Are Wide Grip Pull Ups Bad for Shoulders

The “Yes, But” Answer Most Trainers Won’t Give You

The direct answer to 'are wide grip pull ups bad for shoulders' is yes, for about 80% of people, because the 'extra-wide' grip you see online creates a direct path to shoulder impingement. You're likely here because you feel a pinch or a sharp pain at the top of the movement. You want a wider back, but every rep feels like it's costing you the health of your shoulder. You’re not imagining it, and it's not because you're weak. The problem isn't the pull-up; it's the 'wide grip' myth.

For decades, we've been told that a super-wide grip is the secret to a V-taper back. This is anatomically wrong for most human bodies. Your shoulder is a ball-and-socket joint. When you go excessively wide-well beyond 1.5 times your shoulder width-you force that joint into extreme internal rotation at the top of the pull. This causes the head of your humerus (your upper arm bone) to jam upwards into the acromion (a bony part of your shoulder blade). Your rotator cuff tendons get pinched in between. That sharp pain you feel? That's impingement. It's your body's fire alarm telling you to stop.

The fix is simple: bring your hands in. Your strongest and safest 'wide' grip is only about 1.5 times the width of your shoulders. For most men, this means their pinky fingers are just on the edge of the knurling on a standard pull-up bar, not halfway down the angled portion.

Why “Wider” Is Weaker for Building Your Back

You've been sold a lie: that a wider grip equals wider lats. The reality is that an excessively wide grip actually takes the lats *out* of the movement and puts the stress onto smaller, weaker muscles and, worse, the shoulder joint itself. It's a classic case of chasing the 'look' of an exercise instead of understanding its function.

Think of your lats. They are massive muscles that run down the sides of your back. Their primary job is to pull your upper arm down and back towards your body (adduction and extension). When your grip is at a biomechanically sound position (around 1.5x shoulder width), you can achieve a full range of motion. You can pull your chest to the bar, fully retracting your shoulder blades and getting a powerful squeeze in your lats. This is what stimulates growth.

Now, picture the ultra-wide grip. Your range of motion is cut in half. You can barely get your chin over the bar. You can't fully retract your shoulder blades. Because the angle is so extreme, the primary movers become the teres major and the rhomboids, not the lats. You're performing a partial rep that mainly stresses your shoulder joint for almost no lat-building benefit. It's like trying to squat by only bending your ankles. You’re missing the entire point of the movement. The number one mistake people make is believing that feeling a 'stretch' on the outside of their shoulders means they're working their lats. In reality, they are just straining their joint capsule.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 3-Step Protocol to Fix Your Pull-Up and End Shoulder Pain

If you're dealing with shoulder pain from pull-ups, stop pushing through it. That's a fast track to a chronic injury that could take you out of the gym for months. Instead, rebuild your pull-up from the ground up with this three-step protocol. The goal is to build a massive back, not to perform one specific exercise at all costs.

Step 1: Find Your Real “Power Grip”

Forget what you see on Instagram. Your strongest, safest grip is narrower than you think. Stand directly under a pull-up bar and place your hands straight overhead. This is your shoulder width. From there, move each hand outward by about half a hand's width. This is your new 'wide' grip, approximately 1.5 times your shoulder width. Grab the bar. It should feel strong and stable, not stretched and vulnerable. This position allows your shoulder joint to move freely and your lats to do the heavy lifting. This is your new standard pull-up grip. All your reps will be done from this position from now on.

Step 2: Master the Scapular Pull

The most important part of a pull-up happens before you even bend your arms. Before your next pull-up session, hang from the bar with your new Power Grip. Without bending your elbows, focus on pulling your shoulder blades down and back. Think about trying to tuck them into your back pockets. You should feel your body lift an inch or two. Hold for a second, then relax. This is a scapular pull. It forces your lats to initiate the movement, creating space in the shoulder joint. Do 3 sets of 8-10 reps as part of your warm-up. This one drill will completely change how your pull-ups feel.

