Biggest Mistakes Intermediates Make When Tracking Workouts

The 3 Tracking Mistakes Keeping You Stuck (And How to Fix Them)

The biggest mistakes intermediates make when tracking workouts are focusing only on weight, ignoring total volume, and not using the data to plan the next session; fixing these 3 things is the key to breaking any strength plateau. You're past the beginner phase. You show up, you lift, and you dutifully write down your sets, reps, and weight in a notebook or an app. But your numbers haven't budged in months. Your bench press is stuck at 185 lbs, your squat feels heavier every week, and you're starting to wonder if all this effort is even worth it. This is the most common frustration for intermediate lifters. The problem isn't your work ethic; it's that you're logging data, not tracking progress. Logging is passive recording. Tracking is active analysis used to make your next workout more effective than the last. Most intermediates are great loggers and poor trackers. They collect numbers without a system to interpret them. The good news is that shifting from logging to tracking requires a simple change in perspective, not more time in the gym. We'll break down the three core mistakes and give you a new framework that guarantees you'll know exactly what to do to get stronger next week.

Your workouts are logged. Are you stronger?

Track your lifts properly. See your strength grow week by week.

Why Your Notebook Is Lying to You: The Volume Load Formula

You think you're making progress because you went from doing 3 sets of 8 reps at 225 lbs to 5 sets of 5 reps at 235 lbs on your deadlift. More weight on the bar must mean you're stronger, right? Not necessarily. This is where the concept of Volume Load reveals the truth. Volume Load is the most important number in your training log, and 90% of intermediates ignore it. The formula is simple: Sets x Reps x Weight = Total Volume Load. It measures the total amount of work you performed for a specific exercise. Let's look at that deadlift example. Workout A: 3 sets x 8 reps x 225 lbs = 5,400 lbs of total volume. Workout B: 5 sets x 5 reps x 235 lbs = 5,875 lbs of total volume. In this case, you did make progress. But what if you did 3 sets of 6 reps at 235 lbs? That's only 4,230 lbs of volume-a significant step backward, even though the weight on the bar was higher. Your logbook, just showing weight and reps, would be lying to you. The fundamental principle of getting stronger (progressive overload) is about increasing this Volume Load over time. You can do this by adding weight, adding reps, or adding sets. Focusing only on adding weight is the fastest way to hit a wall. By tracking Volume Load, you open up multiple pathways to progress. If you can't add 5 lbs to the bar, you can add 1 rep to each of your sets. That's still progress. It's a small win that keeps the momentum going and eventually leads to bigger jumps in weight. You have the formula now: Sets x Reps x Weight = Volume Load. Simple. But look at your last 8 weeks of training logs. Can you calculate the exact volume trend for your bench press? If you can't, you're not using progressive overload. You're just hoping for it.

Weeks of progress. All in one place.

Every workout logged. Proof you're getting stronger.

The 3-Step System to Turn Your Logbook into a Progress Machine

Knowing your Volume Load is the first step. Turning that knowledge into a repeatable system for getting stronger is what separates intermediates who stay stuck from those who break through to advanced levels. This isn't about complicated spreadsheets or advanced programming. It's a simple, three-step process you can apply to your very next workout.

Step 1: Track the Right Variables

Your current log probably has 'Exercise,' 'Weight,' and 'Reps.' We need to add two more columns: 'Sets' and 'RPE.' RPE stands for Rate of Perceived Exertion, and it's your secret weapon for managing fatigue and knowing when to push. It's a scale from 1 to 10 measuring how hard a set felt.

• RPE 10: Maximum effort. You could not have done another rep.
• RPE 9: You had 1 rep left in the tank.
• RPE 8: You had 2 reps left in the tank.
• RPE 7: You had 3 reps left in the tank.

Most of your work should be in the RPE 7-9 range. Tracking RPE tells a story that weight and reps alone can't. If you did 3x5 at 225 lbs last week at an RPE 9, and this week you did it at an RPE 7, that's significant progress. Your strength improved even though the numbers on the bar stayed the same.

Step 2: Calculate and Aim to Beat Your Volume Load

After each workout, do the math for your main lifts. Let's use a squat workout as an example:

• Week 1 Squat: 4 sets x 6 reps @ 205 lbs. RPE 8.
• Volume Load: 4 x 6 x 205 = 4,920 lbs.

