modify the plan. Reduce the weight on your main lifts by 10-20% (e.g., use 155-165 pounds instead of 185). Focus on perfect form and tempo. This becomes a technique day or an active recovery session, not a performance day. You still get the work in, but you respect your body's current state.
• 1/5 (Awful): You are genuinely sick, injured, or completely exhausted. Do not train. This is a forced rest day. Go for a walk, do some light stretching, and focus on recovery. Pushing through this will set you back for a week, while taking the day off will have you back at 100% in a day or two.

Step 3: Execute and Record (The New Data)

Based on your decision in Step 2, perform the workout. Immediately after, record what you *actually* did. If you planned for 3x9 at 185 but only got 9, 9, and 7 reps, write that down. If you dropped the weight to 165 and did 3x10, write that down. Add a one-word note like “Strong,” “Grind,” or “Tired.” This act of recording creates the new objective data point that will become your plan for next week. This closes the loop and ensures you are always making decisions based on real-world performance.

What Your Progress Looks Like in 60 Days

Adopting this system will feel strange at first, but the clarity it provides will transform your training. Here is a realistic timeline of what to expect when you stop guessing and start making informed decisions.

In the first 2 weeks, it will feel mechanical. You'll be tempted to ignore the system and just go by feel, especially on days you feel great. You might second-guess your 1-5 rating. The most important thing is to stick with it. Follow the three steps-Plan, Check, Record-without fail. The goal in this phase is not perfect execution, but consistent data collection. You are building the foundation.

By month one (weeks 3-4), you will have a powerful dataset. You can look back and see clear patterns. You'll notice that on days you rated yourself a “3/5,” your performance was still solid. You'll see that after a “2/5” day where you reduced the weight, you came back stronger two days later. This is where confidence builds. You start to trust the process because you can see it working in your own logbook. The conflict between data and feelings begins to fade.

By day 60 (month two and beyond), the system becomes second nature. You will have calibrated your internal feelings against objective reality. You'll intuitively know the difference between being a little tired and needing to back off. You will break through plateaus because you are no longer sabotaging your progress by going too hard on low-energy days or coasting on high-energy days. Your progress will accelerate because every single workout serves a purpose, guided by a logical framework instead of a fleeting emotion.

That's the protocol. Review your plan, rate your feeling, then execute and record. For every exercise. Every workout. For the next 3 months. Most people start a notebook and forget it by week two. The ones who succeed don't have more willpower; they have a system that makes recording effortless.

Your progress. Your proof. All in one place.

Every workout logged. See exactly how far you've come and what to do next.

Frequently Asked Questions

My Watch Says My Recovery Is Low, But I Feel Great

Trust how you feel for today's workout, especially after your warm-up. A watch's recovery score is an algorithm-based guess. If you have energy and your warm-up sets feel strong, proceed with your planned workout. The low score could be from a late meal or stress, not training fatigue.

My Watch Says I Burned 1,000 Calories, But I'm Not Losing Weight

Ignore the calorie burn estimate on your watch. These numbers are notoriously inaccurate, often by 20-40%. For weight loss, trust only two data points: your daily calorie intake log and the average of your scale weight over a 2-4 week period. A consistent calorie deficit is what drives results.

How to Handle Conflicting Data (e.g., HRV vs. Performance)

Prioritize performance data over biometric data. Your training log is the ultimate source of truth. If you are consistently adding weight or reps to your lifts over time, your recovery is sufficient, regardless of what your daily HRV score says. Performance progress is the best indicator of adequate recovery.

The Best Single Metric to Track for Progress

The most important metric is your training log: sets, reps, and weight for your primary compound exercises. This is your objective proof that you are getting stronger. All other data-from the scale to your watch-is secondary to proving that your performance is improving over time.