Biggest Mistakes Intermediates Make When Tracking Workouts

The 3 Tracking Mistakes Keeping You Stuck (And It's Not Your Effort)

The biggest mistakes intermediates make when tracking workouts are focusing only on the weight on the bar, ignoring total volume, and treating every set like a one-rep max attempt. You're doing the hard part-showing up, working hard, and logging your lifts in a notebook or app. But after 6-18 months of training, the progress has slowed to a crawl. Your bench press has been stuck at 185 pounds for two months, and your squat feels heavier every week, not lighter. Your logbook is starting to feel less like a roadmap to getting stronger and more like a diary of your frustration. This is the intermediate plateau, and it’s not because you aren't trying hard enough. It's because you're tracking history instead of planning for progress. The goal of tracking isn't just to record what you did; it's to tell you exactly what to do next week to force your body to adapt. Most lifters track the wrong things. They see the weight on the bar as the only measure of success. If they can't add another 5 pounds, they feel like the workout was a failure. This is mistake #1. Mistake #2 is not understanding that `Weight x Reps x Sets = Volume`. You can get stronger without adding a single pound to the bar. Mistake #3 is chasing failure on every set, leading to burnout and stalled lifts. Fixing these three things will change everything.

See your strength grow week by week.

Track your lifts. Know exactly what to do next.

Why Your Logbook Is Lying About Your Progress

If you think progress is only about adding more weight to the bar, you're missing 90% of the picture. The real driver of muscle and strength gain is progressive overload, which is the gradual increase of stress placed upon the body during training. Intermediates hear this and think it just means lifting heavier. It doesn't. The most important metric for progress is total volume. Let's break it down with simple math. Imagine your bench press workout last week was 185 pounds for 3 sets of 5 reps. Your total volume for that exercise was: 185 lbs x 5 reps x 3 sets = 2,775 pounds. Now, imagine this week you can't add weight. You're stuck at 185. Instead of feeling defeated, you push for one extra rep on each set. Your workout becomes 185 pounds for 3 sets of 6 reps. The new volume is: 185 lbs x 6 reps x 3 sets = 3,330 pounds. You lifted the exact same weight, but you increased your total volume by 555 pounds. That is real, measurable progress. Your muscles were forced to do more work, and they will adapt by getting stronger. This is the secret intermediates miss. They stare at the 185 on the bar and see failure. The math shows a 20% increase in workload. Your logbook, if you only track weight, is lying to you. It's telling you you're stuck when you're actually making significant progress. This is why tracking reps and sets is just as critical as tracking weight. When you understand this, you unlock dozens of new ways to progress without constantly needing to add more plates. You can add a rep, add a set, or decrease rest time. They all increase the demand on your body and drive growth. You understand volume now. It's just math. But look at your last month of workouts. Can you calculate the total volume for your squat session from three weeks ago? Can you prove it's higher today? If you can't answer that in 10 seconds, you're not tracking progress-you're just keeping a diary.

Weeks of progress. All in one place.

Every workout logged. Proof you're getting stronger.

The 3-Step Weekly Review That Guarantees Progress

Stop letting your logbook be a passive record. It's time to turn it into an active tool. Once a week, take 10 minutes to perform this review. This is the system that separates people who are 'exercising' from those who are 'training'.

Step 1: Log Weight, Reps, Sets, and RPE

Your current tracking is incomplete. From now on, for your 3-4 main compound lifts (like squat, bench, deadlift, overhead press), you must log four metrics, not just three. The fourth is the game-changer: RPE, or Rate of Perceived Exertion. It’s a simple scale from 1 to 10 that measures how hard a set felt. For strength training, we only care about RPE 7 and up.

• RPE 10: Absolute failure. You couldn't have done another rep.
• RPE 9: You had exactly one more rep left in the tank.
• RPE 8: You had two clean reps left in the tank.
• RPE 7: You had three clean reps left.

An intermediate lifter should spend most of their time working in the RPE 7-9 range. Constantly hitting RPE 10 is a recipe for burnout and injury. Logging RPE gives context to your numbers. Benching 225 lbs for 5 reps at RPE 7 is a completely different workout than benching 225 lbs for 5 reps at RPE 10.

Step 2: Compare This Week vs. Last Week

Now, look at your log for your main lift. Let's use the squat as an example.

• Last Week: Squat - 225 lbs, 3 sets of 5 reps. RPE on the last set was 8.
• This Week: Squat - 225 lbs, 3 sets of 5 reps. RPE on the last set was 7.

