Should a Skinny Fat Person Cut or Bulk First

The ‘Neither’ Answer to the Skinny Fat Dilemma

The answer to whether a skinny fat person should cut or bulk first is neither; you need to do both at the same time through a process called body recomposition. This involves eating in a slight 200-300 calorie deficit while lifting heavy weights. You're likely here because you're stuck in a frustrating loop. If you eat less to lose the belly fat, you end up looking smaller and weaker, but still soft. If you eat more to build muscle, the fat around your midsection just gets worse. You feel like you can't win. This isn't in your head; it's a real problem for anyone with a body fat percentage between 18-25% (for men) or 25-32% (for women) but not enough muscle mass. Cutting aggressively strips away the little muscle you have, and bulking aggressively just adds more fat. The solution is to stop thinking in terms of 'cutting' or 'bulking' and start thinking like a sculptor. Your goal for the next 3-6 months is to change your body's composition, not just your weight on the scale. You will build a foundation of muscle while simultaneously using your stored body fat as energy to fuel the process. This method is uniquely effective for you because your body is new to the stimulus of proper training and nutrition, allowing it to do two things at once that a more advanced lifter cannot.

Why Your Body Can Build Muscle and Lose Fat Simultaneously

It sounds contradictory, but building muscle while losing fat is entirely possible for someone in a 'skinny fat' state. Here’s why it works for you and not for a seasoned bodybuilder. Your body fat is simply stored energy. When you start a proper strength training program, you send a powerful signal to your body to build new muscle tissue. This process requires energy. At the same time, by eating in a small calorie deficit (around 200-300 calories below your maintenance), you create a minor energy shortfall. Your body needs to get that missing energy from somewhere. Instead of slowing down muscle growth, it pulls the required energy from your fat stores. Think of it like renovating a house while living in it. You're using the old materials (fat) to power the construction of the new framework (muscle). The biggest mistake people make is copying the advice meant for advanced lifters. An experienced lifter with 10% body fat has very little stored energy and their body is already highly adapted to training. For them, building muscle requires a dedicated calorie surplus (a bulk). Trying to lose fat requires a dedicated deficit (a cut). They must do them in separate phases. But as a relative beginner, your body is hyper-responsive to training. This 'newbie gains' window is a unique opportunity where your body is so primed for change that it can effectively do both jobs at once. By trying to do a hard cut or a dirty bulk, you're wasting this window. Body recomposition is the specific tool for the specific job of fixing the skinny fat physique.

Tired of guessing? Track it.

Mofilo tracks food, workouts, and your purpose. Download today.

The 12-Week Skinny Fat Transformation Protocol

Stop guessing and follow a precise plan. For the next 12 weeks, this is your entire focus. Forget about fad diets or celebrity workouts. This is a simple, repeatable system based on proven principles. Your goal is not weight loss; it's composition change. The scale is a liar during this phase. Trust the mirror, your clothes, and your strength numbers in the gym.

Step 1: Calculate Your Recomposition Calories and Protein

Precision is key. We're aiming for a small, sustainable deficit. Here's the simple math:

1. Find Your Maintenance Calories: A reliable estimate is your bodyweight in pounds multiplied by 14. For a 170-pound person, this is 170 x 14 = 2,380 calories per day.
2. Create the Deficit: Subtract 200-300 calories from your maintenance number. For our 170-pound person, the daily target is between 2,080 and 2,180 calories.
3. Set Your Protein Target: This is non-negotiable. Eat 1 gram of protein per pound of your bodyweight. For the 170-pound person, that's 170 grams of protein daily. This protects your existing muscle and provides the building blocks for new muscle. 170g of protein is 680 calories (170 x 4).
4. Fill in Fats and Carbs: Subtract your protein calories from your daily total (e.g., 2,180 - 680 = 1,500 calories remaining). You can split these remaining calories between fats and carbohydrates however you prefer. A good starting point is 30% of total calories from fat and the rest from carbs.

