How to Tell If You Are Maingaining or Just Getting Fat

The Scale Is Lying to You About Your Maingain

To tell if you are maingaining or just getting fat, you must stop using the scale as your only source of truth and instead track three metrics together: a slow body weight increase of about 0.5% per month, a stable waist measurement, and consistent strength progression in the gym. You're eating more, lifting heavy, and the number on the scale is going up. But when you look in the mirror, you don't see chiseled new muscle; you see a softer, puffier version of yourself. The fear that you're just undoing all your hard work and getting fat is real, and it’s the number one reason people quit a building phase too early. Maingaining is not a magical process; it's a disciplined one. It’s about providing just enough fuel to build muscle while minimizing fat storage. The line is incredibly thin, and guessing will always land you on the wrong side. The good news is that you don't have to guess. By tracking these three data points, you can replace fear with facts. If your weight is climbing slowly, your lifts are going up, and your pants still fit the same, you are successfully maingaining. If your weight is shooting up, your waist is expanding, and your lifts are stagnant, you are just gaining fat.

Stop guessing if it's muscle or fat.

Track your lifts, weight, and measurements. See the proof of your progress.

The Hidden Math That Separates Muscle Gain From Fat Gain

The reason this three-metric system works comes down to the simple math of tissue growth. Your body can only build muscle at a very slow rate. For a relatively new lifter, the absolute maximum rate of lean muscle gain is around 0.5 pounds per week. For someone who has been training for a few years, that number drops to 0.5 pounds per month, or even less. Anything you gain faster than that is, by definition, not muscle. It's water and fat. So, if you step on the scale and you're up 5 pounds in two weeks, you can be certain that at least 4 of those pounds are not the muscle you wanted. This is the first checkpoint. A successful maingain involves a weight gain of only 1-2 pounds per month for an intermediate lifter. This translates to a tiny calorie surplus of just 200-300 calories above your maintenance level. A typical “bulk” that has you eating 500-1000 extra calories per day will always result in excessive fat gain. The second piece of the puzzle is density. One pound of muscle takes up about 18% less space than one pound of fat. This is why your waist measurement is your most powerful tool. As you maingain, you might gain 5 pounds of body weight, but if it's primarily muscle, your waist measurement will barely budge. Your shoulders and chest might get bigger, but your waistline stays tight. This is how you can look bigger and more muscular while weighing more, without looking fatter. You now know the rules: gain 0.5-1% of your body weight per month, watch your waist measurement, and get stronger. But knowing the rules and playing the game are different. Can you say, with 100% certainty, what your waist measured 4 weeks ago? Or what your bench press was 8 weeks ago? If the answer is 'I think so,' you're not maingaining. You're guessing.

Your transformation, tracked and proven.

See your strength numbers and body measurements change week by week.

Your 4-Week Maingaining Scorecard: A Step-by-Step Guide

Stop guessing and start measuring. This 4-week protocol will give you a definitive answer. Follow these steps without deviation. The goal is to collect clean data so you can make informed decisions instead of emotional ones.

Step 1: Establish Your Baseline (Day 1)

Before you do anything else, you need a starting point. On Day 1, first thing in the morning after using the bathroom and before eating or drinking anything, do the following:

• Body Weight: Record your weight to the first decimal point (e.g., 181.4 lbs).
• Measurements: Using a flexible tape measure, record the circumference of your waist (at the navel), hips (at the widest point), and chest (across the nipples). For extra data, you can also measure your flexed bicep and thigh.
• Progress Photos: Take photos in good, consistent lighting from the front, side, and back. Stand relaxed. Don't suck in or push out. These are for data, not for Instagram.
• Strength Numbers: In your logbook, note your top working sets for your main compound lifts. For example: Squat: 185 lbs for 3 sets of 5 reps. This is your strength baseline.

Step 2: Set Your Calorie and Protein Targets

Your nutrition dictates the outcome. Use an online calculator to estimate your Total Daily Energy Expenditure (TDEE), or your maintenance calories. Be honest about your activity level.

• Calories: Add 200 calories to your TDEE. If your maintenance is 2,500 calories, you will eat 2,700 calories per day. This small surplus is the key to minimizing fat gain.
• Protein: Set your protein target at 1 gram per pound of your target body weight. If you weigh 180 lbs and want to slowly reach 185 lbs, aim for 185 grams of protein daily. The remaining calories will come from carbs and fats.

Step 3: Track Weekly, Analyze Monthly

Consistency is everything.

• Daily: Weigh yourself each morning under the same conditions as Day 1. Don't react to daily fluctuations. At the end of the week, calculate the average of the 7 weigh-ins. This weekly average is your true weight trend.
• Weekly: Review your weekly average weight. Is it going up by about 0.25-0.5 pounds? If so, you are on track. If it's flat, add another 100 calories. If it's going up by 1+ pound per week, remove 100-200 calories.
• Monthly: After 4 full weeks, repeat the full baseline process: morning weight, all measurements, and new progress photos in the same lighting and poses.