What does this tell you? The weight and reps are identical, but the RPE went down. This means you got stronger. The same workload felt easier. This is a huge win. Without RPE, you would have looked at your log and thought you made zero progress. Now you know you have room to push next week.

Step 3: Make One Small Change for Next Week's Plan

This is where you make the decision that drives progress. Based on your review, you will decide exactly what to do next week. Follow these rules:

• If you hit your target reps and sets, and the final set was RPE 8 or lower: Add weight. For upper body lifts, add 2.5-5 lbs. For lower body lifts, add 5-10 lbs. Your goal for next week is to lift the new, heavier weight for the same number of reps.
• If you hit your target reps and sets, but the final set was RPE 9: Keep the weight the same. Your goal for next week is to add one rep to your first set. So, if you did 3x5, you'll aim for 6, 5, 5. This increases total volume without the big jump in intensity from adding weight.
• If you failed to hit your target reps OR your final set was RPE 10: Keep the weight and reps the same. Your goal for next week is to hit your target reps with better form and try to lower the RPE. If you fail for two weeks in a row, it's time to consider a deload.

This system removes all guesswork. You know exactly why you're doing what you're doing. Every workout has a purpose, guided by the data from the last one.

What Real Progress Looks Like (It's Slower Than You Think)

As a beginner, you could add 5 pounds to the bar every week. Those days are over. Progress as an intermediate is slower, less linear, and requires more patience. Understanding the new timeline will keep you from quitting when things get tough.

In the First Month: After implementing this tracking system, you'll feel a renewed sense of momentum. You'll see your total volume climbing week over week, even if the weight on the bar only moves once or twice. You might add 5-10 pounds to your squat and deadlift, and 5 pounds to your bench press. The main feeling will be one of control; you finally have a real plan.

Months 2-6: This is where the grind begins. Progress will slow. You might only add 5 pounds to a lift per month, not per week. Some weeks, your victory will be a single extra rep. Other weeks, it will be hitting the same numbers at a lower RPE. This is not a sign of failure. This *is* the process of intermediate progression. You are building strength brick by brick, not by the truckload. You will have weeks where you go backward. You'll feel tired, fail a lift you made last week, and question everything. This is normal. Trust the data. If your volume is trending up over the course of a month, you are succeeding.

Warning Signs You're Off Track:

• Your lifts are decreasing for 2-3 weeks in a row. This isn't a bad day; it's a trend. You are likely under-recovering. It's time for a deload week (cut volume and intensity by 50%).
• Every workout feels like an RPE 10 grind. You're pushing too hard, too often. You need to spend more time in the RPE 7-8 range to allow for recovery and sustainable progress.
• You feel no soreness and every lift feels easy (RPE 5-6). You're not pushing hard enough. Your working sets need to be at least an RPE 7 to signal your body to adapt. You've gotten comfortable. It's time to add a rep or add 5 pounds.

Frequently Asked Questions

Tracking Volume for Every Exercise

No, this is overkill and leads to burnout. Focus on calculating and progressing total volume for your 3-4 primary compound movements per week. These are the lifts that drive the most overall strength. For accessory work like bicep curls or leg extensions, simply focus on hitting your target reps with good form and feeling the muscle work.

The Role of RPE and RIR

RPE (Rate of Perceived Exertion) and RIR (Reps in Reserve) are two sides of the same coin. An RPE of 8 means you had 2 reps left in the tank, which is an RIR of 2. It’s a tool to auto-regulate your training. On days you feel great, you can push a little harder. On days you feel worn down, you can pull back slightly, all while staying within your planned progression.

Handling Failed Reps in Your Log

Always log what you actually completed, not what you planned to do. If your goal was 5 reps but you only got 4, you log 4. This is not failure; it's data. It tells you that the load was too heavy for your capacity on that day. This information is critical for making the right decision for your next workout, which will likely be to keep the weight the same.

How Often to Deload

A deload is a planned period of reduced training stress. For an intermediate, a good rule of thumb is to take a deload week every 4-8 weeks of hard training. A more practical sign is when you stall on your main lifts for two consecutive weeks despite good sleep and nutrition. A deload week isn't a week off; it's a week at about 50% of your normal volume and intensity.

Switching From a Notebook to an App

A notebook works perfectly well. The main advantage of a dedicated fitness tracking app is automation. It will calculate your total volume, chart your progress on lifts over time, and show you your personal records at a glance. This saves you from doing the math manually and makes spotting trends much easier.