Step 2: The 3-Day Full-Body Workout That Forces Growth

Your body needs a strong reason to build muscle. A full-body routine performed three times per week is the most effective way to provide that signal. Forget splitting your body into a chest day, back day, etc. You need to stimulate major muscle groups frequently. Alternate between these two workouts:

Workout A:

• Squats: 3 sets of 6-8 reps
• Bench Press: 3 sets of 6-8 reps
• Barbell Rows: 3 sets of 6-8 reps
• Face Pulls: 3 sets of 12-15 reps

Workout B:

• Deadlifts: 3 sets of 5 reps (do not go higher in reps on deadlifts)
• Overhead Press: 3 sets of 6-8 reps
• Lat Pulldowns (or Pull-ups): 3 sets of 8-10 reps
• Dumbbell Lunges: 3 sets of 10-12 reps per leg

Your weekly schedule will look like this:

• Week 1: Monday (A), Wednesday (B), Friday (A)
• Week 2: Monday (B), Wednesday (A), Friday (B)

The only thing that matters is getting stronger. This is called progressive overload. Once you can successfully complete all sets and reps for an exercise (e.g., 3 sets of 8 on Bench Press), you must add 5 pounds to the bar in your next session. This is the signal for growth.

Step 3: Stop Doing Hours of Useless Cardio

This is the second biggest mistake skinny fat people make. You cannot out-run a bad diet, and you will kill your muscle gains by doing too much cardio. Excessive cardio sends a competing signal to your body (an endurance signal, via AMPK activation) that interferes with the muscle-building signal from lifting (via mTOR activation). Your fat loss comes from the 200-300 calorie deficit in your diet, not from the treadmill. Limit cardio to two 30-minute sessions of low-intensity activity per week. This means walking on an incline or light cycling. It should feel easy. Its purpose is to improve cardiovascular health and burn a few extra calories without impacting your recovery and muscle growth.

Week 1 Will Feel Wrong, and That's the Point

You're used to extreme measures, so this balanced approach will feel strange at first. You won't be starving, and you won't be exhausted from workouts. This is by design. Consistency trumps intensity.

• Month 1 (Weeks 1-4): The scale will be your worst enemy. It might not move at all. It might even go up by 2-3 pounds. This is due to your muscles holding more water and glycogen, which is a good sign. Ignore the scale. Take photos at the start and at the end of week 4. You will notice your shoulders look a bit broader and your clothes fit slightly differently around your waist. Your strength in the gym will increase every week. This is your primary metric of success.
• Month 2 (Weeks 5-8): This is where the visual changes start to appear. The scale will begin a slow, steady decline of about 0.5 to 1 pound per week. You'll see more definition in your arms and chest. The 'softness' around your midsection will noticeably decrease. Someone might comment that you look like you're working out.
• Month 3 (Weeks 9-12): By now, the transformation is undeniable. You have visibly more muscle and less body fat. You've likely dropped 5-10 pounds of fat while gaining 3-5 pounds of muscle. You are no longer 'skinny fat.' You now have a solid foundation. From this point, you have earned the right to choose a new path. You can either enter a slight calorie surplus (a lean bulk) to maximize muscle gain or a slightly more aggressive deficit (a mini-cut) to reveal your abs. You've fixed the initial problem and can now train like a traditional lifter.

You read this far. You're serious.

Track food, workouts, and your purpose with Mofilo. Download today.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Body Fat Percentage to Switch to a Bulk

Once you've recomposed your body, you can transition to a traditional bulk. For men, this is when you are visibly lean, around 12-15% body fat. For women, this is around 20-23% body fat. At this point, your body is primed to add mass without excessive fat gain.

Handling Hunger on a Slight Deficit

If you feel excessively hungry on your 200-300 calorie deficit, do not lower your calories further. Instead, focus on food quality. Increase your intake of fibrous vegetables and ensure you are hitting your 1g/lb protein target. Protein and fiber are highly satiating and will keep you full.

The Role of Ab Exercises

You should train your abs directly 2-3 times per week. This builds the muscle, making it more visible once the fat layer is gone. Focus on weighted exercises like cable crunches or leg raises for 3 sets of 10-15 reps. Doing 100 crunches a day will not burn the fat off your stomach.

Adjusting Calories When Weight Stalls

If your weight and measurements have not changed for 2-3 consecutive weeks, you need to make one small adjustment. Either reduce your daily calorie intake by 100 calories or add one 20-minute session of low-intensity cardio. Only make one change at a time and see how your body responds for two weeks.