Step 3: Use Safer, More Effective Alternatives

If you still feel pain even with a corrected grip, it means your shoulder is already inflamed and needs a break from that specific movement pattern. That doesn't mean you stop training your back. Switch to these alternatives, which are often even more effective for building your lats:

1. Neutral-Grip Pull-Ups: This is the king of shoulder safety. With your palms facing each other, the shoulder joint is in its most stable, externally rotated position. You'll be able to use a full range of motion and will likely be able to do 2-3 more reps than with a pronated (overhand) grip. This is your new primary vertical pulling movement.
2. Medium-Grip Lat Pulldowns: The pulldown machine is your best friend for learning proper form. Use the same 1.5x shoulder-width grip. Focus on driving your elbows down and back, and pulling the bar to your upper chest. Squeeze your lats for a full second at the bottom. This builds the mind-muscle connection you need for better pull-ups.
3. Single-Arm Dumbbell Rows: This movement builds raw pulling strength and thickness in your lats, which will carry over to your pull-up performance. Focus on a weight you can control for 3 sets of 8-12 reps per side, pulling the dumbbell towards your hip, not straight up.

What to Expect When You Ditch the Wide Grip

Changing a long-held habit will feel strange at first, but the results will speak for themselves. Here’s a realistic timeline of what you'll experience when you adopt a safer, stronger grip and prioritize joint health.

Week 1-2: It Will Feel “Easier” (And That’s Good)

Your first few sessions with a narrower, 1.5x shoulder-width grip might feel surprisingly easy. You might immediately be able to do 2-4 more reps per set. This isn't a trick. It's what happens when your strongest muscles (the lats) are finally in a position to do their job properly, instead of relying on small stabilizers and your joint capsule. The nagging pinch at the top of your shoulder should diminish or disappear completely. You'll feel soreness in the belly of your lats, not the front of your shoulder.

Month 1: Noticeable Strength and Less Pain

After four weeks of consistent training with proper form and safer alternatives, the chronic shoulder ache you associated with 'back day' will be a memory. Your pull-up numbers will be climbing steadily. More importantly, you'll feel a much stronger contraction in your back. When you look in the mirror, you'll start to see the width you were chasing, but it will be coming from actual muscle growth, not just joint stretching.

Warning Signs to Watch For:

Listen to your body. A dull, deep muscle soreness in your lats and biceps the day after training is a sign of progress. A sharp, stabbing, or pinching pain in the front or top of your shoulder during a rep is a stop sign. If you feel that, immediately stop the exercise. Do not push through it. Revert to an even safer variation, like lat pulldowns or rows, and focus on form.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Correct Pull-Up Grip Width

A simple rule of thumb is 1.5 times your shoulder width. Grab the bar with a grip that places your forearms perpendicular to the ground when you're at the top of the pull. Any wider significantly increases stress on the shoulder joint and reduces lat activation.

Neutral Grip vs. Wide Grip for Lats

Neutral grip pull-ups are far safer for your shoulders and excellent for overall lat development. While a very wide grip creates the *illusion* of targeting lat width, a medium or neutral grip done with a full range of motion is more effective for building actual muscle for most people.

Why Your Shoulders Hurt During Pull-Ups

The most common reason is shoulder impingement. This happens when an excessively wide grip causes the head of your humerus (upper arm bone) to jam into the acromion (part of your shoulder blade), pinching the rotator cuff tendons and bursa in between.

Building a Wide Back Without Wide Grips

Absolutely. A wide back is the result of large latissimus dorsi muscles. You can build impressive lats with medium-grip pull-ups, neutral-grip pull-ups, chin-ups, and various forms of heavy rows. The grip is a tool; the goal is lat growth, not a specific grip width.

Fixing Uneven Pull-Up Strength

If you notice one side pulling more than the other, incorporate unilateral (one-sided) work. Add single-arm dumbbell rows and single-arm lat pulldowns to your routine. When performing pull-ups, consciously focus on initiating the pull with your weaker arm to build that mind-muscle connection.