Step 4: Interpret the Data (The Moment of Truth)

Now you compare your Day 1 data to your Day 28 data. Here are the two most likely scenarios:

• Scenario A (Successful Maingain): Your monthly weight is up 1-2 pounds. Your waist measurement is the same or has increased by no more than 0.5 inches. Your strength on major lifts has increased (e.g., you added 5-10 lbs to your squat for the same reps, or you added 1-2 reps with the same weight). Your photos show a slightly fuller, more dense look. Conclusion: You are successfully maingaining. Keep everything the same for another month.
• Scenario B (Getting Fat): Your monthly weight is up 4+ pounds. Your waist measurement has increased by 1 inch or more. Your strength gains are minimal or have stalled. Your photos look noticeably softer and less defined. Conclusion: Your surplus is too high. You are just getting fat. Reduce your daily calories by 200-300 and repeat the process for another 4 weeks.

What Your Maingain Will Actually Look and Feel Like

Understanding the timeline is crucial because the initial phases can feel misleading. Your body doesn't build muscle in a perfectly linear way, and you need to be patient to see the real trend emerge from the noise.

Month 1: The "Fluffy" Phase

Expect to feel a bit soft and bloated during the first 2-4 weeks. When you increase carbohydrates, your body stores more water (glycogen). This, combined with inflammation from harder training, can cause a quick 2-5 pound jump on the scale and a less-defined look in the mirror. This is not fat. It is water and inflammation. This is the period where most people panic and cut their calories, sabotaging the entire process. Your job is to ignore this initial phase, trust your small calorie surplus, and focus on getting stronger in the gym. The water weight will stabilize, and this is when the real data starts to show.

Month 3: The Trend Becomes Clear

By the end of the third month, the initial water weight is a distant memory. You should be up a total of 3-6 pounds from your starting weight. More importantly, your strength numbers should be undeniably higher. You should have added 15-30 pounds to your major lifts for the same rep range. When you compare your photos from Day 1 to Day 90, you will see a clear difference. You'll look bigger in your shoulders, back, and chest, but your waistline will have remained relatively stable. Your shirts will feel tighter in a good way, while your pants should still fit comfortably. This is the proof that your disciplined approach is working.

Month 6: Noticeable Transformation

After six months of consistent tracking and training, the results are no longer subtle. You've likely gained 6-12 pounds of high-quality body weight. The person in the mirror looks visibly more muscular. The weights you are lifting are substantially heavier than when you started. This slow, steady process has allowed you to build a significant amount of muscle without the corresponding fat gain that would require a long, miserable cutting phase. You have spent the last six months building, not just spinning your wheels in a cycle of bulking and cutting.

Frequently Asked Questions

What if My Strength Is Increasing But So Is My Waist?

This is a clear sign that your calorie surplus is too large. You're building muscle, but you're gaining fat at an unacceptable rate. The solution is simple: reduce your daily calorie intake by 100-200 calories. Keep protein high and continue training hard. Hold this new calorie target for 2-3 weeks and watch your waist measurement. The goal is to find the smallest surplus that still drives strength gains.

How Accurate Are Body Fat Scales?

They are not accurate for single readings. Bioimpedance scales are notoriously unreliable and can be thrown off by hydration levels, when you last ate, and even the temperature of your skin. Do not trust the day-to-day body fat percentage. Use them only to observe a very long-term trend over 3-6 months. For telling the difference between maingaining and getting fat, a simple tape measure around your waist is far more reliable and useful.

Can I Maingain While Doing a Lot of Cardio?

Yes, but it makes hitting your calorie target more difficult and critical. You must eat enough to fuel your lifting, your recovery, and the additional energy burned during cardio. If building muscle is your primary goal, it's best to limit intense, prolonged cardio sessions to 1-2 times per week. Prioritize lifting.

How Long Should I Maingain Before Cutting?

Continue the maingaining phase until you reach a body fat level you are no longer comfortable with. For most people, a good stopping point is when their waist measurement has increased by 2-3 inches from their leanest starting point, or when they can no longer see any abdominal definition. This gives you a solid base of new muscle to reveal during a short, effective cutting phase.

Is a "Dirty Bulk" Ever a Good Idea?

No. A dirty bulk is an inefficient strategy that prioritizes rapid weight gain at all costs. This rapid gain is overwhelmingly fat. You might spend 3 months gaining 20 pounds (3 pounds of muscle, 17 pounds of fat) and then have to spend the next 4-5 months in a miserable diet to lose the fat, likely losing some of the muscle you gained. Maingaining is a slower, smarter process that builds muscle without the unnecessary fat, saving you months of dieting.