Your mission for your next squat session is simple: beat 4,920 lbs. That's it. This becomes your target. It removes all the guesswork and emotion. You have a clear, objective goal.

Step 3: Plan Your Next Session with the 'Plus One' Rule

How do you beat 4,920 lbs? You follow a simple progression hierarchy. Your first goal is always to add reps.

• Option A (Add Reps): Aim for 4 sets of 7 reps at 205 lbs. If you succeed, your new Volume Load is 4 x 7 x 205 = 5,740 lbs. That's a huge win.
• Option B (Add Weight): Once you reach the top of your target rep range (e.g., 8 reps per set), you earn the right to add weight. Drop your reps back down to the bottom of the range (e.g., 6 reps) and add 5-10 lbs to the bar. Your next session might be 4 sets of 6 reps at 215 lbs. The new Volume Load is 5,160 lbs. Still progress.
• Option C (Add a Set): What if you're stuck? You can't add a rep, and you definitely can't add weight. The answer is to add a set. Instead of 4x6, do 5x6 at 205 lbs. Your new Volume Load is 6,150 lbs. This is a powerful tool for breaking through plateaus that most intermediates never use.

This system gives you a logical path forward every single week. You're no longer just showing up and hoping to feel strong. You have a plan based on real data.

What Real Progress Looks Like (It's Not a Straight Line)

If you expect to add weight to the bar every single week, you're going to be disappointed. That's a beginner's game. For an intermediate, progress is slower and less linear, which is why tracking Volume Load is so critical. It allows you to see progress even when the weight on the bar doesn't change.

In the first 4 weeks of implementing this system, you should see your Volume Load increase on your main lifts every week. This might come from adding reps or an extra set. You might only increase the actual weight on the bar once or twice in that first month. This is normal and effective. For example, a realistic bench press progression might look like this:

• Week 1: 3x8 @ 185 lbs (4,440 lbs volume)
• Week 2: 3x9 @ 185 lbs (5,000 lbs volume)
• Week 3: 3x10 @ 185 lbs (5,550 lbs volume)
• Week 4: 3x8 @ 190 lbs (4,560 lbs volume) - Notice the volume dropped, but the weight increased. This is a planned reset to start the cycle again with a heavier weight.

After 8-12 weeks, you will hit a wall. Your body will accumulate fatigue, and you won't be able to increase your Volume Load. This is not failure; it's a signal. It's time for a deload week. For one week, you will cut your total volume by about 50%. You can do this by cutting your sets in half (e.g., do 2 sets instead of 4) or by reducing the weight by 20%. A deload is a planned, strategic retreat that allows your body to recover so you can come back stronger. A good rule of thumb is to plan a deload every 4 to 8 weeks, depending on how hard you're training. Tracking this properly prevents you from grinding yourself into dust and allows for sustained progress over years, not just weeks.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Difference Between RPE and RIR

RPE (Rate of Perceived Exertion) and RIR (Reps in Reserve) are two sides of the same coin. An RPE of 8 means you had 2 reps left in the tank, which is an RIR of 2. They measure the same thing; use whichever one makes more sense to you.

What to Do When You Can't Increase Any Variable

If you fail to beat last week's Volume Load, don't panic. First, check your recovery: sleep, nutrition, and stress. If those are off, that's likely the cause. If they're fine, it might be time for a deload week, even if it's not scheduled.

How to Track Accessory Lifts

You don't need to be as meticulous with Volume Load for exercises like bicep curls or lateral raises. For these, focus on hitting a target rep range (e.g., 10-15 reps) at a consistent RPE (e.g., RPE 8-9). Aim to add reps or weight over time, but don't over-analyze the volume.

The Role of Deload Weeks in Your Logbook

A deload is a planned part of your training. Mark it in your log. For example, write 'Deload Week' at the top. Perform your normal exercises but cut your sets in half. This data is important because it shows you're managing fatigue proactively, which is key to long-term gains.

Digital Apps vs. Paper Notebooks

A paper notebook is simple and effective. A good tracking app can automate the Volume Load calculation, which saves time and makes it easier to see trends. The best tool is the one you will use consistently. The method matters more than the medium.