How to Use Your Workout History to Decide What to Lift Today

The 'Last + 1' Rule: Your New Gym Compass

Here's how to use your workout history to decide what to lift today: look at your last performance for an exercise and add just one thing. That’s it. You either add one more rep than last time, or you add the smallest possible weight, like 2.5 or 5 pounds. This simple rule ends the confusion of walking into the gym and not knowing what to do. You're probably tired of guessing, doing the same routine for months with no change, or feeling like your effort isn't translating into real strength. The 'Last + 1' rule replaces that guesswork with a clear, data-driven plan. Instead of wondering if you should lift 135 pounds or 145 pounds on the bench press, your logbook will give you the exact answer. If last week you benched 135 for 8, 7, and 6 reps, your mission today isn't some random new weight. It's to bench 135 for 8, 7, and 7 reps. That one extra rep is the win. It's the signal to your body that it needs to adapt and get stronger. This is the foundation of getting consistently stronger, and it works for every single exercise, every single time.

Stop guessing. Start progressing.

Track your lifts in Mofilo. Know exactly what to lift to get stronger every week.

Why 'Just Working Out' Fails (And Tracking Succeeds)

Going to the gym and breaking a sweat feels productive, but if you're not systematically challenging your muscles, you're not training-you're just exercising. This is the critical difference between seeing results and staying stuck for years. The principle that drives all muscle and strength gain is called progressive overload. It simply means making your workouts slightly harder over time. Imagine trying to learn a new language by only ever practicing the same 10 words. You'd get very good at those 10 words, but you'd never become fluent. Your muscles work the same way. If you bench press 135 pounds for 8 reps every Monday for a year, your body has no reason to build more muscle or get stronger. It has already adapted to that specific challenge. Now, let's look at the math. A workout of 3 sets of 8 reps with 135 pounds moves a total volume of 3,240 pounds (135 x 8 x 3). If you do that every week, your total volume never changes. But if next week you get just one more rep on your last set (8, 8, 9 reps), your volume becomes 3,375 pounds. That small increase of 135 pounds is the signal that forces your body to adapt. The week after, maybe you increase the weight to 140 pounds and get 8, 7, 7 reps. Your volume is now 3,080 pounds-slightly less, but at a higher intensity. The goal is a constant upward trend in either weight or reps over months. Without tracking, you're blind to this trend. That's the principle: progressive overload. Add a rep or add a little weight. It's simple. But answer this honestly: what did you squat for how many reps four weeks ago? The exact numbers. If you can't answer in 5 seconds, you aren't using progressive overload. You're just guessing.

Your strength gains. All in one place.

Every workout logged. See the proof that you're getting stronger over time.

The 3-Step System for Any Exercise

This is the exact 'if-then' logic you can apply to every exercise in your program, from squats to bicep curls. It removes emotion and fatigue from the decision-making process and relies only on the data from your last session. All you need is a way to log your workouts-a simple notebook or an app works perfectly.

Step 1: Review Your Last Performance

Before you even touch a weight, open your workout log to the last time you performed this specific exercise. Don't rely on memory. Memory is wrong 90% of the time. You need the hard data. Look for two numbers: the weight you used and the exact reps you completed for each set.

• Example: Let's say your program calls for Barbell Rows, 3 sets of 6-8 reps. You look at your log from last Tuesday:
• Set 1: 115 lbs x 8 reps
• Set 2: 115 lbs x 8 reps
• Set 3: 115 lbs x 7 reps

This data is your starting point. It tells you exactly what you are capable of. You successfully completed 2 out of 3 sets in your target rep range.

Step 2: Apply the 'If-Then' Progression Logic

Now you use that data to make a decision for today. There are only two primary paths, making this incredibly simple.

• Path A: You Hit Your Rep Goal → Add Weight
• IF you successfully completed all your sets at the target rep count (e.g., your goal was 3x8 and you got 8, 8, 8), THEN you have earned the right to increase the weight.
• Action: Add the smallest increment possible. For a barbell exercise, this is usually 5 pounds total (a 2.5 lb plate on each side). For a dumbbell exercise, it's typically a 5-pound jump to the next dumbbell. Your goal with the new, heavier weight is to hit the *bottom* of your rep range. So if your range is 6-8 reps, you're now aiming for 120 lbs for at least 6 reps on each set.
• Path B: You Missed Your Rep Goal → Add Reps
• IF you did not complete all sets at the target rep count (like our Barbell Row example where you got 8, 8, 7), THEN you will use the exact same weight as last time.
• Action: Your entire focus for today's workout is to beat last week's performance by at least one rep. Using the example, your goal is to lift 115 lbs and get 8, 8, 8. Or maybe you get 8, 8, 7 again, but it felt easier. That's still progress. As long as you add a rep somewhere, you are progressing. You stay at this weight until you can successfully hit your target of 3 sets of 8 reps.

Step 3: Record Today's Results Immediately

This step is non-negotiable. As soon as you finish your last set of an exercise, write down what you did. Don't wait until you get home. Don't try to remember it at the end of the workout. The moment you re-rack the weight from your last set of squats, log it.

• Example Log Entry:
• Barbell Row: 115 lbs x 8, 8, 8 reps.

By doing this, you have just created the data needed for your *next* workout. You've closed the loop. Next Tuesday, when you go to do Barbell Rows, you'll see your log, know you succeeded at 115 lbs, and your instructions will be clear: move up to 120 lbs.

Your Progress Won't Be a Straight Line. Here's the Map.

Understanding how to use your workout history is a superpower, but it doesn't mean you'll add 5 pounds to your bench press every week forever. Progress is never a perfect, straight line going up. It looks more like a messy, jagged line that trends upward over months. Knowing what to expect will keep you from quitting when things inevitably get hard.

Weeks 1-12: The 'Newbie Gains' Phase

If you're new to structured training, the first 2-3 months are magical. You'll likely be able to add a rep or add weight almost every single session. Your body is adapting rapidly to the new stimulus. Enjoy it. This is the fastest progress you will ever make. It's common to add 20-30 pounds to major lifts like the squat and deadlift in this period.

Months 3-12: The Grind Begins

After the initial surge, progress slows down. This is normal. It does not mean you're doing something wrong. Now, adding one rep might take a full week. Adding 5 pounds to a lift might take 2-3 weeks of hitting your rep goals first. This is where most people get frustrated and quit because they think it's not working anymore. It is. This is what real, sustainable progress looks like. A 5-pound increase on your bench press every month is a 60-pound increase in a year. That is phenomenal progress.

When You Get Stuck (Plateaus)

A true plateau is when you are stuck at the same weight and reps for 3 or more consecutive sessions, despite good effort, nutrition, and sleep. A single bad workout is not a plateau; it's just a bad day. When you hit a real plateau, you have a few tools. You can take a 'deload' week, where you lift at 50-60% of your usual weights to give your body a recovery break. Or, you can switch the exercise variation (e.g., from barbell bench press to dumbbell bench press) for 4-6 weeks to provide a new stimulus.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Difference Between a Bad Day and a Plateau

A bad day is a single workout where your performance drops. It's usually caused by poor sleep, stress, or bad nutrition. A plateau is a trend over 2-3 weeks where you cannot add a single rep or any weight despite consistent effort. Don't change your program after one bad day.

How to Track When Using Dumbbells

The logic is the same. If your gym has 2.5 lb dumbbell increments, use them. If it only has 5 lb jumps (e.g., from 50 lbs to 55 lbs), you will need to work in a higher rep range before increasing weight. For example, instead of 6-8 reps, work in the 8-12 rep range. Only move up to the 55 lb dumbbells once you can do 3 sets of 12 reps with the 50s.

What to Do if The Gym Doesn't Have Small Plates

If your gym lacks 1.25 lb or 2.5 lb plates, making 5 lb jumps on barbell lifts too difficult, your best tool is adding reps. Instead of trying to go from 135 lbs to 145 lbs, stay at 135 lbs and work your way from 3x5 up to 3x10. Once you achieve that, the jump to 145 lbs for 5 reps will feel much more manageable.

How Long to Rest Between Sets

For heavy, compound exercises like squats, bench press, and deadlifts where strength is the goal, rest 2-5 minutes. This allows your nervous system to recover so you can give maximum effort on the next set. For smaller, isolation exercises like curls or lateral raises, 60-90 seconds is sufficient.

When to Change Exercises Completely

Don't change exercises just because you're bored. Change them when you have a reason. A good time to swap an exercise is after a persistent plateau (stuck for 3+ weeks) or after a long training block of 8-12 weeks to provide a novel stimulus to the muscle.